Why Is the Press Turning on McCain's Temper?

by: Matt Stoller

Sun Mar 09, 2008 at 17:51


I am confused.  The media seems to be unveiling Straight Talk John McCain fairly aggressively, with the snippy exchange between McCain and Elizabeth Bumiller being the flash point.

I heard Ana Marie Cox on Reliable Sources this morning talking about McCain's temper and what it's like to be on the bus, and suggesting that McCain is much worse than he was to Bumiller on a regular basis, and that Bumiller was only shocked because she's new to the McCain bus.  "He's a cranky old man" is what she said exactly, I believe.  And another participant in the roundtable said something along the lines of 'well he got caught in a lie'.  What exactly is going on?  Why isn't the punditocracy 100% in love with Saint McCain?

Maybe it's just not fun anymore.  It's well-known that McCain will call up and scream at various individuals if they displease him; I know that board members of Common Cause get a standard McCain shout-a-thon if they criticize him in the press.  He screams at Senators several times a week, and it's pretty clear that he blows up at reporters fairly regularly.  So maybe it just sucks on the bus right now.

Still, this doesn't explain why the press isn't venerating him as they usually do.  It's not that they are doing a good job, they aren't, as they aren't covering his career as a politician.  McCain has a long history of policy-making on various Senate committees, including being the chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, which regulates the media.  This is interesting information the press could research, but hasn't.  And you haven't heard much of anything about the decisions he made as Committee Chair, or his fights and alliances with Abramoff in the Indian Affairs Committee.  

It's all fascinating stuff you won't hear about.  That you won't hear about it is not a surprise, as the National Association of Broadcasters is one of the most powerful lobbies in DC, dispensing Public Service Announcements to various charities in return for them vouching for NAB priorities.  And so, for example, you get the Red Cross and Toys for Tots advocating against local radio caps at town hall meetings.  That's not even considering the lobbying power brought to bear by the industrial conglomerates who own these media companies, which include defense contractors, entertainment companies (the copyright cartel), cable, financial services, and well, you get the point.  The press has its own agenda; did you know that the New York Times is being fought over like a piece of meat in a hedge fund battle and that billionaire real estate mogul Sam Zell owns the LA Times and the Chicago Tribune, carved out a special deal for himself at the FCC, and is shuttering DC reporting staff?

That the media is a special interest organized around maintaining certain policy preferences seems quite plausible as an explanation of its behavior. While reporters don't write their stories with these biases in mind, the 'star system' where Tim Russert is on top both economically and exposure-wise reinforces them every day.  All of this is to say that I just don't understand why it is that the press is turning its bitchy claws a bit towards McCain.  He's going to be good to them, better than the Democrats anyway.  Does he really look like that much of a loser?  He must.

Matt Stoller :: Why Is the Press Turning on McCain's Temper?

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Plus, Obama Really Is A Charmer (4.00 / 1)
And the press corps just has to love that.  It's what they love more than anything else, a President who thinks that Job One is stroking their egos.

Doesn't matter if it's true or not.  Just so long as he lets them feel that way.

(Did they really think those Bush nicknames weren't incredibly demeaning?  Were they really that dumb?  Well, of course they were, but, I mean, really?)

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


Haha (0.00 / 0)
Yeah, I always wondered why they put up with that crap. Being that a person usually gives playful nicknames to people they love, generally children or the person they're married to, I can't see why the press would like to be treated like Bush's child, or his bitch (but, from seeing their job these last few years, I can say they are probably a mix of both).  

Former Edwards Supporter, Obama Supporter since January 30, 2008

[ Parent ]
I thought Obama didn't stroke their egos (0.00 / 0)
Haven't there been stories about how Obama really doesn't talk to the press very much, as opposed to McCain in all his straight-talking folksy refreshing straight-talkiness?  There's been some concern that the press might start digging into Obama just because of that, as I recall.

Also, if this stuff about McCain's temper is going to spill out into the electorate's image of him, there's gonna have to be some footage that far exceeds that clip with Bumiller.  Sure, he was getting testy, but he barely even raised his voice.  Your average voter who hasn't heard anything about McCain's temper, or maybe has but is only dimly aware of it, will probably look at that clip and say, "what's the big deal?"  Although I guess Matt's post is more about the media's general approach to McCain, and if they all start talking about his temper as an issue, then I guess it becomes one by default.  


[ Parent ]
I'm Just Speculating, Really (0.00 / 0)
Obama is personally charming, and whether they're getting enough access to him now or not, it seems pretty likely that they'd like more time with him--and not just to beef up their stories.  Perhaps he's counting on this, and playing a little "hard to get," figuring that it's a long campaign, and he doesn't want them getting bored with him just as the voters are really starting to focus intently.

Whatever.  Like I said, just speculating.  But it makes sense.  They really do operate on that sort of high school clique-type level.  Hello, Buffy, The Vampire Slayer, Seasons 1-3.

And, yeah, the McCain deal is not so much what they show voters, it's how they frame him.  So far, it's been with halos.  Now, maybe, survey says, not so much.

We'll see.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


[ Parent ]
what's strange is (4.00 / 2)
that the "blow-up" with Bumiller wasn't much of a temper tantrum, compared to the attention it's gotten in the media.

I hope we can provoke McCain to really blow his top in front of the cameras. I've been saying we need Mike Stark, or someone like him, to ask a question that really makes McCain angry. It has to be some question no journalist on his bus would dare ask him.

Join the Iowa progressive community at Bleeding Heartland.


i agree (0.00 / 0)
I was sort of waiting for him to flip out in the video, but it never really got beyond "testy" (and the reporter was pushing somewhat obnoxiously, I felt.)

[ Parent ]
Given His "Answers," That's Called "Doing Her Job" (0.00 / 0)
I mean, how did you think it's done?

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
eh (0.00 / 0)
Not by repeating the same question with slight variations!

[ Parent ]
Expecting sparks, got a TDS interview instead (0.00 / 0)
I don't know the background of this video but I'm surprised if the press is using it as example of McCain's temper.  

I think there has been more tension between McCain and Jon Stewart on The Daily Show, e.g., when they engaged on Iraq. McCain tried to filibuster by talking over Stewart and Stewart had to tell McCain to "settle down."  

McCain's main strategy to win an argument is by repeatedly asserting an earth-is-flat rebuttal ad nauseum. I'm only surprised he didn't also address Bumiller with his standard "Friend" condescension.  


[ Parent ]
Maybe Some Reporters are Actually Fed Up with All the Crap (0.00 / 0)
McCain clearly wants to continue Bush's policies. I wonder if some of the reporters are feeling like they got burned by Bush -- his numerous lies and his rank cronyism that led to the quagmire in Iraq, the collapse of Enron and now the collapse of the economy, the incompetent response to hurricane Katrina, the unethical response to Terri Schiavo, etc. etc. -- and feel that they don't want to go down that road again. Since McCain is also a "cranky old man", they have no reason to feel any personal loyalty to him either. So they are actually subjecting him to a little bit of honest scrutiny -- not on most of the important issues of course, but still reporting McCain's many connections to lobbyists and his temper. For once in a very long time, some of the mainstream media seems to be actually practicing a little investigative journalism. It is very refreshing.

Talk to some old hands in Arizona about McCain. (4.00 / 1)
He has even laid his hands on people.  He's VERY unstable and very dangerous.  He push Grant Woods, the then AG, when Woods didn't kow-tow to McCain by laying off the then corrupt and indicted governor, Fife Symington.  Fife and McCain were - and remaim - very close.

Another enemy of McCain in Arizona by the name of Alberto Rodriguez, who was a former header of the state DPS, had been physically accosted by McCain.

There are many many more stories like these out of Arizona.  Hopefully, they all come out now that King John is the nominee.

For some reason, it seems that Obama has some pathological and deep-seated psychological need for Republicans to like him.  Seriously.  It's weird.


The McCaine Mutiny (4.00 / 1)
"For the last time Elizabeth, where did you put my STRAWBERRIES???"

Not that I'm for John McCain, but the media needs to get over itself. (4.00 / 1)
You are going to influence an election with bad coverage for a politician because he speaks harshly to you on the bus?  Well, what did you do?  This is the source of all our problems. We need to bring back the fairness doctrine and drill journalism students with the idea that their job is to be neutral. It's the public's job to decide who to vote for based on issues, not whether these junior high school sorority and fraternity kids "like" the candidate's personality.

You're Missing The Point (0.00 / 0)
Journalists are supposed to ask tough questions.  After 8 years of BushCo, it's often difficult to remember that, but it's true.

This becomes an issue because, if a candidate can't handle press questions without getting his dander up, do we really want him to have his finger on the button?

Fact is, he might well be a better legislator for it.  But that's as one among many.  The White House is a different kind of job.

Remember, it's the GOP that's always going on endlessly about "character."  Well, this is a real character issue.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


[ Parent ]
POW mental damage? I want to know if (0.00 / 0)
he suffered mental damage as a POW? And if so, of what nature and to what extent?

Jeff Wegerson

Don't have an answer... (0.00 / 0)
...but wasn't that question part of the background smear campaign by Bush  against McCain in 2000?

I hope it doesn't arise again; instead, I think it's more effective to review McCain's current mental health regardless of cause.  

(Too bad petulance wasn't a disqualifier for the presidency in 2000--and 2004.)  


[ Parent ]
They're doing it now... (0.00 / 0)
  ...because at this point in the campaign, bad press is the least damaging to McCain. Everyone's paying attention to the Democratic battle anyway.

 Then in the fall, when the press reverts to its usual Monica Lewinsky imitation on McCain, they can claim that "we already covered that" when someone brings it up.

 

"We judge ourselves by our ideals; others by their actions. It is a great convenience." -- Howard Zinn


Why Did The Press... (0.00 / 0)
...take one of Bush's biggest weaknesses, his decades of alcoholism, and make it his strong point?

"Bush is the guy you want to go drinking with! He's your drinking buddy! Have a beer with Bush!"

While at the same time, they took one of Al Gore's biggest strengths, his depths and hunger for knowledge, and turned it against him?

"Al Gore is sooooo boring. He's a know-it-all snob. We hate him, he thinks he's better than us".

Why did the press allow a bunch of partisan lairs to Swiftboat John Kerry, without even trying to get to the bottom of the story and expose their many lies and the bigoted comments of Jerome Corsi were never revealed?

Why is the press constantly attacking Hillary Clinton and fluffing Barack Obama?

Because the press likes to chose the President. They chose Bush twice and now they have chosen "the chosen one".

There's only one saint in this election, and it ain't St. McCain.


Ratings (0.00 / 1)
All the ratings are on the democratic side.  The media really isn't that political.  It tends to protect certain corporations that fund it, but thats about it.  

The assumption that the media is biased against democrats comes from the sleaze of the Clinton's I think.

The liberal wiki
Send an email to terra@liberalwiki.com


Really? (0.00 / 0)
The assumption that the media is biased against democrats comes from the sleaze of the Clinton's I think.

I guess you slept through the 2000 and 2004 campaigns?

miasmo.com


[ Parent ]
Don't Forget 2002! (4.00 / 1)
Gots to gets his beauty rest!

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
Don't forget that Senator McCain is.... (0.00 / 0)

.......................................America's only 'Reverse Ace'!

Yep, John is the only American flyer to lose five planes right out from under himself: engine 'flameout' two....hit power lines one....accident on flight deck one. All this prior to losing his last command to enemy action in North Vietnam.

Affectionately known by his fellow fighting knights of the air as 'Ace' McCain he truly was in a class of his own. Funny thing is he was considered a great 'roomy' but no one wanted to fly with him.

Wonder why....

Peace, Health and Prosperity for Everyone.


Bitchy Claws (0.00 / 0)
I think the blog title should be "Why Do John McCain's Press Q&A's Occur BEFORE He Has His Ritalin?"

Nothing like a few early morning meds to calm the Mad Dog down.


USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox