Opening the Day: Obama's Presumptuous and the Media's Sickeing Dishonesty

by: Matt Stoller

Wed Jul 30, 2008 at 11:04


Some days you just have a hard time dealing with politics.

  • The big story today is going to be Obama's presumptuous quote, which is of course clipped and highly misleading.  Journalist Jonathan Weisman has a long history of doing this kind of smear of Democrats.  Weisman's most famous quote is 'Fuck Brad Delong', something he wrote in an email after the economist Brad Delong wrote a critical piece about one of his articles on Bush's fiscal policy.

  • There's a piece in the Wall Street Journal today going after Kevin Martin, the Republican FCC Chairman who bravely took on the cable industry, which has started to filter the internet.  It contains gem-like quotes such as the following.

    By "majority" he means himself and the two Democrats on the five-member panel.

    Yes, that is in fact a majority, even though it includes Democrats, the other major party in American politics.  I'll have more on this hit piece soon.

  • This is why cable news is important, not because it has a big audience.

    The Times's Jim Rutenberg reports that the McCain campaign's ads - the most recent one criticized Mr. Obama for canceling a visit with American troops in Germany - are getting viewed on local television across the country.

    The result, Mr. Rutenberg writes, is "a public relations coup that allowed him to show his toughest campaign advertisement of the year - one widely panned as misleading - to millions of people, largely free, through television news media hungry for political news with arresting visual imagery."

    It's not a bad thing that millions of people are told untruths, it's a coup!

  • The advertising wars are interesting.

    According to the study, Mr. Obama has spent $27 million on advertisements since he effectively cinched the nomination in early June; Mr. McCain has spent $21 million since then. The Republican Party has chipped in another $3.6 million for ads during the same time period.

    A curious exception: the study, based on data from the Campaign Media Analysis Group, a political advertising monitoring firm, shows Mr. McCain has yet to advertise in Florida, where Mr. Obama has spent $5 million on advertisements. Mr. Obama is also outspending Mr. McCain in Virginia, $2.7 million to $1.5 million.

    Mr. Obama has pushed his advertising unchallenged into states that are generally considered so safely Republican that neither side traditionally bothers advertising in them during presidential campaigns, such as Alaska, Georgia and North Carolina.

What are you reading?

Matt Stoller :: Opening the Day: Obama's Presumptuous and the Media's Sickeing Dishonesty

Tags: , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
so on these ads (4.00 / 1)
It was pretty predictable that cable news would show the ad for free since we've seen it before (Swiftboats, 3AM).

But what can the campaign do?  Should there have been a 30 sec response ad that the news would feel obliged (or would want) to play too?  Maybe that would not work, but these situations are ridiculous.  

New Jersey politics at Blue Jersey.


Slinging mud and trading coarse insults is a good Barack strategy (0.00 / 0)
"Elite" and "arrogant" don't fit with pit-bull attacks. He should start and never stop. Call McCain everything in the book. Not cleverly either.  

[ Parent ]
On Kevin Martin ... (0.00 / 0)
don't get too impressed with the guy .. just becaue he is great on one issue ... doesn't mean you should get all giddy about the guy .. yeah .. he deserves props for this one issue .. but you can't let up on the pressure

Abercrombie (D-HI) (0.00 / 0)
I'm pretty sure I read about his efforts here at OpenLeft, but now he is on CNN.com live with an "Energy Plan Briefing" and he is denouncing both parties.  WTF?


New Jersey politics at Blue Jersey.

I"m in Missouri right now (0.00 / 0)
and it's pretty clear by now that McCain is outspending Obama here by a pretty wide margin, at least on TV.  

I saw an Obama ad yesterday (0.00 / 0)
This was the first one I had seen since the primary.

Re the symbolic quote: I am going to cry. You even have to take the clipped version out of context to make it presumptuous. What has much of the netroots been seeing in Obama all this time other than a symbol?  

Darkness has a hunger that's insatiable, and lightness has a call that's hard to hear.  


[ Parent ]
New VP name (0.00 / 0)
Trapper John at Kos, who predicted John McCain would get the nod when others were counting him out, guesses that Obama might pick Tom Daschle as his VP.  Daschle was one of the very first to sign on with Obama, and former staff members make up much of the core of Obama's staff.  The two are close, with Daschle somewhat of a mentor.  Daschle is part of the pre-Clinton Dem Party, and was the Majority/Minority leader in the first Bush term.  

He has recently been a lobbyist, and his wife is a lobbyist.  He is a very controversial figure in these parts (see post by Matt), perhaps epitomizing the idea of "post-partisanship" that ironically is so polarizing here.

Before everyone cuts the idea to pieces, I want to reprint Mike Lux's comment to that post, since he has actually worked with the man and may be unavailable to chime in:

First is just a factual error in Matt's post: Gephardt was the one who undercut Biden's negotiations to pass a much tougher resolution [on the Iraq War], Daschle was very much on Biden's side on that.
The other is a more general point. Tom Daschle, in my experience with him on capitol hill, was one of the most decent and honorable, and yes, progressive Dem leaders that I have dealt with up there. If you actually look at the way he held that caucus together to stand up to Bush on a wide range of issues, it's actually pretty remarkable- I won't go into the details I personally know about here, but perhaps I should do a post about it someday, because it's mostly behind the scenes stuff that very few people know about. (snip)

There's a whole lot of allegations in Matt's post, and I'm not going to argue them point by point. The general topic of Democrats becoming corporate lobbyists is an important one, and I find myself somewhat more mixed on it than Matt. It's obviously something I haven't chosen to do myself, and I'm not a fan of Dems doing it, but I don't think it's all as black and white as Matt suggests. Some Dems, Daschle included, specifically won't lobby for companies and issues they don't like.

What I see Daschle being able to do is help Obama negotiate things through Congress by peeling off enough of the remaining GOP semi-moderates, such as the Ladies from Maine, Voino, Specter and McCain's replacement (I'm betting he will retire if he loses), while Obama appeals to the public at large.  Daschle is the closest to LBJ (in terms of knowing how to work the Senate) that we have, without LBJ's insecurities and other faults, and the Senate, everyone agrees, is where the obstacles will lie.  He certainly would fulfill Obama's criterion of helping him govern, more than any of the other mentions.

The more I think about it the more sense it makes.  

John McCain--He's not who you think he is.


Put him on the whitehouse staff (4.00 / 2)
Just don't pick him for VP

John McCain doesn't care about Vets.



[ Parent ]
While there is very good logic in what you say ... (0.00 / 0)
I wonder if Obama would go that route for one reason ..  who would come after him? .. Does he want someone to have a leg up in succeeding him come 2016? .. I'd be hard pressed he'd go the Bush route as far as VP goes(meaning not leaving a succession plan in place)

[ Parent ]
there need to be strong "contrast" ads (4.00 / 1)
All of the following about 100% True and issues based:

1.  McCain wants to take away your employer-paid health care plan and make you buy your own instead.

2.  McCain says he wants to stay in Iraq for 100 years and that he wants the troops out in 16 months.

3.  McCain thinks current Social Security is a disgrace and thinks it should be privatized.

4.  McCain says he doesn't know much about the economy, and that Bush's economy is strong.

Maybe they are waiting for September, but I'd like to start seeing them now.

McCain ran to the crazy right in the primaries and now has flip-flopped on everything.



New Jersey politics at Blue Jersey.


Same as the swifties (0.00 / 0)
The result, Mr. Rutenberg writes, is "a public relations coup that allowed him to show his toughest campaign advertisement of the year - one widely panned as misleading - to millions of people, largely free, through television news media hungry for political news with arresting visual imagery."

This is exactly how the swift boat ads got so much air time.

Conduct your own interview of Sarah Palin!


No Florida ads? (0.00 / 0)
I'm seeing more McCain than Obama ads in Florida. That study must be wrong.

Conduct your own interview of Sarah Palin!

Hasia Diner, Jews of the United States (0.00 / 0)
I schnorred this from the Wash.U. Campus Store two years ago already, so Matt may have already read it. Important to get a sense of how American Jews worked as a broad community in American history and how being American was always very important to them. From the O perspective it is very easy to see the hashkafic conflicts in the Jewish community without thinking about how it is embedded in an American context.

Tisha B'Av August 10--don't forget.  

Darkness has a hunger that's insatiable, and lightness has a call that's hard to hear.  


USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox