Harmony Wu - Primary Pressure Pattern Forms on Health Care

by: cos

Sun Mar 21, 2010 at 08:00


[ Edit: Also posted on Daily Kos ]

In 1970, a group formed after the first Earth Day and, calling themselves Environmental Action, named a "Dirty Dozen" of 12 members of Congress who had the worst record on the environment.  Of those 12 incumbents, 6 were defeated that year, and when they declared a new Dirty Dozen in 1972, 7 of them were defeated.

Perhaps not so coincidentally, Congress passed the Clean Air Act in 1970, the Clean Water Act in 1972, and the Endangered Species Act in 1973, and Republican Richard Nixon signed them all.

Few things in American politics exert as much pressure on legislation as a series of coordinated, serious challenges to incumbents - especially primary challenges.  When legislators see a particular issue driving multiple races that put incumbents at risk, they change their behavior on that issue.

I saw this in action much more recently here in Massachusetts in the fight over whether to ban equal marriage.

And now the same pattern is quickly emerging, with Harmony Wu's challenge to Stephen Lynch (MA-9) joining two other primary prominent challenges in recent weeks focused on health care.

cos :: Harmony Wu - Primary Pressure Pattern Forms on Health Care

Flipping the Massachusetts Legislature

Our legislative battle over marriage in Massachusetts began when our legislature voted 105 to 92 in favor of banning equal marriage in early 2004.  By September 2005, when a required second vote was held on the same constitutional amendment, it was rejected in favor of a new amendment being proposed through a referendum petition, which would only need 25% support in the legislature to pass (but would also require votes in two successive sessions).  The first vote on that amendment, at the tail end of the 2005-2006 legislature, was 61 for and 132 against - a little more than the required 25% yes.  On its second vote, it failed to make even that limited requirement, rejected on a vote of 45-151.

In just a few years, we went from 53% of the legislature supporting a ban, to just 23%.  How?

The opening shot was the fall 2004 primary.  In New Bedford, Stephen Canessa defeated incumbent Mark Howland in the Democratic primary for state representative, and more astonishingly, in Somerville & Medford, 26 year old Carl Sciortino, who is gay, defeated 16-year incumbent Vinnie Ciampa in the Democratic primary.

These defeats shocked a number of equal marriage opponents in the state house, one of whom was heard saying to another, "they're coming for us".  After a series of 3 special elections at the beginning of 2005, all won by marriage supporters, and then progressive Pat Jehlen's blowout victory in a state senate special election that summer, the message was clear: Voting to ban equal marriage was a serious risk to one's electoral prospects.

The number of legislators who changed their votes greatly outnumbered the votes that were changed by replacing old legislators with new ones, and in several races for open seats, candidates supporting the ban either didn't run or weren't taken seriously.  Serious electoral challenges have serious effects well beyond their own districts.

A Wave of Health Care-Inspired Challenges?

On March 1st, Arkansas Lt. Governor Bill Halter announced he would run in the Democratic primary for US Senate against incumbent Blanche Lincoln, one of the main Democratic obstacles to passing reform in the Senate.  The very next day, Halter issued a press release saying he supports a public option, and signaling that Lincoln's opposition to a public option would be a major issue.  Within days of entering the race, Halter raised millions of dollars from unions and progressive groups, ensuring a well-funded and credible challenge to Lincoln.

Earlier this week, another notorious Democratic opponent of reform, Representative Bart Stupak of Michigan, picked up a primary challenger, Connie Saltonstall.  Very quickly, progressive groups joined her in supporting the bid.  Saltonstall made it clear that she decided to run because Stupak was using abortion as a wedge issue to block health reform, "putting their [the pro-life caucus] interests above those of his district."

Harmony Wu Challenges Stephen Lynch

Last night, a third challenge popped up, when Harmony Wu of Needham, MA said she'd likely run against him if he votes against reform, as he has announced he plans to do.  Immediately, a Draft Harmony Wu group sprang up, and right now, volunteers are out collecting signatures in Boston to put her on the ballot.

Three weeks into March, three new primary challenges against Democrats who are being obstacles to reform.  Each one of these challengers has made health care a focus of their campaign, and each one of them is probably or definitely in the race in the first place because of health care.  A clear pattern is forming "we're coming for you".

Applying Pressure

Our short term goal: Make as much buzz as we can right now about these, and especially about Harmony Wu, to make sure the press covers her this weekend.  When Democratic lawmakers vote on reform, possibly tomorrow, they need to be aware of this emerging challenge.

In the long term, we can use these challenges to set a narrative for the 2010 election season.  If reform fails to pass now, and we defeat some of its opponents, we'll get another chance.  And even if reform does pass, we will need to make it better, and likely need to add a public option.  A series of strong pro-reform challenges this year will give us a chance to do those things next year.

Edit: A top Obama organizer is weighing running against Stephanie Herseth Sandlin if she votes against reform.  Also, labor groups recruiting a candidate to run against Michael Arcuri in upstate New York - h/t econlibVA on dailykos.


Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

All that is missing is health care reform. n.t (4.00 / 3)


This is a great trend (4.00 / 2)
I hope we can change the Congress over the next few years.

FYI, the link to the associated Kos diary is broken. There is an extra "h" at the beginning.


Fixed (0.00 / 0)
Thanks.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]
Thanks (4.00 / 5)
This is exactly what Open Left and other progressive communities should do in the aftermath of the HCR fight, regardless of what happens with the actual vote. I'd forgotten the Dirty Dozen but it is the perfect model to use. Indeed, the one unassailable progressive "win" in the HCR battle, and bank regulation and climate change issues, is that we know exactly which Democratic politicians feel more comfortable pushing Republican policies instead of policies that benefit working people and small businesses, you know, 90-99% of the population. We didn't know that before with actual votes to prove it.

I'd also like to see Democrats push for Grayson's Medicare buyin, specifically, get someone in the Senate to push the same bill, someone like Sanders and/or Bennett. Then try to get it passed in the next few months, if not the next year. Basically be persistent and never give up.


the buyin is fuel for majority rules (4.00 / 1)
nothing like Grayson's bill is ever going to get 60 votes in this pre-cataclysm Senate. but when the next Congress starts, if the Democrats are still in control, they can change that.

we need to hang that around their necks. make a committment to support majority rule a requirement for support. you can't get health care, or climate change bandaids, or real financial regulation, or anything else without it.

(not that having majority rule would magically make all that stuff happen, these are Democrats after all. necessary but not sufficient.)

not everything worth doing is profitable. not everything profitable is worth doing.


[ Parent ]
Instead of marches and prayer vigils, etc (4.00 / 1)
you are absolutely right that we need to go after specific legislators that we can realistically make pay, and put the rest on notice.  This failure to target specific legislators as opposed to broad kumbaya protests has been a key failure of the Left.  

--Aaron Schutz (Core Dilemmas of Community Organizing)

This is a false choice (4.00 / 1)
If (it's a big if) a march is done properly, it can be a tool to help build the kind of identity that would be needed in order to mount effective electoral challenges.  It should be clear that we haven't built a real movement yet. That sort of effort must be attended to simultaneously to electoral politics - which also must include not only targeting of sitting legislators but electing new legislators who can take leading roles for our causes.  

Politics is the art of the possible, but that means you have to think about changing what is possible, not that you have to accept it in perpetuity.

[ Parent ]
In theory it may be a false choice (0.00 / 0)
but in fact, too many just do marches.  

--Aaron Schutz (Core Dilemmas of Community Organizing)

[ Parent ]
Fair enough - I don't disagree with that (0.00 / 0)
I do disagree about your suggested solution.

Politics is the art of the possible, but that means you have to think about changing what is possible, not that you have to accept it in perpetuity.

[ Parent ]
It may be that by focusing on (4.00 / 2)
marches in the first place, given this tradition, that we are perpetuating a tendency towards the nonstrategic.  I am inclined to think this is right, and that we should focus on strategic efforts first and kumbaya later.  Because otherwise we will never get beyond the big marches.  

In other words, we need to act to resist the current left traditions that are not very productive to us.  So, again, I think you are right in the abstract.  But with the reality of where "we" are at the moment, and the amount of reeducation about how politics operates that is necessary, we should focus on where we are weak.  I mean, we'll still do marches.  There is no danger of that going out of style.  

--Aaron Schutz (Core Dilemmas of Community Organizing)


[ Parent ]
USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox