Driving home from work I endured NPR's inexplicable decision to give Jonah Goldberg airtime to admit that it is "more fun" for conservative pundits to be out of power (actually, I agree, it is more fun having Jonah out of power. Conservatives breaking the Planet isn't fun).
From my non-expert understanding of the subject matter, Alter does a fine job smashing up Shlaes' arguments throughout, but the highlight is the callers and emailers, who give me some sense and hope that conservative New Deal denialism isn't sticking with the public. In particular, at the 8:00 mark in the program, the very first caller actually attended FDR's inauguration and was 16 years old at the time, working as a Senate page. He makes a point of noting Shlaes' perception of history ignores that by 1935-36, things clearly had visibly improved. NPR's host stupidly insists on moving on to other callers in the too-quick manner of NPR, but Alter makes a point of getting contact info from the caller, so hopefully we will hear more from this man. There are very few people alive who were old enough to remember the New Deal in progress, never mind that actually worked in Washington and knew the players. The guy also has a good quip about the 20th Amendment (also from 1933) saving the country from 2 more months of Bush.
STATE BLOGS
