Obama still associating with known academics, diplomats

by: Karl Blumenthal

Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 14:44


Barack Obama will put his Foreign Policy vision front and center tomorrow in an address to the annual AIPAC Policy Conference in Washington, D.C.  A long way from being the fresh-faced upstart too green to compete on national security, Obama is now charged with presenting the Conference with a reasoned alternative to the neanderthal worldview endorsed on Monday by John McCain.  

What follows Obama to AIPAC is the consistent effort among Republicans and the similarly afflicted to tie the change agent's campaign staff (or failing that, anyone he has met) to anti-Semitic nonsense.  The lame effort hasn't yet forced Obama to dissociate himself from notorious terrorist-sympathizers like former National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski or Columbia University cultural scholar Rashid Khalidi.  

Sean Hannity is left clamoring in the meantime for a repudiation of Louis Farrakhan, having missed the last three.  

A timeline awaits you in the extended entry...

Karl Blumenthal :: Obama still associating with known academics, diplomats
August 25, 2007:  On Bloomberg Television's "Political Capital With Al Hunt," Barack Obama's foreign policy vision gets a boost from former National Security Advisor, Zbigniew Brzezinski:

I think there is the need for a fundamental rethinking of how we conduct world affairs, and Obama seems to me to have both the guts and the intelligence to address that issue, and to change the nature of America's relationship with the world.

Sep 11, 2007:  Clinton supporter Alan Dershowitz attempts to reverse the momentum of Brzezinski's pseudo-endorsement by reminding everyone that the former Carter diplomat has praised arguments raised in the book, "The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy" (co-written by his Harvard colleague, Stephen Walt):

It is a tremendous mistake for Barack Obama to select as a foreign policy adviser the one person in public life who has chosen to support a bigoted book.

Confronted with the fact that Obama and Brzezinski actually disagree on the book's merits--the campaign having issued a statement describing arguments in the book as "just wrong"--Dershowitz then raises the bar:

I'm glad he's done that, but now he has to dissociate himself from Brzezinski.

Jan 15, 2008: Op-Ed columnist Richard Cohen introduces an unsettling line of connection between Obama's church and veteran anti-Semite Louis Farrakhan:

In 1982, [Trinity United Church] launched Trumpet Newsmagazine...Last year, it gave the Dr. Jeremiah A. Wright Jr. Trumpeter Award to a man it said "truly epitomized greatness." That man is Louis Farrakhan.

Maybe for Wright and some others, Farrakhan "epitomized greatness." For most Americans, though, Farrakhan epitomizes bigotry, particularly in the form of anti-Semitism. Over the years, he has compiled an awesome record of offensive statements, even denigrating the Holocaust by falsely attributing it to Jewish cooperation with Hitler -- "They helped him get the Third Reich on the road."  His history is a rancid stew of lies.

Jan 21, 2008:  Able to distinguish between the two men and their respective politics, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) welcomes Obama's strong statement of condemnation of Farrakhan.

Jan 23, 2008:  Hoping still to earn a hit amidst the dubious spray of associations, fringe right-wingers like "American Thinker" Ed Lasky hop on the anti-Israel bandwagon:

Several advisors [sic] have evidenced a history of suspicion and worse toward Israel. One of his advisors in particular, Robert Malley, clearly warrants attention, as does the reasoning that led him to being chosen by Barack Obama.

That "reasoning" likely included Malley's extensive list of diplomatic bone-fides (Special Assistant to the President for Arab-Israeli Affairs, Director for Democracy, Human Rights and Humanitarian Affairs at the National Security Council...).  However, Lasky is more compelled by the fact that Malley's father was a Syrian nationalist:

Malley has seemingly followed in his father's footsteps: he represents the next generation of anti-Israel activism. Through his writings he has served as a willing propagandist, bending the truth (and more) to serve an agenda that is marked by anti-Israel bias; he heads a group of Middle East policy advisers for a think-tank funded (in part) by anti-Israel billionaire activist George Soros; and now is on the foreign policy staff of a leading Presidential contender. Each step up the ladder seems to be a step closer towards his goal of empowering radicals and weakening the ties between American and our ally Israel.

Feb 25, 2008:  The Tennessee Republican Party issues a press release entitled "Anti-Semites for Obama":

The Tennessee Republican Party today joins a growing chorus of Americans concerned about the future of the nation of Israel, the only stable democracy in the Middle East, if Sen. Barack Hussein Obama is elected president of the United States.

emphasis mine

Feb 26, 2008:  In their nationally televised debate, Hillary Clinton suggests that Barack Obama has not in fact dissociated himself sufficiently from Louis Farrakhan:

I would not be associated with people who said such inflammatory and untrue charges against either Israel or Jewish people in our country.

In response, Obama:

If the word 'reject' Senator Clinton feels is stronger than the word 'denounce,' then I'm happy to concede the point, and I would reject and denounce.

March 26, 2008:  Having wasted precious time on the Jeremiah Wright fiasco, wingnuts return to insinuating that top Obama advisers are radical anti-Semites.  Matt Brooks, executive director of something called the Republican Jewish Coalition, lobbies:

By choosing to have a military adviser and national campaign co-chairman like General McPeak, serious questions and doubts are once again being raised about Senator Obama's positions and judgment on Middle East issues.

You may remember Merrill A. McPeak as the Silver Star winning Vietnam veteran who went on to be Air Force Chief of Staff during Operations Desert Shield and Desert Storm, but Brooks took the General's remarks on the political challenge of conceding Israeli settlements in the West Bank and Gaza as signs of something far more sinister in his nature:

Rather than putting the blame where it belongs - on the Palestinian leadership and their continued reliance on terror - General McPeak finds it more convenient to blame American Jewry and their perceived influence.

We call on Senator Obama to immediately remove McPeak from his campaign leadership role and as a key adviser.

April 10, 2008:  Friends of Rashid Khalidi bid the Palestinian scholar farewell as he prepares to depart Chicago for an appointment at Columbia University.  Barack Obama attends, despite the outrage of Sean Hannity.

May 30, 2008:  Unsatisfied by (or maybe just unaware of) Obama's condemnation, rejection and denunciation of Louis Farrakhan, Hannity "asks" a guest on his Fox News show:

Would you go to a church that honors a lifetime achievement award with Louis Farrakhan, a guy that we showed earlier says 'he's my brother and that we're friends and that he's a lover of truth?'

It's OK to be friends with a Father that praises an anti-Semite and racist Louis Farrakhan? It's OK to be friends with Rev. Wright? All these things - none of this bothers you, none of this at all... Don't you have a moral obligation to stand against anti-Semitism and racism?

May 31, 2008:  In his ironically titled series, "The Real Barack Obama," Hannity continues the guilt-by-association ploy, but mistakes himself for "Jewish voters":

As Barack Obama continues to grapple with his foreign policy vision, Jewish voters...are clearly concerned about the Presidential candidate's growing list of anti-Israeli supporters like Hamas and their influence on Obama's middle east policy.

Calling in for back-up, Hannity welcomes guest Daniel Pipes to provide insight into Obama's Mideast policy.  Pipes' virulent opposition to Palestinian statehood doesn't surface in the report, which instead focuses mainly on Obama's familiarity with Rashid Khalidi.  Their proximity on the boards of Arab American charitable foundations is apparently damning:

I think the financial relationship between Khalidi and Obama is important because it points to the relationship not just being social/intellectual, but having a deeper base-that they are people who are working together towards the same end.

Now that might actually be the scariest thing I've heard all election season--people working together towards the same end...


Tags: , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Still, you can't deny Obama has a 'Jewish problem', (4.00 / 2)
if by 'problem' you mean, 'might not break 80% of the Jewish vote.'

I long for the day Obama does as well among Christians as among Jews. Part of me finds all this 'Is Obama anti-Jewish' stuff deeply offensive. (How stupid do they think Jews are? Do we get no points for the brainy nerd stereotype?) But another part feels the same way I do about Republicans dumping money into New Jersey, trying to turn it red. Yeah, go ahead: keep working on turning the Jewish vote. That's definitely where you should be investing your talking points.

Though I do sometimes wonder if we in the netroots shouldn't try addressing this nonsense. Get all the big Jewish bloggers (I mean, if there are any, who knows?) to try to force Obama to renounce Joe Lieberman, on the grounds that Lieberman is bad for the Jews. (Which has the lovely added benefit of being true.)  


"where you should be investing your talking points." (0.00 / 0)
Ah, if only there was a limited supply. Sadly, I think Republican talking points are a plentiful and renewable resource.

I support John McCain because children are too healthy anyway.

[ Parent ]
Thanks For Posting This (4.00 / 2)
Though "Timeline" is a somewhat anemic a term for what you've put together.

What I find truly disturbing is that once again we are witnessing a process of profound projection, as Christian Zionists have come to play a larger and larger role in "pro-Israeli" politics, and McCain himself is deeply entwined with them.

As I noted in my diary yesterday, "Hagee: Anti-Christ Is Gay, German & At Least Partly Jewish--But Hagee Wants To Be Jewish Instead!", Christian Zionists--at least those from the Word of Faith camp represented by Hagee--not only relish contemplating the mass extermination of the Jews (except those who convert), they also want to become us, steal our identities.

I quote from and link to a rather lucid diary at Talk2Action that talks about how dispensational philo-Semitism is not all that different from classica anti-Semitism.  Here is part that I didn't quote:

Historically philo-semitism has been a term to describe those groups that were tolerant of their Jewish population for whatever reason, whether that tolerance was based on acceptance or something less benign. However, apocalyptic philo-Semitism is not acceptance or even tolerance of the humanity of Jews or Israel; it is the other edge of the sword of anti-Semitism.  Both anti-Semites and apocalyptic philo-Semites are obsessed with Jews and Judaism, and consumed with the imagined role that Jews play in world events. Both view Jews as supernatural in their abilities to alter the course of the world and both stereotype Jews in a way that suits their own goals but has little to do with Jewish reality.  The difference is that dispensationalists see a possibility for eventual redemption if Jews will only fulfill their assigned role in the end-times drama, and they are driven by the belief that their generation is the one to finally bring about this miraculous transformation of Judaism.

One cannot blame previous generations of Jews for choosing apocalyptic philo-Semitism over overt anti-Semitism.  Often in history there were no other choices for survival.  But the great tragedy of the current relationship between some Jewish leaders and apocalyptic Christian Zionism is that there was another choice.  Jews have been accepted in American society as something other than a supernatural pawn for many years.  It is the humanity of American Jews which is being stripped away every time a Jewish leader stands on stage with an apocalyptic televangelist.

Likewise, Israel's humanity is being stripped from her.  Historically, Jewish Zionism aimed to humanize Jews in the eyes of the rest of the world.  One of the goals of giving Jews a homeland was the removal of the supernatural mantle and associated horrors that had been repeatedly placed upon Jews and Judaism for hundreds of years.  Hagee and others have spent the last three decades reversing this process by turning the clock back to a time when Jews were seen as nonhuman players whose actions, or refusal to act, manipulate the course of the rest of the world.

I think it's fairly transparent that a good deal of the baseless hysteria about Obama is simply projection on the part of those who have embraced those motivated by a worldview that quite openly shares so much in common with classic anti-Semitism.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


Right on, plus: (4.00 / 3)
Let's not forgot the third leg of the stool!  Phil Gramm and the truest kind of globalists that remain privileged in the McCain campaign make for hilarious bedfellows with the likes of Mike Huckabee, John Hagee, Joe Lieberman and John McCain

Very interesting stuff to watch.

John McCain: "I do not support Roe versus Wade. It should be overturned."


[ Parent ]
I've Just Got To Wonder (0.00 / 0)
If Gramm wears Anti-Christ t-shirts under his 3-piece suits.

"Anti-Christ, Superstar," perhaps?

Of course, the Protestant financial types, from small town to overseas investers, have reliably been notorious hotbeds of anti-Semitism.  So, nothing new there, either.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


[ Parent ]
AIPAC is a bigger problem in the world than Louis Farrakhan (0.00 / 0)
and it's a problem with the parts of American politics in which people continue to pretend otherwise.

Don't forget (4.00 / 1)
Noah Pollak sliming Samantha Powers in Commentary.

Then there is the amazingly damning photographic evidence of Obama having the gall to actually hold a conversation with Edward Said ten years ago.  I guess Said is dead so he can't be an adviser, but still...  

John McCain: Health insurance for low income children represents an "unfunded liability."


USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox