We really, really need to form a Progressive Party.

by: Dude Where's My Health Care

Mon Feb 01, 2010 at 09:53


At what point do progressives stop being Democrats' whipped dogs and start acting like a movement capable of putting the Dems in their proper place as the party of the people?  David Sirota wrote today about Obama's latest call to increase war spending beyond its already ludicrous proportions.

How many of the extreme right-wing and criminal policies of Bush-Cheney has Obama adopted?  How many of those extreme right-wing policies has he exceeded?  Last month, knowledge that Obama has gone a step further than Bush, authorizing the executive branch to murder American citizens on the flimsiest of rationales.  This sh__ has GOT to end.

My political activities now are focusing on the building of a viable third party as a tool of a reinvigorated and independent progressive movement.  No efforts to reform the Democratic Party from within can succeed so long as the upper-level of the party establishment is able to crush dissent from within, as is explained here.

[T]the Democratic primaries will be where the action is ... Maybe someone like Kucinich, Feingold ... It will be a "good liberal," not a radical, advocating positions that are reasonable but declared "unrealistic." ("You'll throw the race to the Republicans, we can't have that!") The basis of the campaign will not be a sudden embrace of Bolshevism, but rather Obama's embrace of Wall Street. It will be a mix of angry rank-and-file and disgruntled party machine.

The insurgent candidate will lose. The candidate will not call for a 3rd party, will support Obama after the primaries -- will make a concession speech that would shame the Moscow Show Trials. Many of her or his followers will follow suit. The candidate will not personally work to create an independent infrastructure within the Democratic Party. Obama will probably win, not because of his impressive performance but because the foaming-at-the-mouth Republicans will be splitting. After the election, the Democratic challenger will not lead a 3rd party.

This has been the pattern for decades.  There is no one within the Democratic Party willing to lead a progressive breakoff.  The day Dennis Kucinich kisses all party support for his re-election to Congress goodbye is the day I will rejoice, but it's not going to happen.  So it's on lay progressives to take charge, organize from the ground up, and lead the way to building both the movement and the political organization that will bring it to power within the halls of our nation's capital.

This won't happen overnight; it will take decades for a fully functional progressive political organization to be built, and we will be opposed every step of the way by Democrats, Republicans, and corporations now empowered to spend as much money as their executives want to sway public opinion against us.  But we have got to start sometime, and now is as good a time as any.

Those who claim this isn't the right time will not tell us that the "right time" is never going to come -- there will always be the enxt election cycle to worry about, too much at stake to "risk throwing it to the GOP."  Never mind that all Democrats ever do is throw elections to Republicans simply by behaving like they're members of their counterpart political party.  We must ignore such admonitions and press on.  There is no such thing as perfection in politics, to be the enemy of good things that will never come to fruition so long as the existing political structure continues.  And there is nothing more to be lost by doing what is right and necessary to take back our country.

The good news is that a Progressive Party already exists in some states.  In Missouri, Vermont, and Washington, progressives began rebuilding the political party that bears their name from the ground up, and they used smart strategies and tactics to gain power first at the local level and then at the state level.  They are now starting to branch out into national-level politics by running candidates for the House of Representatives, with a Vermont Progressive having run for the House of Representatives in 2008 on a platform that included calling for Bush's impeachment.  And David Sirota has written previously about New York's Working Families Party, which has gotten results at the local and state levels.

So the foundation exists for progressives to rebuild our movement.  The will is there.  What's lacking is leadership.  If no one in the 'netroots is willing to assume vital leadership roles, then it is up to each and every one of us to take charge and lead.  Enough is enough.  Progressives must stand up to the far right, which dominates both major political parties, and end its rule.  No more excuses, no more capitulations, no more waiting.  Let's get it done.

Dude Where's My Health Care :: We really, really need to form a Progressive Party.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
I agree...you want to work together on this? (4.00 / 1)
I agree with you one hundred percent. I want to get out of this suicide pact with the Dems. Its not going anywhere I like. Let's start something. How do I contact you?

Philip Shropshire
http://www.threeriversonline.com


You can contact me via my profile at FDL. (0.00 / 0)
It's here.  Probably the best way to start or join an existing third party organization is to ask the Vermont chapter organizers.  They know more about how to go about getting a local Progressive Party organization going in your community than I would.  My home state is very hostile to third parties, so it's an uphill climb here.  You can also try contacting the Green Party about where a local chapter exists that you can join.  The first step is creating or joining an independent organization, run democratically, and building it up.  The next is crafting strategies and tactics that can achieve desired results.  I'll touch upon those in my next entry.

"Given the choice between a Republican and someone who acts like a Republican, people will vote for the real Republican all the time." -- Harry S. Truman

[ Parent ]
If You have Enough Support for a Viable 3rd Party (4.00 / 2)
If You have Enough Support for a Viable 3rd Party, you have enough support to elect some viable progressives as Democrats.

You frame the question as if it is one of "timing": "if not now, when"? But that is the wrong question. Kucinich, Feingold and others you cite are not remaining Democrats because they are "cowards" or somehow "bought off." They are behaiving according to the logic of the situation in which they find themselves.

You summon up enough moral force through your good intentions in a way which will remove the structural, objective dilemma facing progressives trying to form a Third Party. You are asking voters to withhold their vote from the "lesser evil" Democrat in order to make a symbolic statement, which objectively will result in the election of the "greater evil" Republican.

And if there IS a way around that dilemma, it would be at the local level, in the down-ticket races, building the organization from the ground up. Yet your example focuses on the presidential election.

If you can mount a "viable" Third Party presidential campaign, whatever that means, you can pour some energy into defeating Blue Dog Democrats and replacing them with progressives. You can elect progressives to your state legislature. It may not seem as "heroic." And you might have to be a small frog in a Big Pond, instead of a small frog who appears to be big, because you're in a tiny pond. Third Party grouplet politics can certainly be fun, but any attempt to logically explain how they might be effective in the real world, strains under the pressure of wishfull thinking and psychological denial approaching that of a religious cult.

Seriously, if your main focus is anti-war work, build the social movement in your community. Help build a semi-autonomous Peacwe and Justice network within your county or state Democratic Party. If you support gay rights, join the LGBT caucus. If you are an enviro, do the same. If you are a multi-issue progressive, join the Progressive Democrats group. They have done remarkable work for such a small group. Remain critical and independent in your attitude towards the candidates, but find the best ones with a chance of being elected and push for them.

Sorry for sounding so harsh. But that's my frank assessment after years of wrestling with the same problems which appear to be frustrating you.


Don't get me wrong. (0.00 / 0)
I'm not saying that politicians like Kucinich are cowards; they're not.  But they are justifiably concerned that if they do make the break, they will find themselves so cut off in terms of money and support that it will end their political careers and therefore any chance they have within the system of making any changes (no matter how small).  In order to convince these people to make the break, as it were, they need to know that they will find money and support from existing independent, movement-driven organizations.

"Given the choice between a Republican and someone who acts like a Republican, people will vote for the real Republican all the time." -- Harry S. Truman

[ Parent ]
USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox