Openleft and Single Payer

by: HousesofProgress

Sat Mar 07, 2009 at 14:02


There have been, and will be posts here on openleft, that call for real pressure, strong pressure, on the drive to 'reform' our healthcare system, and what that 'reform' should be.

 But there have been no diaries, the frontpage thrust of the debate here at openleft is on the economy, the debates and calls to action, such as the necessary calls to primary those who stand ion the way on necessary legistation are on jobs and laws. There are calls to organize around accuracy in reporting, the history of progressives and Keysian economic plans, calls to reinstate civil rights protection and a threatening survielance society.

 But the debate on healthcare is lacking.

That is a shame. This is the time for 'economic, jobs and worker rights progressives' to listen closely to what  'health progressives' are saying, have been saying, will be saying louder and louder in the months and years to come.

 The opportunity, the responsibility, right now to act desicively is greater than at any other time in our history. The ongoing lurch of history will beging to have turbulence, the debates about other significant issues will heat up, the situations in other crisis will press for attention. Right NOW is the time.

 

HousesofProgress :: Openleft and Single Payer

There is a right to healthcare. There have been several news stories about Republican Zack Wamp, Tennessee congressman railing against any health-care reform effort, calling it a move toward “socialism” and that Obama was engaging in almost “class warfare.”

Wamp went so far as to say, “Health care is a privilege,” before clarifying that he meant, “It's not necessarily a right” for those who choose not to pay for health care.

He back tracked. As he should. But even he was unwilling to say that Americans don't have right to healthcare. Althouigh he stupidly, well stupidly to me, 'clarified'  “It's not necessarily a right” for those who choose not to pay for health care.” Which means what? You have right to something you pay for.

MSNBC cals that a clarification. Obviously its not, but the space in the difference is is the new emerging debate.

And so now there is a popular meme, a debate around words, a possible opening, on whether or not Americans have a right to HealthCare. If someone falls from a building and braks bones, we have organized society so that you have a right to accomplished service protecting your life. But if you are at home, dying of a closing artery to your heart. There is no screaming siren, no flashing lights and not a single gurney. No right. Millions of American's cant get coverage because they are already sick. Millions more are afraid of getting tests, because finding somthing wrong might literally mean they can't ever be treated for it. What is the cure for these ills? What is the cure for Insurance hacks working as hard as they can so they 'earn' a bonus for denying care to someone who needs it?

What is the answer except A Right to Healthcare? You can be, should be tested, iof you have a right to have it treated, infact the sooner the better. And if there ius a right to healthcare, who enforces it, and who pays for it?

The answer is singlepayer healthcare.

It will not be easy.

 When single payer was first introduced in Canada, it was promised by the incoming socialist government (the party was called Cooperative Commonwealth Federation, CCF, which became the NDP) of one province. Saskatchewan.  Small, poor farming province. Like Kansas or Nebraska. Wheat and poverty grew every year. When they got elected, first ever socialist government in North America, the outgoing conservative government had destroyed the books and placed the province in hock to Chicago and NY banks in an effort to ensure it would never be able to pay a bill, let alone put in place a state paid for healthcare system. And second as it was brought in the entire workforce of Doctors went on strike. Refusing to see even the deathly ill. Newspaper's screamed  that the “Jew Communists” were “killing babies” (Tommy Douglas was actually a Baptist Minister) Tommy solved the money problem by becoming the farm insurance provider putting tons of farmer cash in the treasury, while reducing the amount that normally left the country. And he solved the Doctors strike by buying a plane and having it fly to Europe and hire Doctors.The day it landed full of Doctors, the strike ended. Single payer was introduced.

Tommy and the CCF ran nationally almost immediately and the Federal Liberal Government saw the light of social remedy and social programs were rolled out across the board. Social welfare, universal Medicare, old age pensions and mothers' allowances. Tommy never got actual power Federally, just enough to apply pressure. He doesn't have a single statue built to him, nor an airport. But when Canadians were asked to vote over several months, in a widely popular CBC television show, who is The Greatest Canadian Ever, Canadians voted and voted and finaly said, that skinny little fellow from Saskatchewan, Tommy Douglas. 

 None of this seems too different from today.  It wiil take a threat of becoming swept from power to push the  “government party” to serve the interests of people.

It always does. 

The question here right this second, is the drive for the 'Right to Health' a real one? Is the drive for a system that can actually solve this problem real? Is the drive for single payer sophisticated enough, is th passion high enough, is the courage here?

 Is the courage available here at openleft? Can we add this debate to the front page? Can we add The Right to Health and SinglePayer to the things that will get you primaried? Get you fired get you sent home?

Is openleft onside?

Poll
Is openleft progressive on Health?
Americans have right to healthcare.
Americans have a right to complain.
Americans are sick because of moral problems.
Insurance componies arent that bad.
I want Openleft to give singlepayer top priority.

Results


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.

As an anti-spam measure, there is a 24-hour waiting period after registering before new users can comment.
blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search