Fair Trade Dems to White House: Listen & Change, Or Watch NAFTA-Style Deals Die

by: David Sirota

Fri May 15, 2009 at 08:00


Roll Call has an update in the increasingly intense war of words between rank-and-file Democrats in Congress who ran and won promising fair trade reform, and White House officials who may force Congress to vote on the Bush-negotiated, NAFTA-style Panama Free Trade Agreement:

An increasingly agitated faction of Democrats is warning party leaders of ugly economic and political consequences if they try to move the Panama agreement.

Not only will it hurt the economy, critics say, but action on a Bush-negotiated trade deal endangers freshman Democrats in 2010 since many ran on a trade reform agenda. In addition, critics say, it doesn't bode well for Obama to anger a bloc of Democrats early on when he needs their support for his ambitious domestic agenda.

"I'm getting really pissed off," said House Rules Chairwoman Louise Slaughter (D)...

Rep. Mike Michaud (D-Maine), co- chairman of the House Trade Working Group, singled out House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D-Md.) in his criticism of his party leaders' desire to advance the Panama deal.

"As a Democratic leader, I don't think it's helpful to vulnerable Members to ask them to support a Bush-negotiated trade deal," Michaud said. "As a Democratic leader, [Hoyer] should not be encouraging the White House to move forward on this."

Panama itself "is not a big deal," said one aide to a House Democrat opposed to the agreement. "It's an opportunity to re-evaluate our cookie-cutter trade deals and then use that as a framework...Panama sets the course for what future agreements look like."

To ratchet up pressure, some of the most senior fair traders in the Democratic caucus are threatening to use their positions to block the trade pact from moving through the House. Specifically, "Rep. Marcy Kaptur (D-Ohio), one of the Members who attended the USTR meeting, said Slaughter repeatedly reminded USTR officials that she chairs the powerful Rules Committee" and that Slaughter "made it very clear that she didn't intend to move any of those bills."

This is what the Make Him Do It Dynamic looks like in legislative practice - fair traders using their leverage to pass and stop bills in Congress to force the White House to respect President Obama's campaign promises. In this case, the administration is being forced to slowly but surely acknowledge - and potentially champion - fair traders' demands for major trade policy reforms, with the Panama trade deal serving as the first vehicle for such changes. As I noted before, such change moves at a glacial pace, but it is moving.

David Sirota :: Fair Trade Dems to White House: Listen & Change, Or Watch NAFTA-Style Deals Die

Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
At least SOMEONE (4.00 / 5)
is showing some backbone - even if for purely political reasons and not because the Panama deal is so bad on so many levels. But I'll take that so long as these Dems stick to their opposition.

"At a glacial pace" (4.00 / 1)
As I noted before, such change moves at a glacial pace, but it is moving.

Progressive reform is moving "at a glacial pace," but lots of others entities aren't... for example glaciers aren't moving "at a glacial pace" any more. Glaciers are melting away like fucking jack-rabbits, while the Progressive Caucus moves its agenda along "at a glacial pace," and Obama's ludicrously weak climate legislation likewise.

So maybe it's time to dream up a new cliche to replace "at a glacial pace," because glaciers will probably disappear before any effective climate legislation is passed by Obama and the Democratic Congress.

My suggestion for a replacement would be "at a Progressive pace," because the Progressive agenda is now the slowest moving thing in the Universe (if it's moving at all).


While I understand your position and don't disagree... (4.00 / 1)
...political reality is what it is, and we are not entirely blameless in the causes.

As I said in another thread:

Look at the US Senate and tell me who our "allies" are, can you count them on one hand? two? You surely don't need to take off your socks.

As tee'd up as some of our good progressives in the House can get, they know as well as I do, as well as most analysts do, that their actions will fall flat in the Senate.

On one hand, I applaud and encourage the leadership as demonstrated here, and urge them to pass real progressive legislation and force the Senate to squash it, let the people see them obstructing change.  Let them explain why they disagree with the strong progressive leaders of the House.

On the other hand, I sympathize with those who have repeatedly been beaten down and see no changes in the landscape, it is hard to keep pushing forward when you know you are going to get knocked back with a Louisville Slugger.

Reality shows us that the Blue Dogs have a disproportionate amount of power in legislating and Harry Reid actively repels progressive action in a Senate where it is hard to find any such action anyway.

Change will only come when we tilt the Democratic caucus in the Senate leftward.


[ Parent ]
Meanwhile... (4.00 / 1)
Bolivia's 18,000 year-old Chacaltaya glacier is gone.

If anyone needs a reminder of the on-the-ground impacts of global climate change, come to the Andes mountains in Bolivia. At 17,388 feet above sea level, Chacaltaya, an 18,000 year-old glacier that delighted thousands of visitors for decades, is gone, completely melted away as of some sad, undetermined moment early this year....


[ Parent ]
So let the House be the vehicle of change. (0.00 / 0)
Since the Senate is so unreliable, and bills must pass both houses of Congress, let progressive Democrats (there are enough of them, albeit a minority against the Republicans and Bush Dog Dems) do exactly what Sirota suggests they are doing: block bad bills using their positions of power, and force passage of good legislation.  Now is not the time for baby steps.  Indeed, there never was such a time.  We need bold, drastic action to address the short-and long-term crises facing our nation and our world.

Believe me, if the Republicans can get their policies implemented in spite of being in the minority, progressives Democrats can too.



[ Parent ]
God Bless Louise Slaughter (4.00 / 4)
She's got more brains, guts and integrity in her little finger than Barack Obama ever dreamed of.

"Senate passes expanded GI bill despite Bush, McCain opposition"

Carpe diem! (0.00 / 0)
Let me seize this opportunity to totally agree with Paul Rosenberg!

Who knows when such a thing will occur again?

Photobucket


[ Parent ]
Christ, we still have at 10 jobs they can still offshore. (4.00 / 2)
KMart is now offshoring all of its IT to India and then there is this.US offshores 22,000 green jobs to India

Obama promised to renegotiate NAFTA.  I'm still waiting for him to deliver on that.  People are not going to sit back and let these idiots give away their jobs and their children's futures.  Sooner or later, Democrats will pay.  This country need radical changes in policy direction including single payer, a real energy policy, a real industrial policy, and a real economy.  Enough of this WS/banking bull shit.  

They're asking for another four years -- in a just world, they'd get 10 to 20. ~~ Dennis Kucinich  


thanks Sirota for writing on this so much (0.00 / 0)
The fact that Dem. leadership plus Obama is pushing that NAFTA style trade deal and blowing off any rhetoric that people believed (I never believed it because I read the actual policies) he would reform trade....

well, to confront this requires a lot at the facts and not partisanship.  

I sure hope all of those new Dems grow a pair and a spine because that's what America voted for, not more of the same.


NoSlaves.com  


The Economic Populist


No, it requires partisanship. (0.00 / 0)
What we've been forced to endure for nearly thirty years now is bipartisanship, that is, Democrats joining with Republicans to systematically dismantle both the New Deal and Progressive Era reforms.  That is NOT the bipartisanship we need.  No, in order to finally defeat the far right, we have to make Democrats fight it, tooth and claw.



[ Parent ]
Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search