The Politico's Prowar Agenda

by: Matt Stoller

Fri Dec 21, 2007 at 12:49


( - promoted by Chris Bowers)

Every so often I run across a really egregious example of prowar advocacy and DC gossip couched as journalism.  One such example is this article from the Politico on how Democrats want Pelosi and Reid to give up on the war.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, despite their pledges to continue pushing to end the war in Iraq, face growing pressure from their rank-and-file Democrats to focus more attention on domestic, "pocketbook" issues in the upcoming election year.

The article quotes one Democratic House member: Brian Baird.  One.  That's it.  And the context is really remarkable.

My hope would be we start looking at real solutions instead of the dichotomy of cut funding versus stay forever," said Rep. Brian Baird (D-Wash.), who had a change of heart this fall after visiting Iraq and realizing the military surge was working.

"The entire policy has been dictated by the 'Out of Iraq Caucus' ... What are we going to do, have another 40 withdrawal votes?"

The journalists who wrote this piece, John Bresnahan and Martin Kady, just sort of throw out there the assertion that the surge is working as fact.  And they quote only Baird, who apparently represents all Democratic junior members, despite not actually being a junior member.  They also quote Senator Mark Pryor discussing his desire to cease talking about Iraq and get on with cutting the estate tax, as if he is a junior Congressional member.

So what do junior members actually think?  Here's Patrick Murphy, the recognized Democratic freshman leader on Iraq, in the Courier Times.

Murphy said Democrats should have tried to push through a war funding bill with strings attached before they left Washington, D.C. for the holiday break.

"I would have stayed in Washington through Christmas, through the New Year," he said. "When you're willing to stand up to the president and fight for things that you believe in, we can be successful and I think this is one of the things we should have fought harder on."

"There is frustration about Iraq," Murphy said. "The president and the Bush Republicans stonewalled our efforts. I knew this job wasn't going to be easy and I look forward to going back and fighting again on behalf of the soldiers who hope for a better strategy.

According to Murphy, who is not a member of the Out of Iraq caucus but is a freshman leader on Iraq, it's time for Democrats to fight on the war.  But according to the Politico, Democrats have given up, junior Democrats want the leadership to give up, antiwar Democrats are crazy, and the surge is working.

Matt Stoller :: The Politico's Prowar Agenda

Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Not the first time (0.00 / 0)
It's pretty thin, I agree. (I flagged another example on Wednesday.)

But - there are a couple of things that lend it credibility:

First, this is not the first time this time to concentrate on domestic issues story has come up. I wrote in September about what looked like a PR offensive from the Senate Dem leadership (with on-the-record quotes!) to flag a new direction.

Second, as the hacks point out, the House Dem leadership was divided on the final vote on the omnibus (HR 2764) - with the $70bn no-strings Iraq funding.

Provides a suggestive context for dissent in the ranks.

Third, they do have a junior Democrat - Jim Webb - on the record.

And he sounds very much as if he'd favor a rebalancing of priorities away from Iraq in 2008.

  All in all, not the most egregious piece masquerading as political journalism that I've seen!


Who IS this idiotic Brian Baird asshole? (4.00 / 1)
And isn't he from a pretty anti-war area of Washington state?

Can't we primary his gullible ass?

I have seen him on Hardball before.  He's a fucking jerk.

For some reason, it seems that Obama has some pathological and deep-seated psychological need for Republicans to like him.  Seriously.  It's weird.


Some Colorado lawmakers also just got bamboozled (0.00 / 0)
Both Ed Perlmutter, CO-7, and Governor Bill Ritter got bamboozled by what one must assume was an awesome Petraeus PowerPoint. The Denver Post went right along, too.

Hello Iraq 2013.


I suspect they are looking at casualty numbers... (0.00 / 0)
...and in that respect the surge does seem to be working. I think it would be intellectually dishonest to argue otherwise. The question is will it last and when will the Iraqi parliament meet the benchmarks the surge was intended to produce?

Is it working? (4.00 / 1)
2007 US casualty numbers are the highest for any year (893 and counting).  Casualties for the last quarter of the year (October-November-December) are substantially lower than for the same quarter in 2006.  That is not a resoundingly clear response, certainly not enough to justify the CW from the Beltway bandits.

If casualties stay down for, say, a year, we may have progress.  I spent too much time hearing similar vidtory pronouncements from Vietnam.


[ Parent ]
Surge isn't necessarily the reason (0.00 / 0)
Since prominent insurgent leaders have stated that they've cut back on attacks on US troops and intend to "wait out the surge" it's premature to say that it's working. It may be no more than a band-aid.

Forgotten Countries - a foreign policy-focused blog

[ Parent ]
I wouldn't read into this quote (0.00 / 0)
Not to be the naysayer, but I don't think the Baird quotation is written the way you're reading it. The writer isn't necessarily saying that what Baird "realized" is correct, just that Baird "realized" it -- replace "realized" with "came to the decision" for the same effect.

If you asked the journalists and editors who oversaw the story, I'd bet they'd tell you that's the way they wrote it, not as any judgment about the surge itself. Maybe they could have found a more neutral-sounding verb, but it's pretty common for a journalist to use this construction to convey the subject's opinion, not the journalist's.

No comment on the publication's agendas more broadly.

No, I do not weep at the world — I am too busy sharpening my oyster knife.
    Zora Neale Hurston


USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox