Senate Forecast and Round-up, February 2nd

by: Chris Bowers

Tue Feb 02, 2010 at 13:13


Senate Forecast update
  • February 02 Senate update: Democratic loss of 5.35 seats (five)
  • Change from Jan 26: Democrats down 0.03 seats (NO CHANGE)
  • Projected 2010 Senate: Democrats 54-46 (assuming no caucus switches)

News

  • Illinois primary tonight.  The Illinois primary is tonight.  For our purposes at Open Left, the Democratic Senate primary is the featured matchup.  It is likely that either Alexis Giannoulisor David Hoffman will win.  Giannoulis has long been the frontrunner, and is perhaps the more lefty candidate.  However he has recently been beset with a banking scandal, is spinning his wheels in the polls and, even before the scandal, trailed Hoffman badly among people who know both candidates.  As such, Giannoulis's polling advantage is probably a mirage.

  • Arkansas--Blanche Lincoln is toast.  I hope Blanche Lincoln enjoyed her time in the Senate, because it will end in less than a year.  New Arkansas polling from PPP put her down 23 points to forthcoming challenger John Boozman.  Rasmussen has her down by 19%.  At this point, running a primary challenger against Blanche Lincoln has more to do with electability than anything else.  Given her deficit, there is no real point or possibility of pushing her to the left.  She is done.

  • Florida--Charlie Crist is also toast.  As the charts in the extended entry show, Marco Rubio has taken a substantial, 7.2% lead on Charlie Crist in the Florida Republican primary.  It is hard to see any conceivable way that an incumbent comes back from such a deficit, given the extremely pro-Rubio trendlines.  This is a political environment where being in prominent, elected office is bad for a campaign.

    It is also worth noting that Crist's demise does not help presumptive Democratic nominee Kendrick Meek at all.  Meek currently trails Rubio by 11.8%, compared to his 10.2% deficit against Crist.  IT is difficult for me to see how Meek overcomes that sort of deficit, given the current political environment and strong, pro-Rubio trendlines.  Florida is rapidly moving out of play.

  • Massachusetts--Scott Brown to be sworn in on February 11th. Scott Brown will be sworn in on Friday, February 11th, at 12:45 p.m.  Given that Democrats only reached 60, active, voting Senators on Friday, September 25th, at 3:30 p.m., that means the Democratic supermajority for 138 days, 21 hours, and 15 minutes.  Hope they enjoyed it because, as the forecast shows in the extended entry, it won't be coming back anytime soon.
Complete forecast charts can be found in the extended entry.
Chris Bowers :: Senate Forecast and Round-up, February 2nd
Senate forecast overview
Democrats* Republicans
Not up for election 41 23
Currently safe 9 12
Sub-total 50 35
Current polling 3.65 11.35
Projected total 54 46
* = Because they caucus with Senate Democrats, Independents Bernie Sanders and Joe Lieberman are considered Democrats

The 15 currently competitive Senate campaigns
("Competitive" is defined as campaigns where incumbent party currently leads by 18% or less in current polling among announced candidates)
Democrats: 3.65 (4)
Republicans: 11.35 (11)

State Democrat Republican Margin Current Dem Win %
Wisconsin Feingold Wall D 14.0 100%
WI Feingold Westlake D 15.0 100%
California Boxer Campbell D 6.0 95%
CA Boxer Fiorina D 8.7 98%
CA R Primary Campbell +12.5
Illinois Giannoulis Kirk* D 5.5 94%
IL Jackson Kirk* R 2.5 19%
IL Hoffman Kirk* R 2.5 19%
IL D Primary Giannoulis +12.3
Missouri Carnahan Blunt* Even 50%
Ohio Fisher Portman* R 5.3 6%
OH Brunner Portman* R 5.8 6%
OH D Primary Fisher +5.5
Colorado Bennet Norton* R 5.8 6%
CO Romanoff Norton* R 7.8 3%
CO D Primary Romanoff +14.0
Pennnsylvania Specter Toomey R 5.8 6%
PA Sestak Toomey R 9.0 1%
PA D Primary Specter +18.5
North Carolina Marshall* Burr R 7.3 3%
Nevada Reid Tarkanian R 7.5 3%
NV Reid Lowden R 8.0 2%
NV Reid Angle R 4.3 9%
NV R Primary Tarkanian +0.5
New Hampshire Hodes* Ayotte* R 8.0 2%
Kentucky Mongiardo Paul R 10.0 0%
KY Conway Paul R 7.0 3%
KY Mongiardo Grayson R 8.0 2%
KY Conway Grayson R 8.5 2%
KY D Primary Mongiardo +3.5
KY R Primary Paul +11.0
Arkansas Lincoln Baker R 10.8 0%
AR Lincoln Boozman R 21.0 0%
AR Lincoln Coleman R 7.3 3%
AR R Primary Baker +2.0 (straw poll)
Florida Meek* Rubio R 11.8 0%
FL Meek* Crist R 10.2 0%
FL R Primary Rubio +7.2
Delaware ???? Castle* R +??? 0%
North Dakota ????? Hoeven R +??? 0%
* = Faces primary challenge, but heavy favorite.

Please let me know how you think the forecast could be improved.  It remains a work in progress.  The methodology can be found here.


Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Still have 60 for a week? (0.00 / 0)
You mean we still have 60 Senate votes for another week?  Seems they could have (or still could) steamroll the healthcare (not technically a) committee bill.  What a bunch of chicken $%$#@! these guys are...

Notice how easily it is to be confused in a two-party system? (0.00 / 0)
People actually think that a single party has 60 votes, when in reality it's a coalition of 7+ factions.

Democracy is one of those cases where more is more.


[ Parent ]
I won't be sorry to see Lincoln go (4.00 / 2)
but if we end up with Senators Portman, Toomey and Ayotte I will be extremely upset. We shouldn't be losing in those states anymore.

If Democrats hold the Senate and Lincoln loses, Debbie Stabenow will be in line to chair the Ag Committee when the next farm bill is written.

Join the Iowa progressive community at Bleeding Heartland.


Toomey in particular has been head-scratching (0.00 / 0)
Wasn't Toomey supposed to be "unelectable" in PA?  And wasn't the point of Specter's switch to avoid Toomey in the primary so he could, um, crush him in the general?

One silver lining is that some of these Republicans (Ayotte, Kirk, Castle) are relative "moderates" and may be gettable votes the closer the Republicans get to 50.  Also, they may be prime pickings in 2016, and if our favored candidates like Brunner and Sestak lose this time around they can get a good chance then.


[ Parent ]
USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox