Honduran Coup A Moment Of Truth--For U.S. As Much As Honduras

by: Paul Rosenberg

Sun Jun 28, 2009 at 21:10


As noted in quick hits, first by Paul Goodman, then by Xcroc, there's been a coup in Honduras, ousting President Manuel Zelaya, who was elected in November 2005.  It's being blogged intensively by Eva Golinger Venezuela, a Venezuelan-American attorney, writer and investigator, author of The Chávez Code: Cracking US Intervention in Venezuela and Bush vs. Chávez: Washington's War on Venezuela, at her blog Postcards from the Revolution.

Arguably the most significant news so far--aside from the fact of the coup itself, and the fact that President  is still alive, is the news that the OAS has condemned the coup.  Her diary about this puts it in proper historical context, contrasting it with the strikingly similar coup in Haiti in 2004:

UPDATE 6:54PM OAS HAS JUST CONDEMNED COUP IN HONDURAS, CALLS FOR ZELAYA'S REINSTATEMENT
In a major blow to the coup leaders in Honduras who just illegally installed themselves in power, the Organization of American States (OAS) has just issued a resolution condemning the coup against President Zelaya, demanding the return of Zelaya to power immediately and clarifying that the OAS will not recognize any other government other than Zelaya's in Honduras. Whew! For a minute there I thought this was going to turn out like Haiti in 2004 when coup forces kidnapped President Aristide and forced him into exile and, while the OAS "condemned" the constitutional rupture, they never called for Aristide's reinstatement, and since the US backed the coup, an illegal transitional government was installed and nothing more came of it from the international community.

This time, things seem different. Still waiting on the US Government's official position...If they say they will not recognize the coup government, then we have to see how things will play out in Honduras.

Other posts from her throughout the day make it clear that the Obama Administration has been typically vague, and still has not made its position clear.  In her most recent post, she said:

Since the Obama Administration has stated the coup situation in Honduras should be resolved via the OAS, and the OAS has just condemned the coup and called for the unconditional restoration of President Zelaya to power, that should also imply that the US Government shares the same position.
Paul Rosenberg :: Honduran Coup A Moment Of Truth--For U.S. As Much As Honduras
America's history of intervention in Latin America goes back over 150 years.  There are some good timelines tracking them with different types of information here and
here.  Honduras first suffered military intervention in 1905, followed by four more interventions in the next two decades.

Here's what happened in Central America alone in just six years a century ago:

1905: U.S. troops land in Honduras for the first of 5 times in next 20 years.

1907: Marines intervene in Honduras to settle a war with Nicaragua.

1908: U.S. troops intervene in Panama for first of 4 times in next decade.

1909: Liberal President José Santos Zelaya of Nicaragua proposes that American mining and banana companies pay taxes; he has also appropriated church lands and legalized divorce, done business with European firms, and executed two Americans for participating in a rebellion. Forced to resign through U.S. pressure. The new president, Adolfo Díaz, is the former treasurer of an American mining company.

1910: U.S. Marines occupy Nicaragua to help support the Díaz regime.

1911: The Liberal regime of Miguel Dávila in Honduras has irked the State Department by being too friendly with Zelaya and by getting into debt with Britain. He is overthrown by former president Manuel Bonilla, aided by American banana tycoon Sam Zemurray and American mercenary Lee Christmas, who becomes commander-in-chief of the Honduran army.

Because of this long history, about which most of us know nothing, but which is quite well known in Latin America, what Obama does in the next 24 hours will be crucial to how he is seen throughout the region. Will his his fresh rhetoric be matched by deeds?  Or will it be just more of the same old same old?


Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
more information on what happened (4.00 / 1)
Thank you for posting this information!  I have two more links I'll submit that provide some further information for readers here:

School of the Americas-Trained Military Detains and Expels Democratically-Elected President Zelaya
Zelaya told TeleSUR that he doesn't believe it was regular soldiers who kidnapped him.  "I have been the victim of a kidnapping carried out by a group of Honduran soldiers.  I don't think the Army is supporting this sort of action.  I think this is a vicious plot planned by elites.  Elite who only want to keep the country isolated and in extreme poverty."

Zelaya fears for the safety of his family, who remains in Honduras.  He pleaded with TeleSUR viewers to seek a way to "have a dialogue with these soldiers so that they don't harm my family, so that they don't shoot anybody.  We can settle our differences through dialogue."

The anti-Zelaya President of Congress, Roberto Micheletti, has declared himself interim president of Honduras.
...
The crisis in Honduras began when the military refused to distribute ballot boxes for the opinion poll in a new Constitution. President Zelaya fired the head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Romeo Orlando Vasquez Velasquez, who refused to step down. The heads of all branches of the Honduran armed forces quit in solidarity with Vasquez. Vasquez, however, refused to step down, bolstered by support in Congress and a Supreme Court ruling that reinstated him. Vasquez remains in control of the armed forces.

Vasquez, along with other military leaders, graduated from the United States' infamous School of the Americas (SOA). According to a School of the Americas Watch database compiled from information obtained from the US government, Vasquez studied in the SOA at least twice: once in 1976 and again in 1984.

The head of the Air Force, Gen. Luis Javier Prince Suazo, studied in the School of the Americas in 1996. The Air Force has been a central protagonist in the Honduran crisis. When the military refused to distribute the ballot boxes for the opinion poll, the ballot boxes were stored on an Air Force base until citizens accompanied by Zelaya rescued them. Zelaya reports that after soldiers kidnapped him, they took him to an Air Force base, where he was put on a plane and sent to Costa Rica.

There is a great deal more information at this link.

And from Rights Action ALERT - Military Coup in Honduras

On the Day of the National Survey for Constitutional Reform, the Honduran President Was Captured by the Military
...
The military is occupying the entire county, and has established checkpoints in the entry and exits of towns, presumably to restrict protesters and possibly to facilitate detentions.
Despite the military occupation there are protests throughout the country and repression is being report.
We are extremely concerned for the safety of the human rights organizations that have supported the President and the efforts for Constitutional Reform.
...
The proposal to draft a new constitution is the culmination of a series of controversial measures undertaken in his presidency, which include a significant raise in the minimum wage, measures to re- nationalize energy generation plants and the telephone system, signing a bill that vastly improves labor conditions for teachers, joining the Venezuelan Petrocaribe program which provides soft loans for development initiatives via petroleum sales, delaying recognition of the new US ambassador after the Bolivian government implicated the US embassy in supporting fascist paramilitary groups destabilizing Bolivia, and others.


Looking back at the run up to the coup: bogus stories of Venezuelan invasion! (0.00 / 0)
The fascists tried to smear Zeyala with charges that he was a Chavezian stooge.

After a years-long propaganda campaign by Honduran right wing media, the ground was set for the coup to gin up phony charges of Venezuelan "meddling". They had the plan ready to go, they were just waiting for Zeyala to give them a plausible pretext, which he did by promoting Constitutional reform (the gall!).

This has all the hallmarks of our Shadow Government's tutelage.

If we can fingerprint who was spreading the mis-info on the Venezuelan invasion in the US we can get an insight into the operational infrastructure of this and other pending coups. Enterprising folk could check the usual outlets, but also various websites "trolls" and "lurkers" to see who and what they are foot soldiering for. (e.g. DKos was crawling with fascist apologists the last couple days, is that normal?)

Can Obama have passion for something besides his image?

Afterword:
I served next to a contingent of Honduran soldiers in Iraq, they are pretty grizzly mf'ers, they liked to fire off random sniper shots into the cities at night. Their favorite targets were minaret lights. Not a humane organization.


If I could float a hypotehsis: Twitter War (4.00 / 1)
I have been checking various internet outlets, and the earliest most vociferous posters have been largely marching in lockstep "message discipline" for the coup.

The hypothesis: the fascists worldwide have seen the power of the new media, and are engaging in battle to subvert it as they did the old.

They are learning quick, too many of us are flatfooted.

Notice how they chose the media black out of the weekend to do the deed.

The average insular American won't know what happened until there is a fait accompli.

I hate to say it, but Obama's dithering style has emboldened the enemies of 1789 and I'm sure our Shadow Government has more up it's sleeve for him over the next 3 1/2 years.

3 AM. ring-ring.


3 am fail (0.00 / 0)
god you people are hilarious.

[ Parent ]
Maybe. But then, you're a troll. (0.00 / 0)
Just looked at your past "contributions", to get an understanding of your political stance, and I have to say that I didn't find anything that really advanced discussions here:
http://www.openleft.com/user/L...
Comments like "Markos is the new Hitler" certainly is not the kind of discourse the majority of OpenLefters is interested in. Imho you're sitting in a glass house and shouldn't accuse other peple of being hilarious. You're the biggest joke of all!

[ Parent ]
premature outrage fail? (0.00 / 0)
nah, never at openleft...

http://www.dailykos.com/story/...

that can't be true.  the great orange satan is clearly a tool of the fascists.


"a tool of the fascists"? Uh, where is the evidence? (0.00 / 0)
Come on, I'm really the last to abstain from criticizing the big Orange Satan, which imho is too much of a nuthouse populated by firebrand populists who don't have a grip of even the most basic facts. But the example you cite sure looks like a rather restrained, some may even say thoughtful opinion piece.

Excuse me pls, but a are you joking and I missed the irony???


[ Parent ]
Looking at your other comments, I understand you tried to be ironic (0.00 / 0)
Sry for missing that initially (I have to admit I'm a bit "irony handicapped" because English isn't my native language). But imho putting oil into the flames, instead of arguing with facts, maybe isn't the best way to advance the discussion here...

[ Parent ]
Texas, maybe California (4.00 / 1)
US involvement in Texas clearly predated the Mexican War.  It was US settlers in Texas who were the driving force for the independence movement and who provided most of the manpower at both the Alamo and San Jacinto.  In fact, Americans came from outside Texas to help (Davey Crockett was by no means alone at the Alamo, he came with a contingent of Tennesseeans).  Both Stephen F. Austin and Sam Houston were Americans.  Sam Houston has the unique distinction of serving as Governor of Tennesee, President of the Texas Republic, and Governor of the state of Texas.

Yes, US settlers wanted more rights for themselves but one of their major gripes with the Mexican constitution was that it forbade slavery.

American workers for Sutter found the gold and Americans not only took away the gold but his nice land holdings as well.  Americans on the spot aided and abetted the invasion of California and IIRC established their own "Bear Flag Republic" in California.  The Bear Flag is the familiar state flag of California and IIRC was painted rather than sewn.  Got to be quick.

I think there were many pre-Civil War instigations about Cuba, some at high levels.  Cuba was seen as a logical extension of the US by pro-slavery supporters.  In fact the islands and central America made a lot more sense than places like Kansas to extend a slave based plantation economy.  


Mexicans Hated Our Freedsoms--To Own Slaves, And Steal Their Lands! (4.00 / 1)
Plus, they had WMDs.  I'm sure of it!

And mustaches, just like Hitler!

(Who hadn't even been born yet, just to show you how devious they were!)

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


[ Parent ]
Good stories at Time, and at a Honduras web weekly (0.00 / 0)
I have to say I'm suprised by the good round up that Time produced:

In the end, though, it was Zelaya's opponents who appear to have become unhinged. Technically, before Sunday anyway, Honduras' justices and generals could claim they held the legal high ground: Zelaya was, after all, blatantly defying a high court ruling, as well as his legislature and attorney general. He was, they could argue, behaving like the populist caudillo his opponents warned he wanted to be. But their violent Sunday morning response has now made them look like the Latin oligarch lackeys of old - and has in fact only lent credence to Zelaya's suggestion that they were indeed just defending a constitution fashioned exclusively for the haves of Honduras.

http://www.time.com/time/world...

And this story at Honduras This Week is a well of informations about the "fourth ballot" issue that led to Zelayas fight with Congress and eventually the verdict by the Supreme Court of Honduras that was used as an alibi for the coup:

On June 22, the Honduran Congress ruled that a referendum could not be held 180 days before or after a General Election, effectively outlawing the vote scheduled to take place on June 28. Despite this, the President has appeared determined to go ahead with the referendum.
...
Public outcry over the fourth box has escalated in recent days, with the announcement that General Romeo Vasquez, commander-in-chief of the armed forces, had been dismissed by the President following his refusal to provide logistical support for a referendum deemed by Congress to be unlawful. The heads of the army, navy and air force later resigned in support of Vasquez. Defense Minister Eduardo Orellana has also resigned.

Congress has ordered that General Vasquez be reinstated.

In a show of support for President Zelaya and his referendum, another rally was held outside the Presidential House on June 25. Supporters of the fourth box rallied together and distributed leaflets.

The President continues to have strong support among trade union leaders and the poor, but his decision to go ahead with Sunday's referendum has prompted fears that he seeks to tear up the Honduran Constitution completely, and even establish a Cuban-style socialist dictatorship.
...
On the morning of June 26, the President hit back at his critics, calling the Congressional President, Roberto Micheletti, "a pathetic, second-class congressman." The comment followed Congressional plans to assess the state of Zelaya's mental health. Such an assessment could see the President declared unfit to rule.
...
It remains to be seen whether, and how, this controversy will end.


http://www.hondurasthisweek.co...

Well, we know now how this ended...

Btw, I found the Honduras source above via a website that proveds links for newspapers in virtually every nation of this earth. A great tool for finding news on foreign policy issues, I recommend it:
http://www.onlinenewspapers.com/


That Passage From Time Really Sticks Out (4.00 / 1)
Especially given how "normally" the framing of the piece begins:

It would be tempting for Washington to dismiss Sunday morning's military overthrow of Honduran President Manuel Zelaya as just a minor banana-republic convulsion. But the Obama Administration doesn't have that luxury. Zelaya is a member of the left-wing club of Latin American leaders - and its honcho, Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez, has already deemed this a hemispheric crisis that will challenge the new north-south bonhomie Obama established two months ago at the Summit of the Americas in Trinidad. Less than an hour after Honduran military aircraft had whisked Zelaya into apparent forced exile in Costa Rica, Chávez was accusing the CIA of having a hand in his ouster. "The Yanqui empire," he said, "has much to do" with what he called "this troglodyte coup."


"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
Donate to Open Left








Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.

As an anti-spam measure, there is a 24-hour waiting period after registering before new users can comment.
blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search