Taser Nation: The New (and Even More Cowardly) Police Brutality

by: tremayne

Sat Aug 22, 2009 at 17:00


Three weeks ago at a Baptism party in Virginia, Prince William County police tasered the grandfather of the boy being Baptized. Here is a local news report on the incident:

The grandfather was tased multiple times for the crime of being drunk on private property while trying to show his I.D. Tasering has become routine. Cop thinks you're being mouthy: you're tased. If the charges are later dropped, which they often are, the tasing was your punishment for the crime of not being deferential enough. An internal investigation concluded procedures were followed.

A New York mom was tasered in front of her kids because she questioned why she was being ticketed for driving with a cell phone when she didn't have one. She filed suit this week. Take a look at the video:

In this case our "heroic and manly" officer, embarrassed at his own mistake, tries to save face by tasering the mom in front of her crying kids. All charges against her have been dismissed and police are conducting an internal investigation to see if they can find a way to justify what happened.

In Michigan, two teenage boys died this spring in separate incidents. These and many other cases are detailed inside.

tremayne :: Taser Nation: The New (and Even More Cowardly) Police Brutality

In March, 15-year-old Brett Elder died after being tasered by Bay City police who were trying to arrest him. Witnesses say he was handcuffed at the time of the tasering. Police say he was not. One month later, 16-year-old Robert Mitchell was killed by a taser operated by police in Warren, Michigan. He was a passenger in a car pulled over for expired tags and had fled the scene, apparently fearful of police there.

Apparently Warren police use tasers routinely; here is another case from that department:

You've probably seen the case of the 72-year-old woman who was tasered after a traffic stop in Texas but here it is if you haven't:

Couldn't the cop handle this elderly woman without tasering her? If 15 and 16 year olds are dying from being tasered don't you think elderly men and women might be even more likely to die? Here's a case from 3 years ago in Georgia (complete with European mockery):

You think race might have been a factor in that one? Tasered for asking questions while not being white. Here's a case from Florida of a woman who tasered at Best Buy:

Tasering has become the preferred method for handling mouthy suspects. Shoot them and you are guaranteed a lengthy investigation. Beat them enough to leave marks and, again, you're facing a long suspension or reassignment to desk duty, possible lawsuits. But the taser is a great option for the angry cop because:

1. In most cases it doesn't leave unsightly physical damage that a jury might find objectionable.

2. You don't have to use your own body to subdue the suspect. This is perfect for the more cowardly cops. You can inflict pain without any chance of incurring pain.

3. You can be "Judge Dredd." So what if the suspect isn't really guilty of anything. They're guilty of not being deferential and you get to inflict the punishment without the mess of "courts" and "rights" and stuff.

4. Your supervisors think it's just fine.

But it's not a laughing matter. At least 200 people have died by taser. And the trend seemed to really pick up during the Bush administration; the culture of torture and "guilty until proven innocent" coming to your neighborhood.


Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Need for "respect" (4.00 / 4)
I see this in the small suburban town I live in in NJ.  We saw this in the Gates incident and in your video about the mom.  Even as few as ten years ago the demand for "respect" from police officers was a lot less.  Police in suburban towns like this one literally tried to avoid giving traffic tickets to the locals.  Now they try to soak as many people as possible for ticky tack offenses.  They still are fairly polite when investigating neighborhood crimes here but I am not so sure how they act when confronted with "resistance."  Local police sue the town semi-frequently(and have won millions), have long-running feuds with both the citizenry and the politicians, and the most obstinate individual just got promoted to a $125 K job in a town of 8,000.  (And he is not the police chief but a co number 2).  Cops and police administrators are paid more than teachers or school administrators and their loyal acolytes are out in force defending them on local blogs and even in public even to the point of going after those who criticize with subpoenas.  (We have 2 to 3 times as many police on a per capita basis as do neighboring towns).

The police on that video or the umpires in baseball games seem to seek confrontation.  Not so long ago, they avoided confrontation and sought to resolve problems with a minimum of hassle.  What are the results?  More crimes, more jails, more problems, and taxes going to the police-jail-"industrial" complex rather than to repairing roads, educating kids or to health care.  Otoh, these same people constantly complain about over spending for schools and libraries.

I don't know if people have OD'd on mafia movies or rap music or what.  But the old idea once emblazoned on police cars of serve and protect has been over taken by demands for respect.  Police are no longer public servants although they do perform a neccesary public service.  This is a sub-culture that has veered into wrong trends.  I'm being cautious with the words, here.  


30+ years of Ronald Reagan.... (0.00 / 0)
have turned all the fat, pasty cops into John Wayne.  8 years of W. turned them into Dirty Harry.   People need to start suing the hell out of the police.  Instead of money, they should demand the cop lose their job.  As it is now, cops know the cities will pay off the complaintant; and they can go about their business as usual.  

They're asking for another four years -- in a just world, they'd get 10 to 20. ~~ Dennis Kucinich  

[ Parent ]
A symptom of authoritarianism (4.00 / 3)
In particular, what we need to overcome to get traction toward better controls on taser use is the idea that people who display any attitude to police "deserve it" because "if you talk back to a cop, you should expect this" as if being imprudent or rude is legitimately punishable by electrocution.

Yes, of course it's wisest not to give lip to cops, but the right to do so hasn't been revoked, and sometimes cops deserve to be reminded they are society's servants, not masters.


You see the same thing (4.00 / 1)
in schools, where the ability to accept received wisdom, follow the rules and not make waves is often seen as an idea quality in a student (or a teacher.) You see it in employment generally.

The personal is indeed political, and I'm inclined to think that we can't overcome this particular manifestation of authoritarianism until we see how it relates to the issue in general, and the many other ways its manifest.  

In the end, I think this is related to neoliberalism - which sees the height of freedom in market transactions and consumption choices, and sees the need for force in all other arenas.

Who are the best keepers of the people's liberties? The people themselves. The sacred trust can be no where so safe as in the hands most interested in preserving it.
James Madison


[ Parent ]
The truly F**Ked up thing about the taser (4.00 / 2)
is that is was never meant to be used as a routine tool. It was meant to be used IN PLACE of firearms on those occasions where firing a weapon would otherwise have been used - in other words, in extreme situations.

The use of the taser must be reined in or else the tool should just be eliminated altogether. It's simply being abused for authoritarian and sadistic purposes.


And not only that, (0.00 / 0)
if the police are just gonna taser everybody all the damn time, why do we (the public) pay so much for police academies? They could probably cut police academy training time down by at least 2/3 since cops don't need to bother about the hassle of defusing a situation non-violently anymore.

[ Parent ]
on injuries (4.00 / 1)
i don't think you can blame overuse of tasers on police officers' being too cowardly to fight. it looks more like police dept management has bought into the idea that tasers reduce workers comp expenses.

just remember (0.00 / 0)
when the authorities say internal affairs investigation that is code for the covert police to protect the white thugs they put on the street to do their dirty work to keep the segment of society the elite class doesn't respect in their place.

if you ever want real reform and a move away from the police state america has become you must have a civilian based investigation on all complaints against police abuse, if the police are really interested in protect and serve they would gladly support this policy, since they don't that speaks to their real agenda and their motives toward the citizenry as a whole.  


Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search