Why Politics

by: Matt Stoller

Fri Mar 28, 2008 at 16:48


Two days ago, I woke up to the sound of cops outside my apartment.  The door to the apartment across the hall was open, and my neighbor was sitting on the couch staring glassy eyed ahead while surrounded by police officers.  I knew the couple in that apartment, a bit, chatting occasionally as you do with neighbors who share elevators.  I'm on the eighth floor, and so I took the elevator down to go on my morning run.  As I left the building, I saw the driveway cordoned off by bright yellow tape, and a body covered in a white sheet on the pavement in that area.  It was clearly his girlfriend who had fallen off the railing.  Now I don't know if it was an accident or a suicide, but it was jarring to see the body and to see my neighbors man's glassy eyed stare eight floors up as he pondered the death of someone so close to him.  The firefighters, cops, and the building management cleaned the area with chemicals and then hosed it down, and I talked to one of the firefighters who told me that something like this happens once a year or so.

Now, there are many reasons that this was upsetting and tragic, but the most common response I got was 'Oh my God, are you ok'.  And of course I'm ok.  I'm a relatively well-adjusted man, and authorities came in and knew how to handle the situation.  But the site was jarring and screwed me up a little bit, and if I encountered something like this all the time, I probably wouldn't be ok after awhile.  And I keep going back to what it must be like to be a 7 year old Iraqi who sees this kind of thing every day, with no authorities around to help, or a soldier who sees this every day, and who basically is the authority supposed to handle it.  That's what is happening, but it's out of our view to spare the political system from the force of our collective empathy.

After all, the shock I hear from friends and acquaintances when I tell them about this story is remarkable.  It's not remarkable that they are sympathetic and shocked, that's just humanity speaking.  What's remarkable is that they are sympathetic and shocked because a random tragedy happened so close to someone they know.  But these kinds of events happen every single day in Iraq.  Every single day.  

As we work in politics, recognize that the policies and political leaders we elect do things that have huge impacts on the world around us.  Whether it's a Cuban girl who can't get a lemon when she has a sore throat or violence halfway around the world, politics matters.  It's not a game.  It's not about liberals versus moderates versus conservatives.  It's about the lives of the people around us, near us, and connected to us.  

Now don't get me wrong, I love politics.  I love the give and take, the negotiations, the arguments, the elections, the stories, even the sleaze.  But that's not why it matters, it's just my fortune in being passionate about something I think happens to matter.  When I give time and effort, it's because I feel a small measure of responsibility for the deaths in Iraq that I have helped cause as a citizen of this country, which chose to go to war in 2002, a war I supported for reasons that seem unfathomably immoral to me now.  I will not make up for my earlier stupidity and craven ideas, but I can be a citizen again.

So every time I give to a candidate or a campaign, I consider it a privilege and an honor.  I try to earmark it for candidates who by their election or service I think have a good chance of shifting our policies, because these policies matter deeply.  But you never really know if it's going to work.  Still, while it's jarring to see a body on the ground, and tragic for my neighbor across the hall and the overall community, we should not speak in hushed tones about these tragedies.  I cannot pretend that because the body was in front of me it was more meaningful than the senseless deaths happening around the world.  And it's equally cynical to take the approach that all we are doing is preventing tragedy, since there is so much joy and wonder that each of us within our communities create when we take responsibility for each other.

We are all connected by a fundamental sense of humanity.  We can hide this through walls and media manipulation, but it will not stay hidden forever.  And while Markos thinks that nagging is the right term to use when discussing fundraising for the end of the quarter, and maybe it is, I think there's something more meaningful about putting yourself on the line, even just a little bit, to make a political change in the world.  That's how most politicians I know think about the problem as well.  Every single day, Congressmen and women hear of funerals in their district of soldiers, every day they make decisions having to do with life and death in thousands of ways.  And every day, many of them try to help as many people as possible, even as their day is sliced into ten minute segments, votes, and meetings with lobbyists, constituents, and advocates.  So when you give $10 or $25 or $50 through Blue Majority or any other manner, recognize that what you are doing is taking a chance that change is possible.

I think that's a very big deal.

Matt Stoller :: Why Politics

Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Why Politics | 9 comments
That is very much why I'm in it too. (0.00 / 0)
I design web site for Democratic campaigns for a living and have been politically active since I came out about eight years ago.  I've been interested in politics much long than that, even following the news fairly closely as a young teenager.

I've always been fascinated by how interconnected everything is.  You can't touch one issue without affecting a thousand others.  I've always seen that as both the awesome potential and the horrific responsibility of politics.  If we're aware of those connections, we can use them to do great good, but if we miscalculate, we can cause tremendous damage as Bush clearly has with this war (destabilizing a region, wrecking our economy, emboldening anti-American leaders around the world, etc.).

I believe the one true test of anyone who wishes to engage in politics is this: Are you leaving the world a better place than you found it?  I think empathy is a tremendous component in that - when we see people being wronged, what are we ourselves doing to right that wrong?  What are we doing to empower other people to do the same?

That lies at the very core of what motivates me every day.


HDNet World Report covered a study (4.00 / 1)
conducted by Feed the Children about people's capacity for empathy.  The short summary is that people - on average - have a great deal of concern when presented with the plight of one individual.  Increase that number to two and people lose nearly half (!) of the concern they had in the first case.  Beyond two people their empathy is basically non-existent.

It's been speculated that this behavior is a defense mechanism from our tribal days, but I don't believe they reached a conclusion about that.  The program was presented in the context of why so many people know they should care about Darfur, TIbet, etc., but just can't seem to muster the emotion.  I thought it was really interesting and it possibly provides some insight into your experience Matt.


Great post Matt (4.00 / 2)
Sometimes Politics is a game, but it's always more than that.  

About another one of our Neighbors (0.00 / 0)
Mike Shor is a DC activist & co-founder of DC for Obama.  Two days ago he had a massive stroke and is in a coma.  I'm told he is brain dead and is not expected to physically live much longer.  I wrote a slightly modified version of  the following to a group of Mike's friends with DC for Obama and DC for Democracy, a DFA affiliate.  He read Open Left but never posted.  I thought somehow it seemed appropriate to add this to Matt's personal and very eloquent post.
_________________________

By my count, Mike Shor made 11 out-of-state trips to help in the Obama Campaign.  Our thoughts and prayers are with Mike & his family.  There is no better way to honor Mike than by working in any of the 50 states for Barack Obama.  In the end, it's about hopes & dreams, not money or even votes.  

Mike was so very proud of the way that the activism has spread from DC to South Carolina & Ohio like a fire on a windy day.  Mike help inspire the new leaders and hundreds of others who never knew him.  Just think of all the young Obama staffers who met Mike in Iowa & New Hampshire & South Carolina & Nevada -- who thought "Who is that old guy & how did he get all that energy?" [Mike is in his 70's]. I remember canvassing with Mike so late one evening in Manchester, NH that we could not even  read the house numbers, and I was tired & cold.  With anyone else I would have suggested that we call it a night & turn in our canvassing forms a bit incomplete but Mike would have given me a piece of his mind at even the thought of leaving the job undone.  He didn't hesitate to let the New Hampshire staff know that he thought they were sort of slackers by not starting canvassing until 10:00 AM on a Saturday.

I had a few arguments with Mike since I first met him in 2003 when I was for Wes Clark & he was for Howard Dean.  The arguments were about tactics, never values.  His commitment to change was greater than anyone and I'm really sorry that we will have to finish the job without him.  Of course, there is still hope for a miracle for Mike but in any case the inspiration that Mike helped ignite in us -- not just to be for change, but to do something about it -- will live on.
 


Democracy's roots in empathy (0.00 / 0)
I cannot pretend that because the body was in front of me it was more meaningful than the senseless deaths happening around the world.  And it's equally cynical to take the approach that all we are doing is preventing tragedy, since there is so much joy and wonder that each of us within our communities create when we take responsibility for each other.

Your comment here, Matt, is powerful, and it says much more than some may know or suspect. Because the politics we practice, democratic politics, was born in the empathy you speak of.

Thanks.


Excellent post . . . (0.00 / 0)
. . . nothing to add.

Evangelicals can relate to this! (0.00 / 0)
Matt,

This is an eloquent piece!

Progressives need to find ways to let politically conservative evangelicals see that these values are the values that drive our support of progressive policies.

If conservative evangelicals could accept that these are the values that drive most progressives, both groups could engage in constructive policy discussions, rather than being distracted by attacks on the stereotypical motives each group so often attributes to the other!


I saw it from the 42 (0.00 / 0)
Matt,

I saw the bloody body under the white sheet from the window of the 42 bus as it stopped in front of your building that morning.  

Now, the 42 is a notoriously see-and-be-seen bus ride during the 9 - 5 rush hours.  All of us liberal, bo-ho, urbanites get picked up from our respective Mt Pleasant and Adams Morgan condos to be dropped near our K Street corridor destination.  At any given time at least 25% of riders are reading their issue of The Economist.

So as the bus picked up riders at that stop at that time, and those of us facing East saw the police, yellow tape, and most importantly, that dead body, we all collectively gasped in terror.  And then, less than a moment later, without another word, back to heads down, silent reading.

Let's just hope that all of those people took in the humanity of the situation as politically as you do.

Shana      


Interesting (0.00 / 0)
but did you say anything to the poor guy?

Surely you didn't just walk past the door and go out to run.


Why Politics | 9 comments
USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox