Time to reopen SCHIP?

by: Daniel De Groot

Wed May 14, 2008 at 21:52


Hotair:

Tom Cole, chairman of the National Republican Congressional Committee, held a press teleconference today in response to the third straight special-election loss this year. Losing Roger Wicker's Mississippi seat stunned the House GOP caucus, which now has three more seats to recover in what looks like a very bad year for Republicans.

They're reeling:


"My sense is--we had a leadership meeting this morning--the sense of the group was we need to pull together as a team. The message of a candidate being 'too liberal' or 'too out of sync' is not what voters want to hear...It just didn't work. But what does work, though, is a realization that the paradigm has been shifted. This country is tired of excuses and doesn't want to hear about 'too liberal' or 'too this' or 'too that.' What they want to hear is solutions."

House Republican Conference Chairman Rep. Adam Putnam of Florida agreed with [Deputy Whip] Cantor's analysis.

Holy crap, when was the last time top Republicans questioned the wisdom of using "too liberal" as a campaign tactic?  The GOP have been rocked.  There's rumours of firing the leadership.  3 more Democratic votes in the House (and 3 less Republicans).

I smell opportunity.

Daniel De Groot :: Time to reopen SCHIP?
I picked SCHIP as the most obvious big-ticket bill that failed due to a close vote in the House vice the usual obstruction in the Senate.  

It's probably not the only thing worth trying again, and I think even GOP senators will be feeling a little uneasy about the ceaseless roadblock obstructionism they've been practising to date.  So even a few things that failed in close cloture votes in the Senate would be worth another try.  I'm sure the new Junior Senator from Missouri, who just saw his former House seat go to a Democrat might be a tad more pliable than he was yesterday.

Now the closest vote on veto-override was 273-156 which put it 13 "yeas" short of override.  Childers and Cazayoux explicitly and prominently support SCHIP expansion in their campaign web sites.  Foster was more generally for UHC so I imagine he's on board for SCHIP.  So that narrows the margin to 276-153 at least.  So we'd only need to flip another 10 votes to override.

With the GOP reeling I'm sure even some of the staunchest nay votes in the darkest red districts must be sweating a little.  Doubting the surety of their re-election just a little.  Back in 2007 they could assure themselves that Democrats would trip-up and the Republican situation would improve.  It hasn't and the trendline isn't good.  

I think Pelosi should test the waters again.  I think they're cracking, more from that Politico link above:


Asked if Republicans need to break with President Bush, Cantor dodged the question, noting that "this election is going to be about John McCain."

Of course, McCain voted Nay too so by all means let's tie Bush, the House Republicans and McCain together with a giant SCHIP ribbon.  

Congress hasn't exactly gotten any more popular lately, but taking advantage of a weakened foe who are openly questioning themselves would be worth trying.  This isn't just politicking of course, because passing SCHIP would be a valuable step in the right direction towards UHC and a much-needed untainted domestic policy victory for the Democratic Congress (minimum wage was passed with the first Iraq supplemental which kind of dampened enthusiasm for the measure).


Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
That's a really good idea (4.00 / 1)
I was impressed with Democratic politiking on the initial SCHIP votes, but if I remember correctly their attempts to keep it in the media spotlight failed badly after the veto. I don't know enough about House procedure, but I think it is also important to figure out ways to keep the issue high profile.

I support John McCain because children are too healthy anyway.

And yeah, by all means (4.00 / 1)
lets get John McCain on the record again siding with George W. Bush on an economic issue. Imagine the 527 groups running ads in the districts of vulnerable Republicans explaining that right now the representative is working with John McCain and George Bush to prevent children from seeing doctors.

It's hitting approximately 11 bird with one stone.

I support John McCain because children are too healthy anyway.


What's The Worst Thing That Could Happen? (4.00 / 2)
It could fail by one vote, I guess, giving us the fewest possible GOP Congresscritiers to use it against.

If that's the worst the could happen, I say do it every day of the week, and twice on Sundays.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


That could be even more effective. (4.00 / 4)
It could fail by one vote, I guess, giving us the fewest possible GOP Congresscritiers to use it against.

If it failed by one vote, every single one of those Republicans could be berated with, "My opponent singlehandedly stopped your children from getting healthcare.  If he had voted for the SCHIP bill it would have passed, instead he cast the deciding vote against it and stood with President Bush."  I think that that is a particularly brutal argument.

That said, I hope that they do bring the bill up again and it actually passes.

We PTDB! Now, let's pass Grayson's Public Option Act!


[ Parent ]
You're Right! (0.00 / 0)
There IS no worst-case scenario!

Sweeeeeet!

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


[ Parent ]
This is how the country moves left (4.00 / 2)
When we get them to question their basic assumption about demonizing the left, and instead it becomes about the best ideas. Of course, we had to beat them first- I hope this is a lesson that Obama can now understand first hand. that only beating makes them pliable.

Great minds think alike! (0.00 / 0)
I was just thinking the same thing today... it puts the republicans on the spot with independents vs. their base... and then there's the veto override...

It could be gold for us... but, I bet it doesn't happen... it involves some risk "(however small).  As they say, when the GOP is committing suicide, don't get in the way... I'm sure our "leadership" will just let things ride out until the fall.

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


I'll Be The Cynic (4.00 / 1)
Was it Carville who said "when your opponent is drowning throw him a [censored] anchor"?

SCHIP is a good program and needs to pass. But we need fewer Republicans even more. It could mean an end to Iraq, a start to universal (or near universal) health care and restoring the rule of law.

So the last thing I'd want is Republicans, when they are drowning, to suddenly be able to claim they did something popular and good.


couple thoughts (4.00 / 2)
I had this same doubt, thinking about the bit in the West Wing where Josh is proud he got some money out of Republicans for something or other, and Bruno rips him apart because it would be better to have the issue to campaign on instead.

However, that said:
1) That is pretty cynical and it's governing to win power, rather governing to achieve the common good, so I have a hard time swallowing it if there's a real chance of passing SCHIP now (carpe diem and all that)

2) On the more cynical side, I'll add that health care has fallen in terms of issue importance as the economy has taken over.  So SCHIP might not be the club it was awhile back anyway.

3) Kristol's memo from 1993 still rings true.  His argument was that Republicans had to kill not compromise on the Clinton health care plan because any form of UHC would revitalize the Democratic party brand and remind voters government works and all sorts of good things Republicans would rather they not think about.  So having millions of kids get health care and their grateful parents feeling like "finally Washington did something for me" could only help progressive politics.



[ Parent ]
Plus... (4.00 / 1)
They voted against it before they voted for it.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox