Get Off The Bench, Mr. President

by: Adam Bink

Fri Aug 21, 2009 at 10:30


So I was watching MSNBC yesterday morning and they were showing video of the Obamas at the Grand Canyon. My first thought was, "why are they at the Grand Canyon during an insanely intense August recess battle over the issue that will very likely define his Presidency?" And then, as if by cue to emphasize what was going on in the world, the host said "next up, is there fallout from Barney Frank's argument with his town hall protester?"

Then I watched the OFA town hall meeting yesterday afternoon, and Jim Gilliam Tweeted:

@jgilliam cable tv was shut out of obama's #hc09 online forum. you can only watch online http://is.gd/2qsK9

It turns out later that Jim was mistaken, but it emphasized a point for me that I want to make on why we're losing this battle in the media, and how to get it back, which I talk about in the extended entry.

Adam Bink :: Get Off The Bench, Mr. President
The President is treating this like a summer hobby. He's not treating it as he should, which is the defining issue of his Presidency, a knock-down, drag-out, work 18 hours a day battle that we have to win. Rep. Eric Massa came to our NY caucus at Netroots Nation and spent 40 minutes talking to us about how people in his district are 80%-20% against the President's bill. EIGHTY TO TWENTY. I worked for Massa in that district (NY-29) in 2006, and my own grandpa lives there. It's not a hotbed of rock-ribbed conservatism, but he sure sounds like one of the 80% when I talk to him. Yet the President spent the first week of the month AWOL in regards to health care, managed to tack on some sightseeing at the end of his short tour of the West, and is going to Martha's Vineyard this weekend. Eric, on the other hand, sounded like he was getting pummeled, and joked to us, "Well, I've had better Augusts, but I signed up for it."

Yes, he did. Did President Obama?

Meanwhile, it's non-stop angry people at town halls, 24/7 on TV. I can't flip on the television without hearing about people with guns at town halls or people upset about the proposed legislation or Barney Frank shouting with people. While those of us who know better understand it's virtually all astroturf, I don't actually think that matters. What people like my grandpa- who as a retired 98-year-old, spends about 80% of his day watching television- sees is that folks are upset. That's the #1 message coming through. It's the same thing we did in 2005 around the Social Security fight. Edward Jones, as a member of the Alliance for Worker Retirement Security, the pro-privatization business front group, would endorse Bush's privatization plan. Americans United to Protect Social Security and other groups would send hordes of angry union members to protest outside their headquarters. They would withdraw their support quickly.

Did Edward Jones care that a crowd of union members were mad at them? No. Did they care about the perception of angry people shouting at them on non-stop cable TV? Absolutely. The right-wing is using the same tactic, and it's one big reason they're winning. We're being shut out of cable, which is what Jim's tweet, however mistaken, emphasized to me.

Okay, so how do we counter it? Well, one way is to keep them from broadcasting it at all. We have two big players on our team's bench (and lately, I do mean, sitting on our bench): President Obama and Vice President Biden. When either of these guys do town hall meetings, cable shows both cover it live as well as show clips of it during the evening news. The local newspaper covers the announcement that they're coming, covers it the day they are actually there, and covers it the day after they leave. And in some places like Buffalo, where I'm from, some local reporter writes a "what it all means" piece two days after, too. It saturates the coverage and helps keep the right-wing anger from getting through.

Obama did that town hall in New Hampshire where everyone was polite and the whole thing went well, and somehow found himself on the defensive amid claims that the Administration packed the thing with supporters. Maybe that made his cautious staff worried about doing more. I don't know. I can tell you that for most folks who don't live inside-the-Beltway, all I care about is getting that coverage live for my grandpa watching at 3 PM in the afternoon on MSNBC, and queued up for the evening local news, and then again for the 11 PM news, and then again in the next day's newspaper, and on NPR, and so forth. The more we saturate the airwaves with Obama and Biden doing events- any events- the more we keep the angry people off the screen.

Yet in the past week, Obama did just one town hall in NH, one in Montana, one in Colorado, an interview with some NASCAR outfit Wednesday night, another radio interview with a conservative talk show yesterday afternoon in which he based liberals again, and then the OFA town hall. In between he did a VFW speech that was almost entirely not on health care except for one short note, went to Yellowstone National Park, went fly-fishing in Montana, and went to the Grand Canyon. And is going to Martha's Vineyard this weekend (where Conservatives for Patients' Rights will mock him with this ad on Massachusetts TV). Meanwhile, Eric Massa and Barney Frank are taking it on the chin.

Sorry, Mr. President,  but that's unacceptable. You need to treat this like the 2008 campaign and do 6, 7, 8 events a day. You need to put into this what myself and hundreds of thousands of grassroots activists are putting into it. I know, you're the President now and the prime minister of a country is waiting for you. I don't care. Make it a phone meeting and clear your schedule. You need to stop going on vacations. You need to get your face on TV in half a dozen markets a day. You need to put all in.

And where the hell is Biden, anyway? I haven't seen his face on television or in the newspaper in I can't remember how long. Has he discovered Cheney's secure undisclosed location and set up shop? By now, I'm wishing that Sanjay Gupta had taken that Surgeon General job. At least his face would have been on CNN all day long.

I'm stuck waiting for my President and my Vice President to get off the bench.


Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
One more big gun (4.00 / 3)
We have one more big gun but alas it can only be fired once.  That would be Ted Kennedy giving an intereview on natioinal TV about health care.  It could be really powerful but would certainly be mocked by the astroturf crowd.  Then again, they mock everything except themselves and their corporate paymasters.

That is true (4.00 / 3)
I keep hearing he's in really bad shape though- indications of which are from his non-attendance at Eunice's funeral, and the request to reform procedures to replace him this week. I don't know how well he would do on TV.

[ Parent ]
Maybe a 'do it for Teddy' movement would carry some weight? (4.00 / 1)
I don't know exactly how best to frame it, but it might resonate.

[ Parent ]
lakoff had an excellent diary on the messaging (4.00 / 1)
disaster yesterday on dailykos.

"t's not too late to turn things around, but we must first understand why the administration is getting beat at the moment.

The answer is simple and unfortunate: The president put both the conceptual framing and the messaging for his health care plan in the hands of policy wonks. This led to twin disasters."

http://www.dailykos.com/story/...

In my little brain, the leafy democrats from the nice neighborhoods, nice schools, nice colleges --- they don't know a fucking thing about how to beat the rove, ailes and atewaters --- they do know how to use their re$ource$ to get those big policy jobs AND keep those policy jobs AND keep making excuses,

and keep fucking losing.

rmm.  

It is too full o' the milk of human kindness To catch the nearest way


Where's the leadership? (4.00 / 5)
We have some significant problems in our country but on most of the issues that have been addressed so far the President's leadership has not matched the magnitude of the problem.  

American's want to see strength in presence of opposition. Yes, President campaigned on a new tone but the cliche is absolutely true: "two way street".  He could've done an interview or in townhall and tell people: "look I tried to reach but the other side doesn't want to work with me.  So I am doing what I believe is best for the country to tackle our problems."  This would have worked. Look at the polls - repuglicans are not polling well.  

But no, what we have is a President who appears weak and obsessed w/bipartisanship - appearances matter the most.  People are looking for leadership and they are not seeing it in the President.

RebelCapitalist - Financial Information for the Rest of Us.


Would this (4.00 / 1)
Obama have won the primaries or general election?

The appearances are flat and too cerebral.

Let's hope he is better in September.  

 


It was never him. (4.00 / 3)
It was us. That is the lesson here.

Frankly, I think Lakoff still has stars in his eyes, he still believes the reason the insurance and drug companies have done so well in pushing Obama is because he hasn't figured out how to fight them. Lakoff has not yet accepted the fact that Obama does not want to fight them.

But the netroots are two steps ahead. We put Obama in the White House, to implement healthcare reform among other things, and if he isn't going to help then we'll do it ourselves. Obama can lead, follow, or get out of the way.

And he does have a performance review coming up in 2012.  

If you liked Bush, you'll love McCain


[ Parent ]
Not only Grand Canyon (2.67 / 3)
but that the most enduring aspect of the story relates to the First Lady's attire.

I mean, the guy takes his mouth and brain everywhere he goes - he can turn any event into a push for his agenda.

If that was what he wanted to do.  

"It sounds wrong...
     ...but its right."


I disagree (0.00 / 0)
Obama out front is exactly the wrong thing to do right now.

Obama in the campaign was at his best when he was above the fray. Town halls only put him into it. A candidate for president is different then the President. The public does make a distinction between running for the job and the job itself. Unfortunately for Obama he comes right after Bush. No matter what he does in these events they are automatically devalued by what went before.

Instead what should be happening is just what has been beginning to happen. The single payer advocates need to come to the fore.

The message should be simplified and sharpened. Single payer would be best, we have compromised to the public option, since the republicans idea of compromise is their way or the highway, we should push for the best solution.


For each DVD you purchase, Brave New Films will donate $5 to OpenLeft.com to support our various projects. Please click on the buttons above to make a purchase.
SEIU will donate $1 to OpenLeft for each individual who signs up for their campaign to pass health care for all Americans. Sign up here.
Donate to Open Left

Senate Whip Count
Public Option Yes: 45
Public Option Maybe: 16
Public Option No: 2
Party of No: 37

QUICK HITS

blog advertising is good for you

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.


blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search