Senate to leave town without unemployment benefit extension

by: Chris Bowers

Fri Mar 26, 2010 at 10:26


If you thought Republicans would loosen their obstructionist ways once health reform was done, think again.  Tom Coburn's filibuster of the unemployment extension, an effort which was supported by many other Republicans, appears to have been successful.  The Senate will adjourn until April 12th, without extending benefits, even though for many those benefits will run out on April 5th:

Senate Democrats and Republicans spent hours negotiating among themselves and with each other to find a compromise. Senate Majority Leader Harry M. Reid (D-Nev.) and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) discussed the possibility of a one- or two-week extension of benefits that would be fully paid for, but Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) was opposed to the idea, according to two Senate aides.

As a result, the House and Senate will leave town without further action. COBRA and flood insurance will expire March 30, and unemployment benefits will expire April 5. The Senate will return to session April 12.(...)

The Senate GOP's refusal to agree to the House's version of the bill was led by Sen. Tom Coburn (R-Okla.), who objected to bringing up the bill. Coburn said that by adding to the federal deficit, we are "stealing future opportunity from our children."

Democrats probably had 60 votes to reach cloture and pass the bill.  However, Coburn had denied unanimous consent for a motion to proceed.  Without that consent, either Cobrun and his supporters have to relent, or else here is the process required:

Leader Reid moves to proceed to an HR [House of Representatives] bill, which will be the vehicle for the Senate health care bill, and files a cloture motion on the motion to proceed

Two calendar days later, the cloture motion on the motion to proceed ripens (there has to be one intervening calendar day between the day you file cloture and the day you have the vote)

The cloture vote on the motion to proceed occurs one hour after we convene on the third day (If cloture is filed on Wednesday, the cloture vote is Friday. If cloture is filed on Thursday, the cloture vote is on Saturday, etc)

Assuming 60 Senators vote to limit debate on the motion to proceed and end the filibuster, the Senate invokes cloture on the motion to proceed

Thirty hours after cloture is invoked the Senate will proceed to vote on adoption of the motion to proceed itself (This assumes (a) consent will not be granted to yield back any post-cloture time on the motion to proceed and (b) consent will not be granted to adopt the motion to proceed itself---adoption of the motion to proceed itself is routinely agreed to by UC but Rs could force a roll call vote).

Upon adoption of the motion to proceed, the Senate will be on the bill

Additionally, cloture cannot be filed when he Senate is voting.  So Harry Reid cold not have filed for cloture until yesterday afternoon.  That means this entire process would have taken another week, as long as Coburn and his supporters were determined to keep obstructing.  Just another reminder that we need broad procedural reform in the Senate.

Chris Bowers :: Senate to leave town without unemployment benefit extension

Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
so intead of taking a week (4.00 / 2)
They will take a week's break, and be in the same situation when they return. Pathetic.  

New Jersey politics at Blue Jersey.

and how ironic is the 49-39 vote to adjourn? (0.00 / 0)
Yes, you can win a vote 49-39 while being unable to get a vote on something you have over 60 votes on.

http://senate.gov/legislative/...


New Jersey politics at Blue Jersey.


[ Parent ]
Democrats can delay leaving town to address this issue (4.00 / 4)


... (4.00 / 3)
Democrats SHOULD delay leaving town to address the issue; but they aren't.   Sickens me.

[ Parent ]
I am not sickened by the expected (4.00 / 2)
They all give great performances and the Democratic blogs push for them, but they keep telegraphing that the party is the party of Rockerfeller Republicans now.

[ Parent ]
I cannot join you (4.00 / 5)
in covering for leadership.

Keep in mind that they tried to get UC on the bill A WEEK AGO.  That means they surely knew, if they were being honest with themselves, that this would happen then.  Reid could have filed cloture after passing the FAA bill and before the reconciliation bill on Tuesday.  That means it would have ripened for yesterday and they could have voted on the motion to proceed then.  And voted.  And voted.  And with every vote, tally up one more example of Republicans denying aid to the needy.  Someone would have broken, as they did in February.

I think the leadership wanted this as an issue more than wanting to ensure no expiration of the benefits.

Insert shameless blog promotion here.


Wasn't aware I was covering for the leadership (n/t) (4.00 / 1)


[ Parent ]
asdf (0.00 / 0)
well look, you're telling people what leadership aides told me, but the facts are they could have filed cloture three days ago.  

Insert shameless blog promotion here.

[ Parent ]
... (0.00 / 0)
It sounds like they are using this to score political points... as Bunning's BS hurt the GOP.  

[ Parent ]
Yeap. Exactly. And as I said above. They don't have to leave (0.00 / 0)
There is no gun to their head. They choose to do so.

[ Parent ]
Most. Stupid. Rules. Ever. (4.00 / 1)
I don't care whose fault this is, the system is broken.  The rules must be changed.

... (4.00 / 4)
This is bullshit.  No wonder the country is in an anti-incumbent mood.  I'm almost as pissed at the Dems as I am the GOP.  

STAY AND PASS THE BILL YOU LAZY FUCKING ASSHOLES!

Seriously, you make more than most Americans and with your long several weeks vacations you get way more vacation time too.   I mean anyone else here want a job paying $174,000 a year and a couple of months off a year?  I sure as hell do.  Meanwhile, the US is the only first world country I know of without mandatory vacations guarenteed to all workers.    

This is ridiculous.   Reid should have had the foresight that this would happen.   If not, then he needs to follow the longer week long process.  

More and more, I want to see primary challenges to many of these lazy bastards.   It's like the GOP are drug abusing alcoholics  and the Dems love to enable them.    

Yes, the process needs to be reformed; but until it is instead of fucking millions of people, cut your vacation short and get to work.    Lazy Rich fucks.


I'm shocked. (4.00 / 1)
Surprised.  Astounded.  Bewildered.  Confounded.  Confused.  Stunned.  Startled.  Dazed.  Jolted.  Floored.  Truly, no one could have predicted Reid would take the path of least resistance.  Like he always does.

What little respect I had left for the guy is gone.  Fuck him.  Fuck him and his willingness to throw millions under the bus for the sake of his own comfort.  And to anyone even contemplating defending this arrogant asshole, you're a Democratic apologist shill.  Fuck you, too, for helping to enable this behavior.  This can no longer be tolerated.  I do not care if a Republican takes his place, Reid must not be reelected.  He is more damaging to us as Majority Leader than any single Republican ever could be.  Can his ass.

Health insurance is not health care.
If you don't fight, you can't win.
Never give up. Never Surrender.
Watch out for flying kabuki.


USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox