We got a bunch of coverage for the Bush Dog Democrat campaign, and I'll go into reactions on Monday and what they mean. Let's just say the top two concern trolls were Fox News and their right-wing blogospheric toenail clippings, and anonymous Democratic senior strategists in the Politico (which did write a good article on the campaign).
UPDATE:Archpundit, a terrific and experienced Illinois blogger and activist, has some interesting things to say about Bush Dog Democrats Melissa Bean and Dan Lipinski. Larry is more politically cautious than I am, and tends to situate his politics in much less ideological and much more partisan terms. It's a useful creative tension, and he's a Bean supporter (I am not). Here's his read.
In the case of IL-8 we aren't likely to get a full throated progressive, but it's a significant problem that Bean has voted for issues trying to appear moderate that do not have the support of the political center even in her district. More than that, the 38 people Matt list are mostly in Republican leaning Districts, but even these votes aren't in the center of these Districts-they are well to the right.
With Bean this is especially relevant. It's true that her district is more concerned with taxes and budgetary issues than many others, but neither the bankruptcy bill nor the FISA changes are popular. They do get the attention of the Tribune which Bean uses to demonstrate she is a 'moderate' and so she ends up seeking their approval on everything. She's not going to change the triangulation pattern-it's a winning strategy in that District, but I think she can be moved towards targeting different issues that aren't nearly as destructive as these. In other cases, we just need to take people out-like Lipinski who is in a 59% Kerry District and votes horribly on just about everything.
However, in the case of Bean and presumably her consultants, we need her to be a strong voice for basic Constitutional Protections-protections gutted by the new version of FISA. We need her to not be voting for a bill that makes those in financial trouble because of sickness or the loss of a job even more vulnerable. We need her to stand up against torture. We need her to stand up against an incredibly unpopular President who not only got us into an unnecessary war, but continues to epically mismanage the war. When she does support such policies, she undermines the reason for Democratic control of Congress and the Presidency, but also, and more importantly, the country.
In a District like Illinois 8 I would never advocate a Democrat try and be Jan Schakowsky. I'll give them slack on tax and budgetary issues. I'll give them some slack on social issues to some degree. I'll give them slack on trade to some degree. But I won't give them slack on issues of fundamental fairness and Constitutional Rights. These are winning issues in all, but the very most conservative areas and even IL-8 isn't that conservative.
STATE BLOGS
