All This Has Happened Before

by: Natasha Chart

Wed Mar 18, 2009 at 02:00


I still haven't found my copy of Buckminster Fuller's Critical Path in the packing, but some helpful soul put the thing online. And while the little ditty I'm about to share with you contains a lot that I find socially problematic, this New Deal era folk tune conveys a widely appreciable sentiment. I've included Fuller's preface for context:

... There were a number of individual bankers who went far beyond unwise banking practices and who, as individuals, took personal advantage of the information they had of individual depositors' affairs and of their privilege as top bank officers to do truly inimical things to enrich their own positions. Few today remember that a half-century ago a number of New York and Chicago's top bankers were sentenced into penitentiaries-the New Yorkers into Sing Sing-the senior partner of J. P. Morgan and Company, the president of the National City Bank, the president of Chase Bank. Every one of them had been found to be doing reprehensible financial tricks. They were selling their own friends short. They were opening their friends' mail and manipulating the stock market. They were manipulating everybody. They were way overstepping the moral limits of the privileges ethically existent for officers in the banking game, so a great housecleaning was done by the New Deal.

The banking story is best told by a poem that was, at that time, allegedly composed by Ogden Nash but was never to my knowledge formally published and copyrighted. It was, however, memorized and widely recited from copies often typewritten by those who remembered it:

Natasha Chart :: All This Has Happened Before
"BUTCHER, BAKER, CANDLESTICK MAKER"

I'm an autocratic figure in these democratic states,
A dandy demonstration of hereditary traits.
As the children of the baker bake the most delicious breads,
As the sons of Casanova fill the most exclusive beds,
As the Barrymores and Roosevelts and others I could name
Inherited the talents that perpetuate their fame,
My position in the structure of society I owe
To the qualities my parents bequeathed me long ago.
My father was a gentleman and musical to boot.
He used to play piano in a house of ill repute.
The Madam was a lady and a credit to her cult,
She enjoyed my father's playing and I was the result.
So my Daddy and my Mummy are the ones I have to thank
That I'm Chairman of the Board of the National Silly Bank.

CHORUS:
  Oh, our parents forgot to get married.
  Our parents forgot to get wed.
  Did a wedding bell chime, it was always a time
  When our parents were somewhere in bed.
  Then all thanks to our kind loving parents.
  We are kings in the land of the free.
  Your banker, your broker, your Washington joker,
  Three prominent bastards are we, tra la,
  Three prominent bastards are we!

In a cozy little farmhouse in a cozy little dell
A dear old-fashioned farmer and his daughter used to dwell.
She was pretty, she was charming, she was tender, she was mild,
And her sympathy was such that she was frequently with child.
The year her hospitality attained a record high
She became a happy mother of an infant which was I.
Whenever she was gloomy, I could always make her grin,
By childishly inquiring who my daddy could have been.
The hired man was favored by the girls in Mummy's set,
And a traveling man from Scranton was an even money bet.
But such were Mother's motives and such was her allure,
That even Roger Babson wasn 't absolutely sure.
Well, I took my mother's morals and I took my daddy's crust,
And I grew to be the founder of the New York Blankers Trust.

CHORUS: Oh, our parents forgot, etc.

In a torrid penal chain gang on a dusty southern road
My late lamented daddy had his permanent abode.
Now some were therefor stealing, but my daddy's only fault
Was an overwhelming tendency for criminal assault.
His philosophy was simple and quite free from moral taint;
Seduction is for sissies, but a he-man wants his rape.
Daddy's total list of victims was embarrassingly rich,
And one of them was Mother, but he couldn't tell me which.
Well, I didn "t go to college but I got me a degree.
I reckon I'm the model of a perfect S.O.B.,
I'm a debit to my country but a credit to my Dad,
The most expensive senator the country ever had.
I remember Daddy's warning-that raping is a crime,
Unless you rape the voters, a million at a time.

CHORUS: Oh, our parents forgot, etc.

I'm an ordinary figure in these democratic states,
A pathetic demonstration of hereditary traits.
As the children of the cop possess the flattest kind of [feet],
As the daughter of the floozie has a waggle to her seat,
My position at the bottom of society I owe
To the qualities my parents bequeathed me long ago.
My father was a married man and, what is even more,
He was married to my mother-a fact which I deplore.
I was born in holy wedlock, consequently by and by,
I was rooked by every bastard who had plunder in his eye.
I invested, I deposited, I voted every fall,
And I saved up every penny and the bastards took it all.
At last I've learned my lesson, and I'm on the proper track,
I'm a self-appointed bastard and I'M GOING TO GET IT BACK.

CHORUS:
  Oh, our parents forgot to get married.
  Our parents forgot to get wed.
  Did a wedding bell chime, it was always a time
  When our parents were somewhere in bed.
  Then all thanks to our kind loving parents.
  We are kings in the land of the free.
  Your banker, your broker, your Washington joker,
  Three prominent bastards are we, tra la,
  Three prominent bastards are we!

See? Problematic. But even though our New Deal ancestors clearly had a few more tolerance and misogyny issues, they managed to get the whole frakking New Deal out of their government.

At that, mostly because FDR was worried like nobody's business that full blown socialism communism would result from popular anger. So thank goodness he caved, because that didn't turn out so well for Russia.

And the parallel examples of Britain and Russia in WWI would have been fresh at the time, with Britain responding to increasing labor agitation by meeting more of the unionists demands and getting more public cooperation in return. Russia responded by ignoring public anger over aristocratic excess in a time of privation until the country was taken out of the war by the overthrow of their government. Maybe FDR had this in mind when he decided that making peasant life easier was just good sense.

So let's hope we have as much mettle as the citizen organizers of the New Deal, and that Obama has as much common sense as Roosevelt. Turned out well the last time the bastards got this completely out of control.

Update: Apologies to commentors rightfully annoyed that I conflated Russia's totalitarian communism with the democratic socialism that prevails in countries like Canada, the UK, etc., countries that I think we'd do very well to imitate. That's what I get for posting when sleepy.

I personally favor a mixed economy. One where the government does things like healthcare, mass transit and primary education that seem to work best when nationalized. And then most industries operated privately, but with effective anti-monopoly enforcement to ensure that no handful of actors can unduly influence the market. Too big to fail is simply, imo, too big.


Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Enough with the bourgeois propaganda! (4.00 / 1)
At that, mostly because FDR was worried like nobody's business that full blown socialism would result from popular anger. So thank goodness he caved, because that didn't turn out so well for Russia.

It worked out very well for Cuba, thank you very much, and so far three or four generations of Cuban women have had a better choice than whoring for casinos, and three or four generations of Cuban men have had a better choice than thugging for Fulgencio Batista.


we need to follow this up with some action on Thursday (0.00 / 0)
We need to get out there Thursday and protest vehemently with signs calling for geithner and summers to be fired (http://takebacktheeconomy.org/). this outrage must be followed by action or else they will never respect/fear it. They'll just pat us on the head and tell us what a great country this is becoz we have the freedom of speech ... but have no effect on anything.

obama is doing his "I got everything under control" act ... acting like everyone is overreacting.  this is a ploy and test for us. they will continue acting like it is no big deal until we make it a big deal by getting out and being heard and being disruptive.  We need muscle behind this movement against these crooks ... that obama has apparently decided to ally himself with becoz they got big money.  We need some synergy and this is our opportunity.  So, I urge everyone to get out there on Thursday and demand change ... or otherwise we will not be taken seriously and continue to be marginalized. This is a very pivotal moment.

Z


Your insights into Americans then doing better at influencing FDR (4.00 / 6)
than Americans so far are doing at influencing BHO fit my view. And I agree that FDR prevented a "socialist" reformation of American capitalism. But when you take your view of "socialism" that you have ingested from your consumption of mainstream American media over the many years of your life you come to the perverse, in my view, conclusion that being saved from "socialism" was a good thing. And indeed that is what the MSM teaches.

The MSM teaches that both Russia and Sweden are "socialist." The MSM media is in the midst of a soft equation of Obama as "socialist." But were you to talk to a variety of people from FDR's time who called themselves socialist, and you showed them the Soviet Union and Sweden and Obama, they would be very confused by your notion of "socialism." Obama has not shown any socialist tendencies. Sweden is very much a capitalist country. And even the ones who supported the Soviet Union, would be hard pressed to defend the notion that the Soviet Union had achieved any sort of "classical" socialist economic system as they understood the word, neither then nor especially with and after Stalin. In the sixties the term "state capitalist" was commonly used to describe the Soviet Union.

Since there are so many progressives that appreciate a definition of socialism that is more accurate than the one that "common wisdom" and MSM use, it behooves you to quit using the word at all. At least until your sense of the word broadens. imho.

Jeff Wegerson


I am a Tommy Douglas Socialist. (4.00 / 8)
I am a member of the New Democratic Party in Canada. I have dual citizenship, my grandfather was a paid speachmaker for the federal and state Democratic Parties.

I am very proud of all the things socialists have brought to Canada, including the Right to Healthcare, old age pensions  and union rights. A long history of lies have followed this party, most of them about the fact that we are "socialists, just like Stalin."  They called us "Jew baby killers". We believe that democracy can be extended to make the economy responsive to the people it contains. Decades and decades of good governments, good balanced budgets, people centred policies and a strong commitment to making our society run for the benefit of all of us should protect us from such crap.

Tommy Douglas is the Greatest Canadian ever according to the Canadian people, and I resent like hell being grouped with Stalin and police states. I most hate it when its done by people I respect, by people in my community.

Socialists have been making life good for societies all across the globe for generations. Look at the numbers of socialists in Hitlers death camps. Look for the socialists on the front lines fighting back against betrayal of the communists and the military coup by fascist Francoists in Spain.

People have been using that lie to stomp progressive unions, progressive candidates and progressive policy for too long. Just stop.



Change
"We must break up the banks and never again let them get so big that they distort our politics and take down the economy.







Donate to Open Left




blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
USER MENU

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search