Local Media Watch: How a Major Paper (the Oregonian) Manufactures a Republican 'Moderate'

by: Matt Stoller

Sun Oct 19, 2008 at 20:42


Gordon Smith, Ben Nelson, Kit Bond, Trent Lott, Susan Collins, and Ted Stevens enjoy the Senate's seersucker suit day.  No word yet on whether Senators can bring their butlers.

It's not just Newsweek of DC elites pressing a conservative, elitist agenda.  Local newspapers are often the worst purveyors of conservative ideas, and they often have a hammerlock on information in the district.  Oregon is a good example, where progressive Jeff Merkley is challenging Republican Gordon Smith.  Though he has a moderate reputation, Gordon Smith is very much the picture of a pampered Republican politician.  Born wealthy into a Mormon family, the anti-choice Smith's family money comes from a frozen food company with a history of safety violations, low pay for workers, and a record of hiring undocumented immigrants.  His privilege is legend; he owns golf clubs worth over a million dollars, he uses 15 year old footage in his ads so he'll appear younger and slimmer, and he enjoys Seersucker suit day in the Senate (he's the one on the far left).  I've even heard rumors he has a golden toilet seat at home and a giant mural of himself in his foyer.  Smith is a wealthy, entitled man who enjoys his position as a wealthy, entitled Senator voting for policies that help those who are wealthy and entitled.  It's literally in his blood.

But in one breath, the powerful local newspaper the Oregonian endorses Democrat Barack Obama, arguing there has "rarely been a time when the nation so desperately needed a sharp change in direction," and Republican Senator Gordon Smith, arguing that his seniority, moderation, and power are what Oregon needs.  Merkley, by contrast, is apparently in thrall to the very liberal wing of his party, as evidenced by his opposition to the bailout and corporate friendly trade agreements.  Oregonians "need a senator who thinks of their needs before he thinks of his party's priorities. Gordon Smith has proven that he's the man in this race who can do that. We believe Oregonians should re-elect him."

Matt Stoller :: Local Media Watch: How a Major Paper (the Oregonian) Manufactures a Republican 'Moderate'
The Oregonian lists off some environmental votes, a stem cell bill, and a hate crimes bill as evidence that Smith is a moderate, but the paper argues that "a conscience-driven reversal of his support for the war in Iraq was his most important decision. He made the choice after deep reflection and while under great pressure from the White House and Republicans to stay the course. His defection prompted others and pushed the administration toward finally developing an endgame in Iraq."

Actually, after calling Bush's Iraq policy as one that 'may even be criminal' in late 2006, Smith voted to block debate on the surge just a few months later.  Smith's voted against birth control, choice, a progressive tax code, and he voted badly on Iraq, directly in opposition to the position the Oregonian lauds him for taking.  The Oregonian is pushing a specific ideological agenda; the paper wants a Wall Street bailout (the Treasury is already blacking out compensation schemes for the Bank of New York Mellon) and corporate trade agreements.  Merkley doesn't.  Ergo, Gordon Smith is a moderate.

He's not, obviously, or maybe he is since 'moderate' doesn't actually mean anything these days except for whining a lot before supporting the acceptable conservative policy.  Regardless, I'm not worried about the death of the newspaper industry.  It's about time, frankly.  Conventional wisdom doesn't just come from DC elites, it comes from a whole set of interlocking industrial interests, many of whom publish a paper or own a TV station near you.


Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Norman Rockwell gone horribly wrong. (0.00 / 0)
What ever it is, this photo makes me want to go see a musical.

Oregonian (4.00 / 1)
The Oregonian loves Gordon Smith. It has loved him for as long as I can remember. There was no question in my mind that it would endorse Smith for re-election.

I have read good words about Merkley here on this blog, but I have to say that, as someone who lives in Portland, I think he has run a less-than-stellar campaign. (I will say, though, that I was thrilled that he ran a pro-choice ad that used the word 'abortion." That was good.)

I voted for Steve Novick in the Dem primary. I really liked him. He was a progressive voice, and I think he would have been a good candidate. The Rahm Emanuel coalition decided that Merkley would be a better candidate for them, though. And they threw Merkley a boatload of cash to defeat Novick.

That stuck in my craw, and I think it was a sour note for a lot of Dems here. So I admit that I was not thrilled with Merkley prior to his post-primary campaign.

Still, I think my assessment of his campaign is legitimate. It has been uninspired. He has a singular lack of charisma (maybe not his fault, but Novick was Personality Plus). There are reports that he tearfully gave back (!) money to a local Palestinian group for trumped-up reasons, after accepting their support initially (hello, Rahm!).

All of which makes this extremely disappointing for those of us who saw a real chance to beat Smith this year.

I think Novick would have been a better candidate against Smith. And if Merkley doesn't win, I won't be the only one thinking that Rahm Emanuel and his cronies screwed the pooch here in Oregon, too.


I liked Novick a lot better, too (0.00 / 0)
But it's not exactly fair to blame Congressman Rahm Emanuel for what goes on in the Senate.  That's Chuck Schumer you're pissed at, not Rahm.

ProgressiveHistorians: History For Our Future

[ Parent ]
true... (0.00 / 0)
It was Emanuel/Schumer et al.

[ Parent ]
Even though I was an early Merkley supporter (0.00 / 0)
I liked Novick and continue to respect him a great deal. But, as an Oregonian, you have to admit that what Merkley has done for our state on the progressive front has been tremendous. Helping engineer the takeover of the Oregon House to leading the most progressive session we've ever seen, is a good reason to support Jeff imo. He may not be a extremely charasmatic pol like Obama for instance, but he's a very skilled progressive legislator, and we could sure use him in the Senate.  

Netroots Director for Oregon Senate Candidate Jeff Merkley

[ Parent ]
you mean blood sucker suits (0.00 / 0)
thank you, thank you very much.

oh - lets play a quiz, what will Nancy Pelosi, Chris Dodd, Chuck Schumer, and Barack Obama do about the blackout of bailout compensation schemes for NY Mellon? (or any other part of this incredible ripoff)

to see the answer hold your laptop up to a mirror.

Answer: GNIHTON

Michael Bloomberg, prince of corporate welfare


asdf (0.00 / 0)
As a non-Oregonian, I'm guessing all we can hope for is a big enough youth turnout that will vote straight Dem to outnumber the older Obama voters who will split the ticket. Is that correct?

nah (4.00 / 2)
Oregon's done with smith.

[ Parent ]
I would be shocked, Matt (0.00 / 0)
...if that were true. Really shocked.

Happy, yes.

But I don't see the evidence.


[ Parent ]
how could you be "really shocked" (0.00 / 0)
that someone who is 5 points ahead in the pollster.com estimate and has not polled wose than 1 behind since September 1st wins?  Plus the incumbent has not hit 51% in any poll this year.

I don't deny Merkley could lose, but a win would not be shocking.



New Jersey politics at Blue Jersey.


[ Parent ]
I'm a life-long Oregonian (4.00 / 1)
I doubt the Oregonian has a significant impact on voter choice. It is universally held in contempt. The Oregonian has always been a Republican newspaper. The management is corporate Republican and fancies itself as "moderate" in the Rockefeller Republican mode, something that no longer exists.
I'm of the opinion that Merkley will be elected in the wave for change this election. A factor in this race is Smith's flight from right wing politics to portray himself as a friend of Obama's and Wyden's. A number of Rs are going to vote for the Constitution party candidate. This appears to be  borne out in polling by SUSA.

Addendum: Once upon a time there was a Labor connected competitor in Portland, "The Oregon Journal." I used to receive it home delivery. It fell on hard times in the 1970s and was bought out by the Oregonian and dissolved. It would be nice to see those newspapers again. Maybe the online revolution will make it possible.  


I'm pretty sure (0.00 / 0)
the dude on the right isn't Gordon Smith, since he's quite clearly the dude on the left.

ProgressiveHistorians: History For Our Future

Oregonian (0.00 / 0)
The Oregonian is owned by the same company which owns Conde Nast, and a bunch of other newspapers (but is not part of an "industrial interest" that I'm aware of).  The New Yorker (a Conde Nast publication) just published a great Obama endorsement.  So, I think we're looking at local management (editorial board, etc) calling the shots, not further up the chain.

http://www.actblue.com/page/asaslist

Come on now, Mattie ... (0.00 / 0)
Seersuckers ain't that bad.  Especially down here in the humid and hot summers of New Orleans.

[ Parent ]
Ok, but what about that lame light grey color? (0.00 / 0)
Those guys look like they're starring in a funny detergent ad:

"That's how a dentist's convention could look like without fabulous UBIK°!
Don't let your world turn grey because of stinginess.
Get rid of the cheap stuff, and buy Ubik°!
And then dentists will look like dentists again."

° UBIK is always safe when used as directed. Check additional package info for details.


[ Parent ]
It's quite a stretch (0.00 / 0)
for a State-wide paper to keep one foot (the left one) in Portland and the other foot (the right one) in Pendleton.
Merkley is a good progressive, and he seems to be pulling slightly ahead of Smith. If Smith is ever to be unseated, this is the year. It's uncomfortably close, but crucial for the Senate and for Democrats' ability to govern in Washington.
Amiable Mr. Smith is trying to pass himself off now as the best friend Democrats ever had, but he consistently votes conservative, especially on economic issues.  

All papers and news go right (0.00 / 0)
they are driven by ad dollars which are fed by sprawl interests of automobiles and developers.  

http://www.streetsblog.org/200...

27% of local tv stations and 18% of local newspapers ads are paid for by the auto industry.  

It's Electric! TheOverheadWire.com


Donate to Open Left








Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.

As an anti-spam measure, there is a 24-hour waiting period after registering before new users can comment.
blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search