Enforcement Only Policies = No Real Solutions

by: Drum Major Institute

Thu Oct 08, 2009 at 13:16


Originally posted by Cristina Jimenez to DMIBlog.

Immigration enforcement, not immigration reform, has been the focus of the Obama administration. The administration expanded the 287(g) program, which empowers local police to enforce federal immigration laws, and renewed E-Verify, the Bush mandated system that federal contractors are required to use to verify the immigration status of workers. Both are flawed and ineffective enforcement policies.

Obama's enforcement approach also targets employers. Instead of massively arresting immigrant workers in the workplace like the Bush administration, the focus now is on punishing employers that hire undocumented workers. As a result of this new focus, American Apparel is in the process of firing 1,800 immigrant workers in LA. A federal investigation revealed irregularities with the employees' documentation. Most of the workers losing their jobs are women who support their families.

This enforcement approach, however, does not address the real problem: an underground workforce that threatens the wages and working conditions of all workers. In reality, this kind of enforcement drives undocumented workers further into the shadows and increases the likelihood of workplace violations-affecting all workers. As I have argued before, to address the real problem, we need immigration reform that ensures that all workers, regardless of their immigration status, are guaranteed equal labor rights. Enacting enforcement only polices does not lead us to real solutions.  

Drum Major Institute :: Enforcement Only Policies = No Real Solutions

Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
only partially agree (0.00 / 0)
Enforcement of existing law (labor and immigration) is the right way. You seem to be saying that enforcing labor law only is preferable, and I totally agree that we need much more of that. However, reward must be countered with punishment or unethical, employeers will continue to drive down wages across the country for their own greed. This reduces the purchasing power of all producers and substantially contributes to the declining market that so recently slapped us awake. Whial it is convenient to have temperary non-citizen workers when we cannot fill available jobs, it is disasterous to have these same workers in the manpower pool in times of high unemployment, like now. And as you point out, these employees need better protection too. The unauthorized workers, however are always used to undercut existing wages, and the employeers absusing them to everyone's disadvantage must be policed if the nation is to recover. And penalities must be appropriate for the offence. I personally would like to see employeer penalites increased to 100% of minimum wages for a year for each illegal immigrant found on the payroll. And seizure of the entire business for second offence.

Government by organized money is just as dangerous as government by organized mob..... FDR

USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox