2010 elections and the base vote

by: Adam Bink

Tue Feb 23, 2010 at 12:43


Here's President Obama at the State of the Union:

This year -- this year, I will work with Congress and our military to finally repeal the law that denies gay Americans the right to serve the country they love because of who they are. It's the right thing to do.

Here's The Advocate's Kerry Eleveld asking Robert Gibbs about Don't Ask, Don't Tell during yesterday's press briefing:

The Advocate: Senator Lieberman is planning to introduce a "don't ask, don't tell" repeal bill next week. Would the president like to see Congress pass repeal this year?

Gibbs: As you know, Kerry, the president is strongly in support of this, working with Secretary Gates and Admiral Mullen. There is a process that's underway. You saw in Admiral Mullen the first Joint [Chiefs] Chair to openly - active Joint [Chiefs] Chair - to openly call for its repeal. We have stated throughout this process that the only durable way for this to happen is through legislation. We think that Senator Lieberman's proposal is obviously an important step in that legislation, and I would point out that you heard from commanders in the field over the weekend on news shows as well as former chairman Powell also come out strongly in support of repealing "don't ask, don't tell."

It's like the President never said "this year" at all. What's wrong with a simple "yes, the President and Commander in Chief made that clear at the State of the Union"?

Kerry again:

The Advocate: A lot of people fear that if it doesn't happen this year that it very well may not happen throughout the entire first term, not to assume a second one.

Gibbs: I don't think the president shares that view because I believe, and i think you all have seen this throughout, obviously there's been a lot of polling on this done since the president's proposal and since Secretary Gates and Admiral Mullen testified on Capitol Hill about this. There is strong bipartisan support for its repeal among, among the American people. The president obviously shares that, as do important members of the military, and we think it will become law.

Give me a break. There's "strong bipartisan support" for a lot of things. Doesn't mean they have a shot in hell of getting done in the next Congress. What are the reasons for Gibbs' equivocation? What would it cost the White House to re-commit to repeal and lay out a plan? If repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell is as bipartisan and beloved by the nation as Gibbs says it is, then there should be no reason for this kind of equivocation.

And by the way, this is about the umpteenth opportunity of late for prominent LGBT organizations and advocates to take to the media and do the following: (a) Reiterate how critical it is that repeal, among other LGBT issues, is done before the 2010 midterms (b) Light a fire under Democrats' behinds by taking a page out of labor's book and warning that angry and/or apathetic base LGBT voters will stay home in droves, helping to cause another 1994. Stan Greenberg's polling demonstrated that from the 2008 elections to the 2009 off-year elections, Rising American Electorate voters- base Democrats, all- as percentage of the electorate dropped 9% in Virginia and 10% in New Jersey. There are a lot of reasons for that, but a big one is that they are demoralized by lack of action at the national level, and it played a role in losses across the board. And we all saw just how fired up Democrats were in Massachusetts.

LGBT voters are far from fired up and ready to go, and statements like this from the White House don't help. LGBT organizations and advocates should all be reminding them of their political best interests.

Adam Bink :: 2010 elections and the base vote

Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
There goes the Duke of Plaza-Obama (4.00 / 1)
Leading his regiment from behind, as usual.

hmm (0.00 / 0)
"this is about the umpteenth opportunity of late for prominent LGBT organizations and advocates to take to the media and do the following: (a) Reiterate how critical it is that repeal, among other LGBT issues, is done before the 2010 midterms"

I've already said I disagree with prioritising this strategy so take this for what it's worth, but if you could help me understand why it's important for this to be done immediately, I would be more likely to support it.  I understand why Labor making gains is important to my political interests in redistribution, creating social justice infrastructure, etc.  I don't understand why repealing DADT is, except insofar as it mobilises people as part of a broader LGBT and social justice agenda- not even as much as repealing DOMA, which can be framed as both a civil rights issue, an economic issue, a moral issue, an emotional issue, a class issue, and even a state's rights issue - why should states that are progressive have their citizens suffer from differential rights?  

If someone could spell this out for me- why it is so important to repeal DADT now, rather than five years from now- then I would be much more inclined to support what you're saying.


Reasons (0.00 / 0)
1. The most simple- barring LGBT people from serving is wrong, and five more years of discrimination is wrong.
2. It costs the gov't a ton of taxpayer money every year to discharge military personnel, money that could be spent elsewhere.
3. Recruiting is so low the military has had to start recruiting ex-convicts and drug abusers. Part of that is the tens of thousands who have been discharged under Don't Ask, Don't Tell. I'd like the military to have the best personnel available.
4. I'd like the military to have the capability it needs, and a high number of Arabic linguists have been discharged.

Get your copy of The Progressive Revolution
Me on Facebook

Me on Twitter


[ Parent ]
okay (0.00 / 0)
1. i agree.  but the question is why is it more wrong than all of the other things that are done to lgbt people that are wrong (e.g. incitement to kill in jamaica, possible genocide in uganda potentially influenced/funded by american christian right, doma, ban on adoption, homophobic bullying in schools, not having health care, being discriminated against for their sexuality AND their nationality or gender or disability or other things, etc.)

2. i agree that it is a waste of money.  how much money would it save and is that money worth the political capital in the short term it would cost for lgbt allies to support this measure.  are there other places that could be put?

3 and 4. what's wrong with ex convicts and drug abusers as human beings?  also, why do you want the military to be the best that it can be when it is currently being used to slaughter people, including lgbt people?  of the hundreds of thosuands killed in iraq, don't you think about 10% of them were LGBT?  doesn't militarism reinforce gender stereotypes, and more generally attitudes towards violence and the economy that are destructive to social ends, etc.?  there seems to be some evidence that service increases the chances of domestic violence - why would we want more lgbt people having that experience and why would we want the lgbt partners and children of active service people exposed to that?

these are the reasons why i think the campaign for dadt repeal GIVEN the level of political capital expended and being expended on it needs to be seriously assessed.  Who decided this was the campaign, why is it so singularly focused, and where is the broader social justice context, without which any claim for rights is just an interest group claim (however justified) rather than part of something that snowballs into far greater rights.

i can see arguments for why DADT should be repealed - morally, emotionally, and, under certain somewhat conservative or nationalist or gendered frames - politically.  I can understand that the campaign itself could lead to other gains, and that simply the act of winning could lead to things.  I understand that the military is a core institution in the U.S. whether I like it or not.  but all that said...

why?  Why this?  How did it come about?  that's the objective question if the answers that you gave above on a progressive blog are among the best ones for spending a lot of time and energy repealing dadt (And they probably are).


[ Parent ]
Donate to Open Left







QUICK HITS


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search