Running Dry--A Filmmaker's Systemic View Of Water Stewardship

by: Paul Rosenberg

Sun May 24, 2009 at 15:00


This diary is related to my diary from yesterday, "Remember That Swine Flu Panic?" It, too, is from the current issue of Random Lengths News, but more significantly, it's also about seeing a problem--in this case a large and growing gap between water needs and availability--in an interconnected systemic fashion.  It's a brief review and discussion of the documentary, " The American Southwest: Are We Running Dry?", by Jim Thebaut.  Read it on the flip.

Paul Rosenberg :: Running Dry--A Filmmaker's Systemic View Of Water Stewardship
Prophetic Filmmaker Shines Light On Southwest Water Plight
By Paul Rosenberg, Senior Editor

"Everyone takes water for granted," filmmaker Jim Thebaut said.  "I don't think that the average citizen begins to realize how fragile the system is."  

Maybe not.  But just a few minutes of his latest documentary, The American Southwest: Are We Running Dry? is enough to change all that. Thebaut is not just a documentary film-maker, he's also a man on a mission: ensuring that "all people... have access to safe, affordable and sustainable drinking water and adequate sanitation" in a world where 1.2 billion people live where water security is imperiled, and trends are only growing worse. On Thursday, May 7, that mission brought him to the Aquarium of the Pacific in Long Beach for a special screening of his followup to his 2005 documentary, Running Dry, which had a global focus.

"Even though people appreciated the message, there was a disconnect between the world and what's happening here in the US," Thebault told Random Lengths, when asked how he came to make the followup. "When I say that a child dies every 15 seconds they say, well that's over there.  I did it [the Southwest film] to bring the issue home," he explained.  And that meant covering everything from the extravagant desert water fantasies of Las Vegas hotels and Palm Springs golf courses to the Third World conditions of Navajo and Hopi communities where 80,000 people lack basic running water.

The screening was followed with a panel discussion featuring Thebault with two local water officials, Tim Brick, Chair of the Board of the Metropoliticn Water District, who also appeared in the documentary, and Kevin Wattier, General Manager of the Long Beach Water Department.  

While the threat of global warming and the Southwest's particular vulnerability clearly loom in the background (see "The Fire This Time and Next", RLN, November 02, 2007, for the prospective recurrence of Medieval megadroughts), the film, narrated by actress Jane Seymour, avoids focusing on global warming, going out of its way to include a balance of Democratic and Republican senators and representatives-as well as Dr. Gene Whitney, science advisor to President Bush, along with a range of local and regional water officials.  It's enough to simply focus on existing shortages, inadequate infrastructure (such as 100-year-old levees in the Sacramento/San Joaquin Delta), projected massive population growth, and the undisputed fact that the Colorado River compact-the backbone of regional water distribution-was based on what we now know to have been an exceptionally wet period of time.  Put them all together and the need for urgent and comprehensive action emerges organically from the film.

While the film derives most of its power from the gradual weaving together of hard facts and human testimony, there are some stunners that stand out, perhaps most notably the warning that Lake Mead might not be there in its present form in 20 years.  "We might have to go on rationing, or not have any water at all," Thebault warns, pointing out that the CIA has cited this as a potential national security threat.  Another stunner is the vast difference in water consumption levels between the US and other industrial nations.

In the followup discussion, Wattier revealed a silver lining to that disturbing fact-by cutting back through a number of coordinated strategies, Long Beach has dramatically reduced its per-capita water consumption, back to levels not seen since 1945.  While Long Beach has proven that dramatic efficiency gains are possible, the sheer magnitude of regional population growth-increasing sprawl, and burdening more fragile ecosystems-makes a strong case for the need for a comprehensive water and land-use policy transcending traditional political boundaries.

"We need to plan on a watershed level.  Water transcends political boundaries."  Thebault said.  This is clearly evident in the way his latest documentary revolves around the Colorado, with side-discussions of the Rio Grande and the Sacramento/San Joaquin river system.

Thebault has little patience for traditional states-rights arguments, given how water systems work.  But he's not for running roughshod over anyone.  "It [water/land use policy] should be implemented on a national and a regional level.  The Southeast has their own set of issues. The Midwest especially faces depletion of aquifers," he points out.

"Every region has its own unique issues."

Watch the trailer here.


Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
you know what I hate? (0.00 / 0)
Lawns. Just think of how much water lawns consume. Think of how much suburban land is taken up by lawns - they are huge contributors to sprawl. As far as I know, lawns are pretty much just an American phenomenon; and like so many distinctly American phenomena, they are wasteful, inane, and crude simulacra (of nature, in this case).

But such is our commitment to lawns that even in the Southwest, where I'm from, many houses have grass lawns. Absurd! And where they don't have grass lawns, they have lawns made of rocks, which are environmentally better, I guess, but aesthetically stupid - as if we just can't give up the idea that a house isn't a home unless it's isolated on a little island of useless and aesthetically misguided landscaping.

Down with lawns!


Long Beach Is Working Actively To Replace Lawns (0.00 / 0)
Maybe they're defensible in a few limited climates with abundant rainfall, but they sure as shootin' don't belong in our semi-arid Mediterranean climate.  Here there's a positive emphasis on promoting drought-tolerant native plant gardening, and its part of broader shift of public values that's really encouraging.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
They're not lawns, they're victory gardens! (4.00 / 4)
That have been laying fallow for six decades.

Having some gardening space might come in handy in one decade more!


[ Parent ]
It's insane that Americans have spent the last twenty years (4.00 / 1)
vacating temperate climates with abundant rainfall and farmland and building on deserts that were never really going to be able to support tens of millions of people.  

Heating, also, is more energy efficient than cooling is.  People need to stop moving to the desert.


talk about your trends with a short shelf life (0.00 / 0)
The southwestern megalopoli are the epitome of unsustainability. And looking at Las Vegas and Phoenix after the mortgage crisis, the exodus out of the desert may have already begun.

[ Parent ]
Paul, I have a problem (0.00 / 0)
I can comment using Explorer, but cannot using Firefox.  Does Firefox not work with OpenLeft?  I don't have problem with other sites.  Is there a way to fix this?

Thanks for any info.  Sorry to intrude off-topic, delete this if you wish, but I don't know how to get through otherwise.  You can e-mail me back at andreamajor@comcast.net if you wish.

Full Court Press!  http://www.openleft.com/showDi...


are you logging in ok? is your username being displayed while in firefox? (0.00 / 0)
I use firefox 3 and it works just fine

[ Parent ]
log-in is fine (0.00 / 0)
... but I have no comment/reply link, get "can't open page" when I try to add diary or do quick hit.  Used to be, when I'd re-open OpenLeft, I was logged in.  Now I have to re-log-in, not that doing so does me any good.

Full Court Press!  http://www.openleft.com/showDi...

[ Parent ]
re (0.00 / 0)
Used to be, when I'd re-open OpenLeft, I was logged in.  Now I have to re-log-in

could the problem be cookies?

I had the same 'web-site doesn't remember me' problem and by enabling cookies for that website did it.


[ Parent ]
exactamundo !!! (0.00 / 0)
I was beginning to suspect, but you hit it on the head.  So what I did was go into my cookie list on Firefox, found the ones for OpenLeft, and deleted them ALL.

Then I logged in, closed Firefox, went back in, all was fine.

Thanks!

Full Court Press!  http://www.openleft.com/showDi...


[ Parent ]
nice! (0.00 / 0)
glad I could help

[ Parent ]
I Use Firefox All The Time (0.00 / 0)
But it's certainly possible it won't work on some machines.  I've had those sorts of problems with other sites on the computers at work, so I know those sorts of problems are out there.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
the problem is ... (0.00 / 0)
... that Firefox is about a zillion times faster.

Full Court Press!  http://www.openleft.com/showDi...

[ Parent ]
Water shortages (0.00 / 0)
and rising sea levels -- I realize that desalinization is expensive but is it just me or is it not obvious that we've got to invest seriously in desalinization projects to mitigate the water problems?

Also, the overpopulation issue in areas where water has always been an issue seems like something that has to be addressed by zoning laws or something to stop the sprawl.  Why isn't this happening?  People can't keep moving to places that don't have enough water, never have, and probably never will.  It's crazy.  And, BTW, I always thought Las Vegas was crazy, but when the area started growing exponentially, it became even more insane.

I know this sounds cold and simplistic, but I think we're putting too much focus on bringing more water into these areas, and too little focus on not overpopulating them.  Humans have always settled in areas that have the resources to sustain them.  Why are we trying to create oases in deserts?  Nature always wins.


Desalinization Is Part of The Answer (0.00 / 0)
But it's expensive.  It's now price-competitive in Southern California with water from the Sacramento/San Joaquin delta, but there are also limitations on where the plants can be located.  All together, estimate range from 2-10% of SoCal water needs could be met from desalination.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
Some CA 'news'papers bad on local news, even the water shortage (0.00 / 0)
Alexander Cockburn writes at Chronicles Magazine:

South of me in Mendocino County, Calif., is the Anderson Valley Advertiser, a weekly edited by my friend Bruce Anderson. I've written a column for it for over 20 years. The AVA does everything a newspaper should do. It covers the county board of supervisors, the court system, the cops, water issues, the marijuana industry. It's fun to read and reminds people of what a real newspaper should be, which is why half its circulation is outside the county, often the other end of the United States.

I asked Bruce about proposed bailouts of the mainstream press: "Do you like these bailout ideas?" "No, I don't. I don't even want them to rest in peace. I want them to twist and turn in their graves eternally. Why? They don't do any local reporting and haven't for about 25 years. I'm talking here about the Santa Rosa Press Democrat, owned by the New York Times Company, and the San Francisco Chronicle.

"With the drought upon us here on North Coast, the Press Democrat has yet to run a coherent account of how precarious our water supplies and delivery systems are. Why? They might get objections from the building industry and the wine industry on which they're almost totally dependent for advertising these days.



435 Dem Primaries 2012
Coffee Party Usa
TheRealNews.Com


USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox