AT&T Lied About Censorship of Pearl Jam

by: Matt Stoller

Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 10:55


Welcome Buzzflash readers. Check out more of our  work on Net Neutrality on Open Left, and also be sure to visit our front page for more of our other content--Chris Bowers

This matters.

A crew member who worked on a show webcast by AT&T confirmed that there was a policy in place to remove artists' political comments from shows before they were webcast.

"I can definitively say that at a previous event where AT&T was covering the show, the instructions were to shut it down if there was any swearing or if anybody starts getting political. Granted, they didn't say to shut down any Anti-Bush comments or anything specific to any point of view or party, but 'getting political' was mentioned."

This directly contradicts AT&T's earlier statements that the censorship of Pearl Jam was an accident.

Wired reporter Eliot Van Buskirk goes on to point out that AT&T Chief Randall L. Stephenson is also the Vice-Chairman of the President's National Security Telecommunications Advisory Committee.

And here are Stephenson's political donations prior to 2006.  Yes, he's a Bush donor.  But that's not all.  Here are the rest.

12/28/1999 Rep. Dennis Hastert ( R-IL) $500
10/26/2001 Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) $1,000
3/14/2002 Keep Our Majority PAC (run by fmr Speaker Dennis Hastert (R-IL) $2,000
4/18/2002 Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) $1,000
10/11/2002 Keep Our Majority PAC (run by fmr Speaker Dennis Hastert (R-IL)) $1,000
6/2/2003 Sen. Sam Brownback (R-KS) $250
6/21/2003 Sen. Christopher S 'Kit' Bond (R-MO) $250
7/18/2003 President George W. Bush (R) $500
7/23/2003 President George W. Bush (R) $1,500
1/23/2004 Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchinson (R-TX) $500
3/17/2004 Rebecca Armendariz Klein, Republican candidate for Congress (TX) $250
5/3/2004 Rep. Pete Sessions (R-TX) $500
5/25/2004 Republican National Cmte $500
7/14/2004 Kirk Humphreys, Republican Candidate for Senate (OK primary), $250
7/28/2004 Republican National Cmte $2,500
8/4/2004 Rebecca Armendariz Klein, Republican candidate for Congress (TX) $250
10/22/2004 Republican National Cmte $1,000
11/29/2004 Rep. Joe Barton, (R-TX) $1,000
1/27/2005 Sen. John Ensign (R-NV) $500
7/17/2005 Rep. Tom DeLay (R-TX) $1,000
8/9/2005 Rep. Pete Sessions, (R-TX) $500
9/20/2005 Sen. George Allen (R) $500
10/20/2005 Keep Our Majority PAC (run by fmr Speaker Dennis Hastert (R-IL) $1,000
11/9/2005 Rep. Joe Barton (R-TX) $500
12/12/2005 Denise Bode, Republican candidate for Congress (OK) $1,000
3/31/2006 Rep. Mike Ferguson (R-NJ) $1,000
6/13/2006 Denise Bode, Republican candidate for Congress (OK) $1,000
7/27/2006 Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-TX) $500
9/22/2006 National Republican Congressional Cmte $1,000

And here's one of his statements on net neutrality and AT&T's control of the internet.

SBC Chief Operating Officer Randall Stephenson was quoted in an industry newsletter saying, "We're going to control the video on our network. The content guys will have to make a deal with us." Stephenson's statement was widely interpreted to mean that his company intends to block on its broadband network the video content of any companies or producers who have not struck a deal with SBC.

Paging Congressman Markey...

Matt Stoller :: AT&T Lied About Censorship of Pearl Jam

Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
That lines up w/ the LATimes report (0.00 / 0)
that AT&T had censored performers well before the incident @ Lollapalooza:

In response to fans who claimed that the audio silencing of Vedder's sung remarks about Bush at Lollapalooza were not unique in the history of AT&T's Blue Room live webcasts, an AT&T spokeswoman on Friday said: "It's not our intent to edit political comments in webcasts on the attblueroom.com. Unfortunately, it has happened in the past in a handful of cases. We have taken steps to ensure that it won't happen again."

The statement from spokeswoman Tiffany Nels did not specify what those steps were, nor did it mention what performers were involved.

One fan who contacted The Times Friday said AT&T's Blue Room webcast bleeped the sound during performances by the Flaming Lips and the John Butler Trio at the Bonnaroo Festival in Tennessee in June.

A public forum on Butler's website, www.johnbutlertrio.com, includes a discussion among fans about several audio gaps during a spoken introduction to the song "Gov Did Nothin'," which included references critical of the government's response to Hurricane Katrina.

A representative for the Flaming Lips said the band has received reports from fans of some corruption of the webcast of its Bonnaroo set but added that the band had not been able to review the specifics as of Friday for this story and would not comment.

Twice makes a coincidence. Three times makes a pattern. If AT&T, w/ no policy, accidentally censored performers three times, what's its explanation?


AT&T (0.00 / 0)
Aren't they a wholly owned subsidiary of the NSA? Some surprise.

AT&T Lied About Censorship of Pearl Jam (0.00 / 0)
I really get PO when I think about the lack of choice I have at work for Internet connection. After seeing where and who my money went to in the political arena makes me sick. It would be different if there was some kind of equality in the giving, but there was not any appearance of AT&T trying to be fair and appease the other half of the political spectrum that they service. Maybe I should write the FCC and AT&T and maybe a letter to the editor.

USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox