OPEN LEFT EXCLUSIVE: PEOPLE OF DIFFERENT GENDERS AND ETHNICITIES VOTE DIFFERENTLY!!!!!

by: Chris Bowers

Wed May 27, 2009 at 12:15


BREAKING!!!! OPEN LEFT EXCLUSIVE!!!! MUST CREDIT OPEN LEFT!!!!

Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor has controversially claimed that non-white dudes might judge differently than white dudes in sexual and racial discrimination cases. Supposedly, this is because people see the world differently based on their different experiences, or something. Now, newly unearthed data shockingly suggests that this offesnive and outlandish claim might actually have some validity.

The first tip came when Chris Bowers, Open Left's Director of Perpetually Gazing at Exit Polls, discovered the following chart buried at the top of the first page of the rarely viewed 2008 national exit poll. It shows that people with different genders and ethnicities had a tendency to vote--brace yourself--differently from each other:


Holy demographic revelation Batman--people with different genders and races saw the world differently enough that they ended up voting differently than each other! Even more shockingly, according to a rarely known polling outfit called Pew, it appears that people with different ethnicities perceive differing levels of racism in the country:


I checked to se if the Pew poll was a fluke, but it turns out that 1,764 other polls confirm that white people believe there is less racism in American than black people.

So, it appears that people with different genders and ethnicities do actually view the world differently, including different views on the prevalence of gender and racial discrimination in America.

There is no word as of this writing on whether or not civilization can survive this earth-shattering revelation. However, Chris Bowers, Senior Apocalypse Preparation Director for Openleft.com, has told me that he is stocking up on canned goods--especially the lentil soups he really enjoys. Mmmmm.... lentils.

Chris Bowers :: OPEN LEFT EXCLUSIVE: PEOPLE OF DIFFERENT GENDERS AND ETHNICITIES VOTE DIFFERENTLY!!!!!

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Um... (4.00 / 4)
Is your comment snark?

[ Parent ]
well is this comment snark? (4.00 / 2)
no wait, that doesn't make any sense.

[ Parent ]
I completely agree 100%!!!!!! (0.00 / 0)
Lentils are delicious.

miasmo.com

Chris Bowers is white, I presume (4.00 / 2)
And as a non-white person of a different ethnicity, I must vote differently on the issue of lentil soups being delicious.

Things You Don't Talk About in Polite Company: Religion, Politics, the Occasional Intersection of Both

Chris, Chris, Chris... (4.00 / 7)
You're going about this all wrong. Of course people vote differently based on their race and their experience - but only if they aren't white males!

The thing is, the white male experience is normal. It's like a baseline; it's the sort of experience you would have if you were to be born into a cultural vacuum. But if you're a woman or a person of color, then your experience is altered by your gender or race. It makes you different, peripheral - abnormal.

Now I ask you: do we want to have a Supreme Court that makes decisions based on normality? Or based on abnormality?

Q.E.D.


Hmmm (0.00 / 0)
As blasphemous as your ideas seem to me, you might be onto something.

Anyway, I still vote for the Terminator to be on the Supreme Court. It doesn't feel pain or remorse. It will keep making judicial rulings. That is all it does!


[ Parent ]
wonderful (0.00 / 0)
Shades of the old Wonkette back when Ana Marie still ran the joint. OMG NEWS FLASH!!!

Chris do you have any further breakdown of the latino vote? (0.00 / 0)
How much of the 30+% going McCain was influenced by religion versus geography or localized culture/influence?  How much of it was marginalized by landslide victories in the electoral college one way or the other?

To me, losing 30+% of the Latino vote to McCain/Palin is pretty disappointing.


There are some details (4.00 / 1)
Age breakdowns show middle-aged Latinos as more pro-Republican than other groups. Also, Cuban Americans, especially those in Florida, are typically more Republican than other Latinos.

It is a big and diverse community (really, communities). NNDN has done a lot of polling on this. I'd look to them for more info:

http://ndn.org/programs/hispan...  


[ Parent ]
More please (4.00 / 4)
I find the ideas of this "Senior Apocalypse Preparation Director" intriguing, and I'd like to subscribe to his newsletter.

Me | My Work | Future Majority

Several points you didn't mention (4.00 / 1)
1)How important race and gender are relative to other factors in the decision-making process

2)Whether these patterns are because of intrinsic differences, or because of manipulation by political campaigns, etc., and

3)Whether this trend is as relevant as it was 20 years ago, 30 years ago, 40, etc.


Lest we forget (0.00 / 0)
There was a time not so long ago when race was paramount.  Why?  Black people in some locales were not allowed to vote.  Many of these same locales were discouraging voting period.  There was one party and voting, at least in the off-years was anemic.

Not only were blacks disenfranchised but whites in many states didn't vote much either.  The Hispanic vote in some south Texas counties, while allowed, was suspiciously monolithic depending on the alliances of anglo political bosses.

In South Carolina, for example, the state had a contested general election for Governor just once between contested elections in 1914 and 1966.  The Republican candidate for Governor got 283 votes in 1938.  For the whole state. Thirteen elections for Governor in this period were officially unopposed. The earliest national vote totals for the House are from 1942, well into Jim Crow. Northern (i.e. non-Southern House districts averaged 82,335 votes, southern ditricts averaged 17,824 votes, South Carolina averaged 3,893 votes per Congressional district.

It is a darned good thing that we have different opinions and different voices contributing to our democracy.  E pluribus unum.  Out of many, one.  Not one voice or one race but one nation.


[ Parent ]
I agree (0.00 / 0)
and its good to see some diversity on the Supreme Court. I just think that race is a declining factor, that identity politics in general have a tendency to go "sideways" in a direction that is not productive, and I think that liberals are stuck in a rut right now in a seeming inability to view the world from a paradigm that doesn't break everyone down into a lab specimen.

I'm trying to pop us out of that rut. There really are more things that connect than divide us, and that's the direction I believe the zeitgeist is headed.

BTW: you mentioned South Texas counties, are you from that area?


[ Parent ]
Voting by skin color? (0.00 / 1)
I found the aritcle and it's graphs very interesting. I try to vote for people based on their track record and what they believe is important. Free Auto Insurance Quotes

Property in Brazil

Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search