The Green Zone in St. Paul

by: Matt Stoller

Mon Sep 01, 2008 at 12:00


I'm trying to upload photos and am having trouble with the internets.  I'm at the Uptake, an office set aside for bloggers right near the security perimeter outside the Excel Center.  The scene here in St Paul is downright creepy.  It's deserted, with chain link fences and barbed wire surrounding the downtown area and riot police running down the empty streets, chanting out load cheers like they are on a military missions.  There are a few Republican delegates, some young Republican operatives, a few people hawking wares, and a scattered group of protesters with signs that takl about war and profit.  It is anything but festive, a far cry from Denver in both the level of excitement and the overt fascist overtones.  
Matt Stoller :: The Green Zone in St. Paul

The only interesting events going on here are the raids of local hippies by an aggressive and corrupt county sheriff, and I'll be heading to the formal protest in a few minutes.  What's dispiriting is just how complicit people are in this security state; outside the Democratic rapid response center, I spoke to a (probably liberal) woman who expressed comfort at all the security in that it will help prevent bombs from the anarchists.

This is the essence of 'security theater', intended to intimidate rather than protect.  I took pictures of the riot police, and I have to say I was scared in doing so because there was literally no one around, two squads of riot police, and brick buildings on one side and barbed wire fences on the other.  

This isn't a Republican problem, by the way.  The Fleet Center in Boston in 2004 was just as bad, and there's ridiculous amounts of security theater all over the country, supplemented by higher security budgets since 9/11 and a blanket acceptance of our loss of freedoms by citizens and elites.  Go to Capitol Hill or the White House and you'll see what I mean, though the conventions are far worse.

My dream for the 2007 inauguration was Nancy Pelosi would take the speaker's gavel and order one symbolic cinder block removed from in front of the capitol.  I would hope that the next President does something like that, though I don't think he will.

This country should not become a 'homeland', as the Department of Homeland Security refers to it, and our cities should not have green zones.  This is an abridgment of freedom so egregious not because it is so frightening, because the police are generally nice and doing their jobs, but so accepted by all involved.


Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Keep saying it! (4.00 / 2)
The "security theater" is the leading edge of authoritarian militarization of the country.

Can it happen here?

The NYPD (0.00 / 0)
were brought in to do the training of twin city police for the RNC. and if I heard correctly, the twin cities have received the same amount of Home Land Security funding as NYC.

There have been more raids than just on the meet up center. Videographer friends of mine who traveled to MN for the RNC, who are very experienced from RNC and ongoing civil rights campaigns here were immediately detained and had equipment confiscated last week when they arrived. Other videographers have had their base locations raided. And the "fire code violation" based raids are being repeated in the twincities; they were the common excuse used by NYPD to break up anti-RNC fundraiser parties in NYC.

Michael Bloomberg, prince of corporate welfare


"Code Violation" (0.00 / 0)
The "fire code violation" was used in DC a few years back.  The ACLU had a lawsuit about it.  It is so blatantly appalling.  They confiscated the computers in DC too.  The chief of police was commended and now others are copying this nonsense.

McCain on the minimum wage

[ Parent ]
police presence in Saint Paul (0.00 / 0)
The police presence in Saint Paul is massive. I have lived in the twin cities for the last 31 years and before that New York City. I attended the big anti-Vietnam War protests in Washington D.C. and I never saw so many police from so many jurisdictions: St Paul Police, Minneapolis Police, ATF, State Troopers, Sherburne County, Ramsey County Sheriff (battlin Bob Fletcher), Hennepin County Sheriff. These were all officers I saw today. Probably because of the preemptive raids yesterday today's rally and march to the RNC was small to my eyes. I think there was a march with roughly the same numbers from the Cathedral to the Capitol in 2003 just before Bush took us into war protesting the imminent war. There was very little police presence then...certainly nothing like the Armies all over the Twin Cities.  

Donate to Open Left








Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.

As an anti-spam measure, there is a 24-hour waiting period after registering before new users can comment.
blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search