House Republican Strategy on Auto Bailout Bill

by: Matt Stoller

Wed Dec 10, 2008 at 17:07


The Republican House membership might try a vicious strategy to stop the auto bailout bill.  Typically, bills go through the rules committee in the House, which controls floor time and which amendments are allowed to be proposed and voted on.  However, Republicans use a tactic called a 'Motion to Recommit', which is a motion allowing the minority to add an amendment or kill the bill outright by sending it back to the committee out of which it was reported.  During the Delay era, Republicans were ruthless about MTRs, and they were routine matters that went down by party line pretty much every single time.  During the Pelosi era, Republicans propose MTRs and Blue Dogs often threaten to vote with the Republicans, so they are used to overwhelm Pelosi's control of the chamber.

Tonight, Republicans in the House might use the MTR to add all sorts of nasty stuff to the bailout.  Below is an email circulating in the House about what they might do.  Right now, the only amendment the Rules Committee authorized for a vote is one that adds oversight to the TARP program, but as you'll see, there's ample opportunity for Republicans to get very nasty if they can rustle up the votes from wayward Democrats (probably Blue Dogs).

The Rules Committee reported out a structured rule for the auto bailout bill.  There is one hour of general debate on the bill, and the rule provides for an MTR (more on that below).

One amdt from Mr. LaTourette was made in order that was fully supported by the Rules Committee.  The amdt text is attached.  The amdt adds oversight to TARP.  It stipulates that a company getting TARP money must report how much new lending it did.  It is specifically aimed at the problem where lenders are taking TARP money and not using it for the intended purpose of lending, but instead are using the TARP funds to buy other banks, claim their assets, and say they are lending more money now (and in some cases laying off employees from the acquired bank in the process).

LaTourette amdt - the amdt requires that any lending assistance provided under TARP or EISA to an insured depository institution shall report the amount of any increase or decrease in new lending attributed to the TARP or EISA assistance.  If the institution cannot provide an accurate report, the institution shall report the total amount of increase or decrease in overall new lending in its quarterly reports (10 minutes debate).

Please be advised that the MTR could be especially nasty - it is going to depend on how much trouble the Rs who oppose this wish to cause.  The scope of this bill is very, very wide.  And the Rs are really upset about a number of things right now.  If the Rs wish to stir up an immense amount of trouble, the MTR could be things such as emissions standards, CAFÉ, the Columbia FTA (it is germane to the bill), anything transportation-related (due to the guarantee provision for mass transit entities), something immigration-related (the bill includes a COLA for judges, which opens the scope of Judiciary Cmte), and more.  It is assumed the President will work to keep their Rs in line on this so they do not torpedo the bill, but there are no guarantees and no assurances. Wanted to be sure you are aware of this in the event things start spinning out of control.

Finally, the Senate will not be taking this up today, so we will be playing the waiting game.  It is hoped the Senate will simply pass our bill tomorrow, pass it, and send to the President.  But if recent history is any indicator, what is more likely to happen is we will pass the bill tonight; the Senate will take up the bill tomorrow, make changes to it, and stuff it down our throat; and we will then pass whatever the Senate passed.  Stay tuned.

Tonight's Schedule (subj to change of course):

Debate on same day rule - 1 hour.  We are now debating the same day rule
Vote on same day rule
Debate on the auto rule - 1 hour
Vote on the rule
General debate on the bill - 1 hour
Debate on the LaTourette amdt - 10 minutes
Vote on amdt (possibly voiced)
MTR debate - 10 minutes
Vote on MTR
Final Passage

We are going to be here for a while.  Guessing 7:30pm-8pm; could be earlier or later depending on if time is yielded back or something is voiced.

Matt Stoller :: House Republican Strategy on Auto Bailout Bill

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Well, I don't mind that ammendment... (0.00 / 0)
LaTourette would be a fool to kill an auto loan bill... he's got a couple Big 3 plants right in his district!

I don't think you'll get many blue dogs in on this stuff... they are mostly from automotive and union states and are in general support of the auto bailout.

Typical republicans, trying to destroy America any way they can...

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


The blue dogs and southern Republicans are playing with fire. (0.00 / 0)
If Detroit can shut down a plant in Michigan or shut down a plant in Tenneesee, hmmm.  

They're asking for another four years -- in a just world, they'd get 10 to 20. ~~ Dennis Kucinich  

32 R "Yes", 20 D "No" (0.00 / 0)
The one name on the Democrats who surprised me: Pete Stark.

Here's the Blue Dog heavy list:

Artur Davis, AL
Gabrielle Giffords, AZ
Harry Mitchell, AZ
Dennis Cardoza, CA
Bob Filner,CA
Pete Stark,CA
Allen Boyd, FL
Jim Marshall,GA
Collin Peterson, MN
Tim Walz, MN
Travis Childers, MS
GK Butterfield,NC
Mike McIntyre,NC
Heath Shuler,NC
Stephanie Herseth Sandlin, SD
Jim Cooper, TN
Ciro Rodriguez, TX
Jim Mattheson, UT
Nick Rahall, WV
Steve Kagen,WV

The Republican "Yes" list added up to 31 but Tom Davis was not listed (yes, no, or not voting).

Don Young, AK
Mike Castle,DE
Ray LaHood, IL
Don Manzullo,IL
Steve Buyer, IN
Mark Souder,IN
Ron Lewis, KY
Jim McCrery, LA
Dave Camp, MI
Vern Ehlers,MI
Pete Hoekstra,MI
Joe Knollenberg,MI
Thad MCCotter,MI
Candice Miller,MI
Mike Rogers,MI
Fred Upton, MI
Jim Ramstad, MN
JoAnn Emmerson, MO
Jon Porter,NV
Rodney Frelinghuysen,NJ
Chris Smith,NJ
Peter King,NY
John McHugh,NY
Jim Walsh,NY
Steve LaTourette,OH
Ralph Regula,OH
Phil English,PA
Tim Murphy,PA
Joe Barton,TX
Shelley Moore Capito,WV
Paul Ryan,WI

10 of the Republicans were either retiring or defeated and won't be coming back.  

The list is from the San Diego Times Union from google.


[ Parent ]
Missing name (0.00 / 0)
OMG, it's Duncan Hunter.

[ Parent ]
Except for CA, they are all right to work for less states. (0.00 / 0)
CA has lots of domestic plants.  I was talking to the head of one of the Detroit 3, and did ask when they were going to stand up and get even.  

They're asking for another four years -- in a just world, they'd get 10 to 20. ~~ Dennis Kucinich  

[ Parent ]
This is the Republicans' once in a lifetime chance to kill the UAW (4.00 / 4)
And you damn well know they are going to fight and claw every step of the way to do it.

Kill the GOP in Midwest (4.00 / 3)
It's also a once in a lifetime chance to kill the GOP in the Midwest.  Half of (14 of 26)their seats were won with under 60% of the vote in OH (4 of 8), MI (3 of 7), IL(4 of 7), MN (3-3).

Oh, yeah, AIG has another $10 billion they misplaced.  

Unlimited bucks for the banks and unlimited grief for auto.

Tom Mr. Stupido Friedman says Detroit's model is all wrong.  Not that they need to learn from the Japanese or Germans?  Nope, Israel is supposed to be the automotive savior.  Haven't seen any of those in the mall parking lots.

When Friedman and Fox agree you know it is 100% wrong.


It wouild be temporary... (0.00 / 0)
They know this...

Yes, no former union member would ever vote for the GOP again, but without an active union to GOTV them, many may just not vote at all...

As the old union folk fade away, the people who are left will experience permanent poverty and government inaction... this mixture is ripe for God and guns distractions, and eventually the GOP will own these places outright...

The poorer people get, the more republican they are likely to be... unions were a hedge against that... eliminating the largest craft union kills that hedge...  why do you think that republicans hate unions so much?

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


[ Parent ]
The GOP vision (4.00 / 4)
I lived in Michigan up until two years ago and when Republican governor John Engler was just elected, a Democratic staffer in the State Senate made clear to me what his vision and the Republican Party vision for America was. A state and country full of small, non-union shops focused in small towns and rural areas. No vision for anyone else. Big cities and suburbs could rot for all they cared and they chose to leave those areas to Democrats. Killing a relatively well-paying, heavily unionized industry is exactly what they are aiming for so they can return to some sort of vision they beleived America once was.

[ Parent ]
Very well put (4.00 / 1)
That's exactly what Sarah Palin is all about.  

[ Parent ]
That's exactly what they did in Ohio... (4.00 / 1)
...They made sure that no funding went to the big cities, instead funneling it all to small townships...  So, now Cleveland's in the crapper and so is Cincinnati, and the whole state is practically in a depression...

The cities and the burbs are the engines of growth in an economy, not their small minded "little shop" rural garbage...

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


[ Parent ]
Donate to Open Left








Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.

As an anti-spam measure, there is a 24-hour waiting period after registering before new users can comment.
blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search