Overnight open thread

by: Chris Bowers

Mon Mar 22, 2010 at 00:00


Health reform has passed the House.  The reconciliation "fix" to the Senate bill, too.

Personal reactions:

I feel relief that the most difficult aspects of this specific fight are over.  This was just an utterly grueling fight.

I feel grateful to everyone who participated in this fight, even to those on the left who opposed final passage.

I feel determined, in that this is just a step in the right direction.  There is a long way to go before we achieve universal health care in this county.

I feel sad that it came at the cost of throwing reproductive rights under the bus.  Any win that means hurting some of your friends is not a full win.

I feel frustrated, because I know we could have won the public option campaign, but it didn't happen.

It feels good that Democrats did something with their majority.  I hope it works out well, and provides the benefits its strongest supporters say it will.

This is an open thread.  Tomorrow, more fights ensue.  Good night.

Chris Bowers :: Overnight open thread

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Thanks for all your work Chris (4.00 / 19)
You and others here have made a major impact.

Seconded! (4.00 / 5)


Self-refuting Christine O'Donnell is proof monkeys are still evolving into humans

[ Parent ]
... (0.00 / 0)
Wouldn't it be possible to minimize the Executive Order over the next year?   At the least keep it to the status quo.  

Agree though, this is the first step in a long journey.   Pushing for Grayson, or at least a version of Grayson which gives at a minimum 50+ Medicare buyin would be huge.      


There won't be another step. This was it. (4.00 / 3)
I hope you get what you think you are getting from it.

Bear in mind (4.00 / 6)
That the next time that anything positive happens regarding health care at the federal level, that instance will prove you wrong.

[ Parent ]
I don't care about being wrong (4.00 / 8)
What do I lose in your mind by being wrong here? A better health care bill in the near future. Wow, horrible. Your point is for someone with an ego.

What do I gain by pointing out that this is likely it? Hopefully progressives will wake up to do a better job on upcoming policy debates like with finance reform.

Once, one takes their personality out of the equation, it makes these things easier.  


[ Parent ]
My point is that this ISN'T likely it (4.00 / 4)
You don't actually have any mechanism by which to measure the likelihood of future action.  You're just being fatalistic.

So when something positive does happen in the future, remember how certain you were that it wouldn't, and abandon your fatalism.  It's an unhelpful trait that actually hinders positive change.  


[ Parent ]
LOL, Right. Look, the barometer is the behavior observed from the progressive (3.56 / 9)
leadership thus far.  Prove me wrong by actually doing something progressive rather than passing a right of center bill.

The people involved in any given project is one of the best barometers for determining probability of success. Progressives are lacking.

If you want me to believe something different about the leadership, they will need to prove it. Right now, you are flapping your gums and typing just like you did before. Yet, you have a right leaning bill to show for it.

Even Chris's statement makes it perfectly clear that the bill is right leaning as he separates it from the left. I am no longer impressed by what you have to say.

Your actions will speak louder than your talk. Because all you are is bills that will never pass and words about hoping for the future.  You don't even have a mechansim. YOu just have a lot of talk.


[ Parent ]
Leadership changes (4.00 / 2)
Is this the best we'll get this year?  Yes.  Is this the best we'll get in the next two years?  Maybe.  Is this the best we'll get in the next three years?  Many elections occur between then and now, so who knows?

[ Parent ]
LOL. Okay. hope hope hope! (4.00 / 2)


[ Parent ]
Good point, guess I'll give up (0.00 / 0)


[ Parent ]
you better jus stop (1.33 / 3)
flappin them there gums and gives up hope. aint nuttin good gonna ever happen. all u are iz bills!???? we all gonna die anywayz  read the bible and other random shit

Extraordinary progressive star in the making

[ Parent ]
No it is much better to give me zeros to show how confident you are (3.33 / 6)
in whatyou are saying here. LOL. Please continue to make my point for me.

[ Parent ]
So what's the plan for getting a PO/Medicare Buy-in? (3.43 / 7)
If it's just "electing better people" to Congress, then, okay, that was always the plan whether or not this legislation passed.

Except now, regardless of how many better Democrats we get, we're still stuck with this legislation, which you might see as a benefit to the uninsured but I see as an enslavement act to the health insurance industry.


[ Parent ]
Please... Obama is telling us it's over.... (4.00 / 10)
why do you think he and every other weak Democrat is comparing this to what Teddy Roosevelt, FDR, and Truman as well as Ted Kennedy have been trying to accomplish. This is Obama's mission accomplished moment. He and the cheerleaders at the kos and many other places are talking about Newt Gingrich's bill from 1994 as national public health care reform they wanted. It's a joke.

With no resemblance of any public option the "improving SS over the years" metaphor is dead. before Kucnich decided to support this bill he was right in calling it built on a foundation of sand.

Also, think about the heavy lifting the Democrats didn't want to do, yet somehow after huge majorities and a huge mandate was won in 2008 and they ran away, they are somehow going to do it now after the 2010 loses which will still be there because Obama is not listening to Volcker.

So be happy with what you got, which isn't very much all considering.



[ Parent ]
Spot on. Any loses this year will be seen as a need to move right, not left (4.00 / 3)
Although it was right of center economic policies that will lead to the loses. But I am nearly ready to give up on getting people out of the faith based politics. It is as frustrating as when I did care enough to canvass in 2004 and talking to hard core supporters.

[ Parent ]
This is sad and true (4.00 / 4)
It's a dangerous precedent set that "success" comes from moving right and I cringe to think how watered down Elizabeth Warren's CFPA will get with this precedent along with every other major issue.

I have tried to keep faith when many others(whom I respect, the single payer or nothing people who were eventually right I must say) wouldn't because we at least had the "it can be improved like SS was" metaphor, but no without some resemblance of public administration to build on.

So I really am disillusioned and you have it right; faith based politics is just as bad in the Democratic party. I have found this out, nor more painfully than right now.



[ Parent ]
I wrote this diary over a year ago...still applies today. (4.00 / 2)
"If you need to change a paradigm, you must think OUTSIDE the box.  

Clinton is criticized for her UNIVERSAL health care plan by Obamaphiles because DC won't go for it.

If you give DC a plan that is just one step to the left, they will drag you and it - YUP, and Dems will be partners in that dragging - right back to the middle...nowhere!!!!

But if you give DC a plan that forces big thinking and possible big changes AT LEAST YOU WILL GET THINGS MOVING and not stand still, in the same place.

But we all know the BO doesn't really want change - he wants to talk about ending the bitterness in DC but has no policies that will actually do that.

All talk.  No action.  

And the "screwee" of his "big" vision?  We, the people."



[ Parent ]
How to accomplish things (4.00 / 1)
1) Denigrate whatever happens
2) Give up
3) Get angry


[ Parent ]
How to not effectively argue (4.00 / 6)
1) Use straw mans

2) Don't realize to whom you are speaking to about accomplishments and what they mean

3) Pretend everything is OK when it wasn't the day the public option died.




[ Parent ]
Probably the reason I don't realize who I'm speaking to (0.00 / 0)
Is that you use a pseudonym and link to posts wherein you don't identify yourself.

[ Parent ]
This was it? (4.00 / 3)
Does that mean you're giving up on a Medicare buy-in? Giving up on any more health care activism?

[ Parent ]
Hell no... (4.00 / 1)
But, can we take a couple days off?  We haven't had a vacation in a long while!

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


[ Parent ]
You can take the next 10 to 15 years off (3.27 / 11)


[ Parent ]
I don't understand why this is troll-rated, unless it's some kind of code language I don't know about (3.43 / 7)


[ Parent ]
Uprated for ratings abuse. (4.00 / 7)
If this place starts acting like the herd on dailykos, I'm out of here.  I barely go to orange anymore because I can't stand the vapid cheerleading.  The diaries at dailykos have become magnets for centrist teabaggers in t-shirts and that maybe giving them too much credit.  

[ Parent ]
Well they are using the exact same approaches (4.00 / 3)
troll rate disagreement, use terms like ad honinems when such terms are not applicable etc. So, I expect to see more of that here. They have practically driven off all dissent on daily kos and the management there does not seem to care.

[ Parent ]
Because this comment basically says "fuck off" (0.00 / 0)
It's totally content-free.

[ Parent ]
no it says that he or she expects things not to change for a very long time. (0.00 / 0)
you're reading snark where there isn't much.

[ Parent ]
You really are projecting a lot here (0.00 / 0)
What I am writing is that we need to realize this is it on this bill, and learn from it for upcoming battles like finance reform.  I have said that so many times along this and other threads about how progressives/liberals fail at negotiation and that we need to stop waiting for some future point of hope. Hope is not a policy change. Figuring out how to do things better is. Right now, for example, your inablility to even aknowledge the very real possibility that change will not occur for decades is illustrative of a problematic mindset. You can't even entertain you are wrong. Whereas I have said, I am fine with being wrong here because it will mean reform is happening. Yet in your mind, this is all emotional 'I am snarking you" You are not that important. Living in a better country with better outcomesf or all is. We differ about how you get there. You think you get there through hoping for it. I don't we get there through realism.

[ Parent ]
Uprated to counter TR abuse. (4.00 / 3)
That is just silly.

Health insurance is not health care.
If you don't fight, you can't win.
Never give up. Never Surrender.
Watch out for flying kabuki.


[ Parent ]
The funny thing is that they don't get my point (4.00 / 4)
My point is learn from your mistakes so that future bills on other issues will go well rather than engaging in hope as the main operation for policies. Instead, they set around being truly fatalistic by leaving it all to hope.

[ Parent ]
Medicare buy in is not going to happen (4.00 / 3)


[ Parent ]
Unlikely... (4.00 / 6)
Medicare has been amended at least a dozen times with expansion in at least 1/2 of those changes...

SCHIP has been expanded TWICE in the last 10 years.... COBRA was expanded last year...

History shows that existing programs are much easier to improve than starting from scratch.

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


[ Parent ]
LOL, okay whatever. See me in a year when the bill never gets past (4.00 / 1)
where it is now.

[ Parent ]
Okay but how about in three or five years? (4.00 / 4)
The world doesn't end next year.

[ Parent ]
You are not going to get more under this presidency (3.50 / 8)
this was it. are you new to politics? Think about what you are suggesting. They would have to go against the White House. The bill that just passed was the bill that the president wanted. You are expecting progressives to suddenly do what they were unwilling to do even when they had leverage- go up against the White House. Is this possible? Anything is possible. Is it likely? It is extremely unlikely given who the progressives are in the national leadership.  

[ Parent ]
So what's the plan to pass a Medicare Buy-in? (3.43 / 7)
How do we get to 218 votes in the House and 51 (or 60) in the Senate?

[ Parent ]
How do you get those votes? (0.00 / 0)
Eh, you don't.  Ever.

Unless you get a leader in the WH and throw every "Dem" bum out of Congress.  


[ Parent ]
Also, what's the "program" that we're improving here? (3.33 / 6)
I don't see any real "programs" in this legislation, unless you mean the subsidies, the expansion of which would mean better coverage of people but also more money flowing into insurance industry coffers.

So what are we proposing to expand here?


[ Parent ]
Bookmarked (4.00 / 2)
For future ridicule and mocking...

Self-refuting Christine O'Donnell is proof monkeys are still evolving into humans

[ Parent ]
No, there will be another step (4.00 / 5)
They're going to gut Medicare (and Social Security, but that's less directly health related).  Oh, and the GOP is going to gut the subsidies, probably with Obama's signature on the bill.  

We've only just begun to move further right!

But, yeah, no way Obama takes on reform again.  This entire bill is designed to prevent that, particularly the fact that many of the provisions don't even kick in until after he's up for re-election (a sure sign of suckitude, IMO).  

Healthcare is not going away, it's still going to collapse, albeit after we've thrown millions more dollars at the insurance companies.  But it's quite clear that nothing will be done about it until it collapses.  


[ Parent ]
I forgot one more thing that will happen (4.00 / 5)
"Progressives" will ban together to try to stop the White House from gutting Medicare, will win minor concessions, and then will declare a great victory when Medicare is only 90% gutted.  Because they kept it from being as bad as it was going to be (and, of course, Obama will have no choice so be sure to vote for him again in 2012, particularly women because if you don't the Republicans will take away your abortion rights!).

[ Parent ]
Two great posts in a row! (0.00 / 0)
I wish I had more "recommends" to use.

[ Parent ]
You know what's super-hilarious right now? (4.00 / 4)
Reading redstate.com.

Tonight the Democrats voted to put people in jail who have no insurance

Rrrrright.

The second lesson that should be learned is that there is no such thing as a Pro-Life Democrat.

Democrats who voted against the bill, take note -- nobody cares.

It is easy in the face of what happened tonight to sound or become defeatist. You mustn't.

Freedom needs you now more than ever. The fight has only just begun. But we must be clear what the strategy is and what the battle plan looks like.

ONWARD CHRISTIAN SOLDIERS!


Oh, and this (4.00 / 6)
Friends, if we are going to destroy the Democrats, we must first build up an army of real conservatives in Congress. Half measures, Democrat-lite, and men who compromise in favor of more government must be unacceptable.

Yes, this is the answer.  Entertain silly fantasies about repealing this entire bill and purge all the pragmatism from your party.  Do it up, guys.


[ Parent ]
Ironic (4.00 / 3)
Since Bush resided over the biggest expansion of Federal government since the 30's.

[ Parent ]
And this ... (4.00 / 6)
from The Tan Man himself:

"Hard to sleep right now... this is how my hero Strom Thurmond must have felt back in 1957. #healthcare #sadday"

http://twitter.com/GOPBoehner/...



[ Parent ]
My God!!! (4.00 / 4)
This needs to be pasted everywhere!!!  WTF????

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


[ Parent ]
yeah (4.00 / 2)
he's a sick piece of shit

Extraordinary progressive star in the making

[ Parent ]
WHAT?!!!! (0.00 / 0)
   Much worse then what Trent Lott said!!!!  He needs to resign for that comment.  My God...

[ Parent ]
Cancel that (4.00 / 4)
It's a fake account.

Real one: http://twitter.com/Johnboehner


[ Parent ]
thats what (4.00 / 2)
I just figured esp with the treason comment. Either way I'm sure that's what boehner really thinks.

Extraordinary progressive star in the making

[ Parent ]
Good luck to them... (4.00 / 3)
After Obama signs the bills, he will convene the death panels, and I'm sure they will be on the list!!

***rolls eyes***

Whatever!

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


[ Parent ]
This is just the start (0.00 / 0)
I have HCR hangover and we still have another bar to hit. The Stupak agreement is another example of Christian privilege that violates my religious rights and a woman's right to her body. I hope that the price was enough and that we keep working on shaping the reform into what it should be including a viable Public Option that ends the monopoly practices of the health insurance industry.

I'll be watching


P.O. (4.00 / 7)
isn't dead. That plus the Grayson Medicare buy-in would be nice additions.

in any regard, it's a first step. hopefully the next few steps come quicker.


... (4.00 / 2)
Why do you need a PO if you have Medicare buy-in?   Seems like a waste of money that can be better used elsewhere if the Medicare Buy-in for all is enacted.

[ Parent ]
yes (0.00 / 0)
you're right. One or the other would be a huge improvement and would be something that my wife and I could really benefit from (my employer wanted $770/m for her policy). Then we found out that state law didn't allow her to have a cheaper private plan because my employer offered her one. She's a student.

[ Parent ]
... (0.00 / 0)
Wow... that's bullshit.    Why would  a state have a law blocking someone from getting insurance elsewhere?   What state is that?

Hopefully, you'll find a cheaper option in the exchanges eventually or maybe she would be eligible for the high risk plans that are the gap fillers until the pre-existing conditions aspect kicks in in 2014.  Maybe this would supercede that idiotic state law.

I agree though, I would love to see one or the other enacted... preferably medicare as I feel it would be cheaper to implement and the additional premiums would help improve medicare.    


[ Parent ]
the great state (0.00 / 0)
of New Jersey. We live in Hoboken while she goes to school across the Hudson in nYc. I believe this is the only state in the union that has such a rule. Insurance companies know they can bleed consumers dry through such policy and might be one major reason why the public plans we looked at were better and at almost half the cost of what we were offered through work.

We'll be out of here well before 2014, but crap like this is another reason why the PO or Medicare buy-in would be such good policy.

 


[ Parent ]
Thank you world! (4.00 / 1)
Thank you for this hi-larious comedy of errors over the past year! I cried; I laughed; I didn't need the whole of my seat (because I only needed the edge).

But maybe for your next performance, you could do something a little less--commercial.


I'm a little emotional (4.00 / 1)
I don't know if it's because this health-care bill is historic, even though I know it doesn't go far enough or if I'm sad that it takes so goddam much effort in this country to take care of sick people.

I'm emotional too, because it IS historic (4.00 / 7)
AFAIK, for the first time in American history, the United States national government will require by law, with few exceptions, people to pay private, for-profit corporations as a condition of merely being here in the United States.

What we are beholding here is the complete merging of corporate greed and state.  So yes, it is historic.


[ Parent ]
they merged about 10-15 years ago (4.00 / 3)
what you're beholding is the Democratic Party's stamp of approval in the name of progress.

And, depending on who you ask, either the first incremental steps to ending that merger or its consolidation in a different form.


[ Parent ]
Yay, we won! (0.00 / 0)
  Very happy day.

Who won? (2.00 / 2)
Certainly not women.  Or those who have to wait 4 years for anything to start to kick in.  Of those who will be given huge premiums for pre-existing conditions or face fines large enough to bankrupt their tiny incomes.

Oh, wait.  You work for an insurance company!  How silly of me.  Yes....you can begin to gouge Americans ASAP as you wait for 2014 to roll around.  Just like the banksters and credit card companies.

Happy Day in Hartford!


[ Parent ]
Oh yeah? (0.00 / 0)
  You work for SATAN!!!!!!!!!

[ Parent ]
Nancy is the best (4.00 / 6)
Speaker of the House Ever. If only Harry Reid was half as good as Nancy, we would have the Medicare for all already. But he isn't, so we have to settle for one step closer to total victory.  As Of today Health Care is consider a right and no longer a Privilege. So now starts the battle to make sure each and every citizen of the US gets the Health Care that is their birth right.

Co-sta Ri-ca Here We Come! (4.00 / 10)
They did universal healthcare back in the '50s. Three generations ago.

With today's bill, we still don't have that, but we do lock in the free market health insurance system in this country (check your stock portfolios on Monday!), and as an aside, we even have various degrees of coverage for up to 10% of the population. Starting in whatever year the coverage actually goes into effect.

And like the Dems say, this is just the start of a 50 year struggle for...well they never actually say what it's for, just that it's the start of a 50 year struggle. And that no one on our side is going to revisit the issue for at least 10 years. So I guess in 10 years we can embark on a 50 year struggle to do what a third world country did some 60ish years ago. Unfortunately, all we had going for us this time around were the biggest Democratic majorities in 30 years in both houses of Congress, and a newly elected president with an explicit mandate for change, particularly on this issue.

I have to admit, that kind of has me down from time to time. Especially when I remember the president dismissing single payer last summer by saying that "the current system has been in place so long, you can't just start over with something new". Which I guess applies not only to health care, but financial reform and education and labor laws and the environment and well, just about everything I guess.

But then one of our Dem leaders will remind me of the struggles of Harriet Tubman or Big Bill Haywood, or any number of progressive heroes. And they remind me of the struggles those folks went through, as they fought against institutionalized greed and prejudice, backed by a powerful money machine and the cultural sensibilities of the elite. (They usually do this right after voting against drug importation, or the capping of usury, or dropping pro-union legislation, or after having health care reform protestors arrested.)

And they say "glacierpeaks! Of course losing is disappointing. And change is hard and long! So long-who knows when it will actually happen. But when you think about it, each time you lose, it makes you just a little more like Harriet and Big Bill."

So I say, this bill is just the first step! There's no stoppin' us now. And when we have the occasional disappointment every time the Dems actually vote on something, I'll just identify with the miseries of people before me, and I'll do that each year, and after a 50 year struggle maybe we can do what Costa Rica did 60ish years ago.



If I were in my early life instead of having (4.00 / 3)
a daughter and three grandsons with roots in Michigan,  I'd be outta here so fast my head would spin.  Why anybody would want to stay in this ugly, murdering, and piggy country is beyond me.   There are places willing to pay us to come there.   Who knows.  Maybe anyway.  I keep working on my grandsons to expand their horizons, and my SIL works for a company that could provide him a transfer overseas.  

[ Parent ]
Our son and DIL are working in London... (4.00 / 1)
...and will probably be transferred back here in the not too distant future.  My husband and I have suggested they look at Canada instead of the "good ole U S of A".

We are stuck here - just built our retirement home - if I had only been smarter, it would have been in some other country.


[ Parent ]
Rooted. (4.00 / 1)
Put additions on our summer house and remodeled our home.  Wish I had sold everything instead and moved into an apartment.  Worked so hard to put down roots only to discover they end up being anchors.  

[ Parent ]
I've got my original roots in Michigan.... (4.00 / 1)
and still have a special place there, too.

Such a wonderful, beautiful state.


[ Parent ]
JDS...where are you? (0.00 / 0)
You've missed another chance to troll-rate anything that I post!!!!!

[ Parent ]
i moved out of the country in 2006 (4.00 / 2)
i couldn't handle it anymore.  i'm waiting for you all to fix it before i come back :)

i currently have:

a) free health care (i did on a one year student visa)
b) opinions that are part of the political spectrum
c) reasonable working hours
d) can call the police without worrying that i'm participating in a massive attempt to violate an entire race of people
e) people around me who do things like talking about social class
f) programs around me to link people up here with people in the developing world so that people in the developing world can have some influence on the general elections here

I also make enouh money to live on, eat well, go out sometimes, pay my taxes, and pay some of the ridiculously high interest debt i have from livingi n the u.s. or borrowing from u.s. lenders as a student here.

don't get me wrong - there are a lot of things wrong with where i am - and really all places - but as an American, I can safely say that the United States is not hospitable to people who are interested in the common good or decency to other people as a principle of politics.  and much less so to people who are working class, Black, women, LGBT, noncitizens, etc. or some combination fo all those.


[ Parent ]
I just had a friend ask me to move to Europe, but I don't think I can do it (0.00 / 0)


[ Parent ]
if you can get a visa and you're not an ethnic minority, i would recommend it (2.00 / 2)
you'll live longer.  if you are an ethnic minority i would think twice, but probably still do it (i did, by way of India).

I like having America on my laptop, and nothing more, for now...


[ Parent ]
He's an older black guy (0.00 / 0)
Like me he's a business man, and he keeps saying he just finds more opportunities there. Unfortunately, unless one's thing is working in the government (which is not my interest), corporate america can be hell on wheels. However, I've started my own business so it is not just that I am not sure I Want to live some place else. Also, I am gay, and he tells me I would find more guys to my liking there, but that's another story.

[ Parent ]
it's easier to be LGBT in Europe (0.00 / 0)
imo.  i am (in the UK).  it's harder to be an LGBT person of color (I'm South Asian).

mostly, though, the quality of life is MUCH MUCH higher.  Trust, me, i have abundant complaints - but I also have thousands of dollars in debt at very high interest rates from financing an independent business (as a freelance journalist and non profit consultant) and living in new york.  When I had health care, I paid hundreds of dollars in COBRA coverage and then went without until I was screamed at that this was idiotic (whcih it is, if you can afford it, which i couldn't).  I was lucky enough to live in a state that provides coverage to low income people so I know what public insurance can be in the United States - it was at least as comparable to my private insurance except for a short time that I was on a union health plan.


[ Parent ]
Thanks for the insight. I have suspected that I would face (0.00 / 0)
problems as a black gay male there. His view is that I won't, but I think he's also biased toward Europe.

[ Parent ]
rule of thumb: (0.00 / 0)
in UK, random stop and searches by the police:

South Asian people get stopped twice as much as White people.  Black people get stopped seven times as much as White people.

Another interesting statistic that I wish someone had told me before I moved here - the UK is about 92-93% White (though that's including eastern european migrants but even then the figures don't drop significantly I don't think).  That's not far from Iowa levels, and even if Lodnon is more diverse than other places, that's starting off from a lower base point of diversity.  

Gives you a sense, at least.  There are other dimensions at play obviously (Islamophobia is a HUGE problem in Europe, imo), but as I'm sure you know, the LGBT community has issues around race as well and that holds true, I think, in Europe as well as in the U.S.

On the other hand, racism and all, Rome and Paris are lovely :)  Like I said, as with all places, there are tradeoffs - if you want a lower stress lifestyle for a while where you don't have to constantly worry about whether you can leave your job because you might not have health care or whether you'll have holidays (you will!) it's worth a few years, at least, i think.  And apparently Birmingham is going to be the first majority-minority city in Europe soon :)  

Plus it's closer to Africa and Asia, which is useful for me, as much as I would love to visit Latin America more :)  Helps fill in gaps you acquire just by dint of being American and growing up there.


[ Parent ]
Thank you again. This really confirms my thinking. Especially the race element. (0.00 / 0)


[ Parent ]
If I leave, I can be (4.00 / 1)
the underground railroad for my daughter and grandkids.  

[ Parent ]
indeed (0.00 / 0)
and you'll all still be able to vote in american elections and participate in conversations like these without being subjected on a constant basis to the extremely conservative environments in the united states.  it does do wonders...

but more to teh point, i think self care is important.  if it's not possible to exist sanely in a place, it's worthwhile to leave.  


[ Parent ]
Is Medicare Buy-in dead? (4.00 / 6)
I won't go so far as to say that the PO or Medicare buy-in are dead for 15-20 years, but tonight's vote set the effort back considerably:

1. After Congress and the WH address an issue, they tend not to revisit it for some time.

2. The Democrats who voted for the current legislation will not be bad-mouthing it.  There will be tremendous pressure within the Party to take a "wait-and-see" approach before addressing HCR again.  (There is even a psychological phenomena that people who are wavering over a decision become more convinced in its correctness simply by making the decision.  Tomorrow. Democrats who were uncertain whether this legislation was, on balance, better than the status quo but who came around in the end will suddenly exhibit certainty that the bill will accomplish great things.)  

3. Someone called this Obama's Mission Accomplished moment.  The Obama WH won't want to hear that remaining cost concerns necessitate Medicare Buy-in any more than the Bush Administration wanted to hear about an insurgency in Iraq.

3. All the institutional players that were bought off to support the current legislation will not have an incentive to come back to the negotiating table for Medicare Buy-in.

4. Everyone is tired of this issue.  Let's just drop it already.

If HCR had failed this year, it would have been electorally bad for Obama and the Dems, but the public perception of a crisis wouldn't have diminished.   But now, I predict that the WH will point to any further demands of Grayson, Kucinich, etc. as evidence that "you can't please everybody, particularly the purist, extreme left wing of the party."

Liberals' hopes to "build upon" the current legislation will likely be dashed upon the rocky shoals of Rahm Emanuel quotes comparing liberals to teabaggers.


#3 is particularly instructive (4.00 / 4)
The interest groups like the insurance industry were pretty quiet during this whole fight, but whenever they did make a fuss it was usually over the public option.

Now that they've won and the bill is passed, I don't see how we get a PO on a stand-alone vote, if it even makes it so far as to get a vote.  Having a "must-pass" HCR bill was the one ounce of leverage we could cling on to in this whole process.  Now that leverage is gone and the improbable has become the nearly impossible, and yet people somehow expect us to be able to achieve it?

Everyone that's wishfully chanting "we can still get a public option!" needs to lay out, very clearly, what exactly is the plan to get there.  If they get to accuse the kill-the-bill side of wishful fantasies, then we get to ask them to put their grand plan for action on the table.


[ Parent ]
i think the plan is modeled after the 1960s democratic party or the 2000s republican party (0.00 / 0)
you build as much power as you can for your party and for your party's faction within your party, wait for a national crisis (which happens from time to time) that temporarily removes the institutional obstacles to major national change and seize on that opportunity to pass something that runs against specific entrenched interests.

will it work?  i don't know - historically it has to an extent.  but that doesn't mean the future is the same as the past.  in essence, the argument is that passing this bill doesn't change anything structural while ameliorating some fo the negative effects of the current system and so we can continue doing what we were doing before.

personally, i don't think anything can happen until the costs of insurance are shown to skyrocket for another 10 years and progressivism (ideally social democracy, but i'm too cynical to believe thatw ill happen) captures the democratic party and the democratic party has an enormous majority.  all of which can only happen with some fighting within the democratic party and some fighting with republicans and a lot of convincing of everyone who doesn't attach themselves to one or the other of those two (which may be millions of people to varying degrees).



[ Parent ]
Okay, that's the same plan we in the kill-the-bill camp have (4.00 / 1)
One of the major selling points of pass-the-bill was that it offered some pathway to Medicare for All that kill-the-bill didn't.

What that pathway was, I don't think they ever explained it.  This, despite mocking the kill-the-billers for not coming up with a better pathway than what you described.  I fault myself for not asking, or at least not asking more persistently.

So now that the bill has passed, I'm going to ask everyone who was cheering its passage: How does passage of this bill get us closer to Medicare for All, in a way that killing the bill would have not?

And I don't count political arguments like "oh the Democrats will retain control of Congress" or "oh the Democrats won't be so discouraged/frightened" since it's still unclear that either will turn out to be the case, and it's also unclear that either actually translates into moving towards Medicare for All.  I mean, what in the actual substance of the bill makes the path to Medicare for All easier?


[ Parent ]
well, i wasn't one of the people cheering (0.00 / 0)
namely because it makes me nauseous, more or less.  But the argument would run that

a) it reinforces the idea that government can do something, even something as limited as passing a bill on a major social issue

b) it demonstrates the Democratic Party can pass major social legislation without Republican support (which hasn't been demonstrated in like a generation)

c) it may (and this is the key part) demonstrate that the solution it legislated is wholly inadequate in terms of controlling costs, providing high quality universal care, and thereby serve as proof by demonstration that conservative market-based solutions to an industry and issue that is defined by economies of scale are stupid and misserve the public.

So collectively, it improves the situation in the short run in purely material terms for some people while making the structural situation in the industry itself worse.  But if progressives are motivated enough to organise against the industry - which they should be given how poor this bill is on multiple fronts, it could lead to a next step, which could then lead to a next step, etc.

In essence, it's an incrementalist approach of jumping half way (or really a fifth of the way ;) to the door, and then again, and then again.

I don't know that we'll ever reach the door, but we will have gotten closer to the door, at least in terms of expansion and quality of coverage and possibly care.

The main honest difference between the kill-the-bill camp and the pass-the-legislation camp basically hinges on - do you prefer risk now without the problem-reinforcing aspects of the bill or do you prefer less risk with the prospect of some of the amerliorating aspects of the bill.

But there are less direct differences in the arguments as well which have to do with people's subjective experiences, their positions on various issues (E.g. abortion rights), their attention to or lack thereof on structural change, their appreciation of or inattention to institutional limits, the extent to which they rely on history as a way of understanding the future vs. not.

basic differences in political approaches that people tend to have, in other words, when they're not a combination of totally slimy and/or ignorant.  And everyone I've interacted with on this website is not slimy and/or ignorant to an extent that I wouldn't talk to them.


[ Parent ]
Okay, thanks (0.00 / 0)
I'll accept (a) and (b) as valid arguments, even though they are still political rather than based on the contents of the bill.  I strongly believe in the idea of promoting government's role in improving people's lives; my problem with this bill is that I see it as more of a benefit for the insurance industry than for ordinary people.

As for (c), while I agree that that may be the case (and I think it would be the best possible outcome at this point) I don't think the pass-the-bill people ever made that argument.  I didn't see too many people saying they wanted the bill to pass so that it would then fail and pave the way for Medicare for All (if anything, that's more something I would say).


[ Parent ]
but whether you work alongside them depends in part on what you think the effects of their actinos are (4.00 / 1)
not their arguments, right? :)

in fact, it would have been impossible for them to say such a thing and I'm not sure I would have liked it if they had and supported it, because that's uber cynical - especially when you're not accountable to anyone - there's no vote of the uninsured governing progressive blog commenters' opinions - they're self-generated.

but that doesn't mean that it may not be an effect of their actions :)

anyway, i've given you both sides of my split response in the two comments- i can see how it will move things forward, but at the same time, it deeply embeds the economic control of insurance industry and pharma and all else over health care and hence health care debates.  it makes it extremely unlikely that there will be single payer health care in the united states for a long time, unless the system collapses altogether (which is possible).

i think it points to the need to minimise money in politics and more broadly to point out and reverse the capture of the u.s. government by special interests in the true sense - sectors of the economy that are damaging all of society, costing a fortune, and contributing little (unless you count administration, lobbying, marketing, prescription drug dependency, profit-taking off of unviersity research, and promoting f"£ked up intellectual property regimes, all at an extremely high cost as a contribution)

anyway, i'm glad that something like immigration reform wasn't debated and i hope it won't be - if this is what they do to people who are constituents, what woudl they do to people who are not?  well the answer is in afghanstian and detention centers and county jails in the u.s.  on the flipside, if they had debated something on which there was more progressive clout because of social conditions (e.g. jobs bill!!! or better yet - debt relief!) and put effort into that rather than trying to fix random macroeconomic problems and a large social problem but at a poorly chosen time - well you might have gotten something comprehensive but on a different issue, and better.


[ Parent ]
but to answer your boldfaced questions a bit more cynically (4.00 / 3)
it doesn't.  the reality is that people have prioritised something other than medicare for all - probably largely for the reasons that chris articulated in his post about why he started to support the bill.

it's unfortunate (to really understate it), but it is a reality that we have to deal with.  But people who are more radical than other people have confronted this problem for a long time - that unless you change structures/institutions/etc while you ameliorate things, you don't get as far as you want to in the long run.


[ Parent ]
Where is there any indication (4.00 / 2)
Obama and the Dem leadership is interested in using a national crisis to pass liberal legislation?  Everything he's done has been to consolidate moves to the right and authoritarian gains.  Look at TARP and the financial crisis -  he didn't use it to reign in the banks, he used it to funnel taxpayer money to them.  The same model the healthcare bill follows (and we are in the midst of a healthcare crisis).


[ Parent ]
i'm talking about 10-20 years from now (4.00 / 2)
i expect less than nothing from the obama administration.  which is a shame, because all i wanted was nothing.

[ Parent ]
I like your answers because whether I agree or disagree (0.00 / 0)
And sometimes I disagree, there is at least an attempt not to bury your head in the sand of what's happening.  

[ Parent ]
One of the reasons I still come to this site is that (0.00 / 0)
unlike other places there is still enough people interested in fact based analysis versus pure belief driven analysis. What I mean is- I can ultimately disagree with someone over what should be done (a la Paul Rosenberg the other day) but on some level basic factual elements of a situation should not be denied just because it does not agree with belief. All to often I am coming to the conclusion that faith based is not right or left or middle. It is a matter of whether one wants to think outside of the bubble. That's why it is ironic to me that people think I am going to be bothered by being wrong about my assertions here. They just don't get it. Fact based analysis comes down to the reality that one can be wrong as a part of the process. If one assumes that one is never going to be wrong, that's just belief.  

[ Parent ]
Does the reconciliation fix have the Obama-proposed commission to regulate insurance company premium increases? (4.00 / 1)
If so, can someone explain how exactly that will work?

No (4.00 / 3)
As many predicted when it was announced, this idea didn't qualify to be in the reconciliation bill because it doesn't deal primarily with the budget.  

[ Parent ]
Okay, how would it have worked, as proposed? (4.00 / 1)


[ Parent ]
it was not a strong provision and its announce was cynical (0.00 / 0)
As far regulations go too subject to political influence. Need a number of chinese walls to work aas concept. Think of it like the issues with finance reform coming up.

[ Parent ]
Good one by the SFGate (4.00 / 1)
Republican's determination to make health care reform Obama's "Waterloo" appears to have succeeded.  Only thing is, Obama turns out to be the Duke of Wellington.
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/...

What I don't like about this is that it makes the Stupak block look like the Prussian Army. Remember Wellington's famous quote? "Either night or the Prussians will come." While this sure must resemble Obama's thinking, to compare extremist "christian" blackmailer Stupak to the great, courageous Marshall Blücher is total nonsense, of course. Blücher didn't ask for any favors or profits in return for his action, he came to the rescue of the British Army because it was the right thing to do!


Stupak is finished... (4.00 / 2)
Just like Nelson, no one likes an extortionist... The right to life folks that he needs so badly to like him have turned on him, and he's alienated his base.  I suspect that his approval numbers are Nelson-like at home now, too.

It's his own fault.  He should have learned Ben Nelson's lesson... don't hold legislation hostage over lies.  

REID: Voting against us was never part of our arrangement!
SPECTER: I am altering the deal! Pray I don't alter it any further!
REID: This deal keeps getting worse all the time!


[ Parent ]
I'm glad it passed (4.00 / 2)
But it does absolute nothing for me until 2014. I'm still completely screwed and there are millions who are much worse off than I am.

The HCR process turned me from a $3,000 contributor and campaign worker to a bitter cynic with a visceral dislike for Obama and the democrats.

It's better than doing nothing, and I'm glad we've got Sotomayor, but Obama really killed my passion.


Good (2.86 / 7)
President Obama deserves your distaste.  He deserves all our distastes.  Wherever we stand on passage of the bill (I was against it), I hope we can all agree that President Obama is not "the shit"; he's just shit, and right now he isn't anything close to some kind of liberal champion.

[ Parent ]
Welcome to the club.... (4.00 / 3)
If this is the best the Democratic Party can do with a majority and mandate, it needs to die along with the health care reform they didn't pass.   Their disregard for the electorate was so complete and flagrant, it was akin to robbing a police station in broad daylight.  I'll never vote for a Democrat again, and I'm certainly not going to give them another dime - ever.  In fact, I look forward to voting against the lying neoliberal in 2012.  

[ Parent ]
Could we slow down? (4.00 / 1)
I absolutely hate this bill, and the Democratic majority hasn't truly earned the progressive vote, but come on...do we throw all the Democrats out? Obama's a Dem, but so is Alan Grayson. Obama wanted something called "healthcare reform" and he got it, such as it is. From where I sit, we progressives will never know what it feels like to bend the will of the centrists because when the chance arose our people--the ones who were s'posed to have our back--folded. That's the lesson of healthcare reform, plain and simple.

I don't know when the stars will align again like they did last fall, but the Bush presidency is proof that the GOP can do an awful lot of damage to the country unchallenged. Obama's not perfect, but his presidency hasn't hit the halfway mark yet. With just a little more savvy on our side, I think there're plenty of things that can be done before the clock runs out.

"This ain't for the underground. This here is for the sun." -Saul Williams


[ Parent ]
the bush presidency was building for 36 years (0.00 / 0)
if you date it from the debacle the republicans suffered in 1964.  

by that sense of time frames, what you're talking about will not happen until about 2030 (if you date it from 1994) or 2037 (if you date it from after the terrorist attacks in 2001, when Bush's fake mandate kicked in).

Not that these dates are certainties and the past predicts the future and all that (things do chagne), but it does give you a sense of what kinds of time frames you're looking at.  So plan accordingly!  and carefully!

if we do so, we might not just get rid of the filibuster, but actually have proportional voting, public fianncing of elections, a social democratic safety net, far more democracy, and above all things that will ensure that, like social security, the changes we want and accomplish will be very hard to get rid of

and we will also look back in horror at the kinds of things that have happened for the past 15 years and are still happening now.


[ Parent ]
If you can't hurt them, you can't negotiate with them. (0.00 / 0)
You have to do it.  

[ Parent ]
Re: Obama (0.00 / 0)
Have you seen this?

This secret deal to kill the PO, combined with another secret deal to kill drug importation/negotiation are the main reasons I have turned against President Obama.  Before I learned of this, I thought he was hapless, incompetent, foolish, and weak, which are not great things to be but are still forgivable so long as his intentions were good.  But now, with this, he can no longer claim even that.

There are many good Democrats to support in 2010, 2012, and beyond.  I don't count President Obama as one of them.  Not anymore.


[ Parent ]
Does that link... (0.00 / 0)
...really prove there was a "secret deal to kill the PO" coming from the White House? The Huffington Post went for hyperbole by saying the White House "promised" something, but if you do some unraveling of the supposed admission by Deputy Chief Of Staff Jim Messina, what it actually reveals is that the SENATE, particularly the Finance Committee, was always the problem. Notice how the House Of Reps, where the true agitation for the PO was, is portrayed by lobbyists as crazies or something?

Near as I can tell, Baucus & Co. negotiated some deal for a cap on hospital costs with the industry, then told the White House that they'd probably only have the votes for co-ops. True, Obama could've told them to F-ck off!, but at the time they were still thinking (stupidly, of course) about bipartisanship. That's nothing insidious, but it may be "hapless"--to use your word--and ultimately, foolish.  

"This ain't for the underground. This here is for the sun." -Saul Williams


[ Parent ]
I'm not sure which language you're reading (4.00 / 1)
Here's what I'm quoting that sums up both the pharma deal and the hospital deal (emphasis added):

Drug industry lobbyists said they negotiated a deal to contribute $80 billion over 10 years toward the cost of an overhaul with Mr. Baucus, under White House supervision, before taking it to the president for final approval. House lawmakers have said they were caught by surprise when it was announced.

Hospital industry lobbyists, speaking on condition of anonymity for fear of alienating the White House, say they negotiated their $155 billion in concessions with Mr. Baucus and the administration in tandem. House staff members were present, including for at least one White House meeting, but their role was peripheral, the lobbyists said.

Several hospital lobbyists involved in the White House deals said it was understood as a condition of their support that the final legislation would not include a government-run health plan paying Medicare rates - generally 80 percent of private sector rates - or controlled by the secretary of health and human services.

"We have an agreement with the White House that I'm very confident will be seen all the way through conference," one of the industry lobbyists, Chip Kahn, director of the Federation of American Hospitals, told a Capitol Hill newsletter.



[ Parent ]
Believe what you wanna believe… (0.00 / 0)
...but what I know is that lobbyists are notorious, agenda-driven spinners (read: liars), so the idea of "lobbyists, speaking on condition of anonymity for fear of alienating the White House" is especially suspect. Then, the only quote for attribution is from "a Capitol Hill newsletter"?!? Isn't this a NY Times story? Whatever...

"This ain't for the underground. This here is for the sun." -Saul Williams

[ Parent ]
First off, Chip Kahn is not anonymous (4.00 / 1)
Secondly, to quote the first page of the same article:

Not to worry, Jim Messina, the deputy White House chief of staff, told the hospital lobbyists, according to White House officials and lobbyists briefed on the call. The White House was standing behind the deal, Mr. Messina told them, capping the industry's costs at a maximum of $155 billion over 10 years in exchange for its political support.

This is someone in the White House backing the deal.  I don't know how you were blaming Senate Finance earlier; whether the deal was originally negotiated by Baucus or not is irrelevant - the point is, the President was involved in a secret, closed-door deal after having campaigned extensively on transparency.  The contrast between Obama's rhetoric as a candidate and his actual actions as President is truly cringeworthy, not to mention reprehensible.

Thirdly, as the article goes on to mention, the Obama White House cutting these deals undermines and contradicts his publicly-stated goal of having a public option.  Not only was he going against a liberal goal, he was doing so dishonestly.

Fourthly, would you be this skeptical and defensive if the President in question were George W. Bush or John McCain?


[ Parent ]
Disagreeing is not being defensive… (0.00 / 0)
...and I'm not sure how any speculation about Bush or McCain is relevant. As I said, Chip Kahn, the only attributed quote was from "a Capitol Hill newsletter."  

"This ain't for the underground. This here is for the sun." -Saul Williams

[ Parent ]
To misquote a sociopath (4.00 / 1)
"you don't make policy with the congress you want, you make policy with the congress you have."

and the results reflects that.


"It sounds wrong...
     ...but its right."


[ Parent ]
i'm not sure if you're being entirely fair to sociopaths here (0.00 / 0)
but we'll leave that debate for another day :)

[ Parent ]
Further change dead for 15-20 years? (4.00 / 2)
I think not.  This is just fatalism talking.

But if we're so frigging smart that we can foretell the budgetary crisis that awaits our healthcare system somewhere down the road, NOW is the time to get ready our answer to that inevitable crisis.

It must be Medicare for All.  It must be removing the profit motive from the medical system.  It must be removing the for-profit insurers whose very raison d'etre is an unavoidable conflict of interest.  

That is the battle we need to be about now.  Only this time "for Healthcare Reform" is not enough.  Too vague.

But understand, this intermediate step put us in this position.  Now it's up to us to make something of it.

sTiVo's rule: Just because YOU "wouldn't put it past 'em" doesn't prove that THEY did it.


REad the comment below (1.33 / 3)
it represents reality. People like you are scary to me because you are nothing but bush supporters circa 2003. You believe what you want to believe without regard to any facts thrown your way.

[ Parent ]
Ad Hominem - Off Target (4.00 / 1)
The comment you sneered at is actually complementary to the comment you describe as reality. "Reality" says costs will rise quickly and real movement could happen by 2016. That's a mere 6 years from now which agrees with sTivo that 15-20 years is far too pessimistic. Both see rising costs as a way that Medicare for All may get new life in the future. So what's with the over the top personal attack?

[ Parent ]
You seem to not know what the word ad honinem means (4.00 / 1)
Disagreement with you over your version of reality is not an ad honinem. If that's an ad honinem then all disagrees are. This is again is pretty sad how much of you are invested in your version of reality. Bush circa 2003.

[ Parent ]
Ad hominem (4.00 / 1)
You seem not to know how to spell "Ad Hominem". I'd say that characterizing the commenter as a Bush Supporter based on that comment qualifies as a personal attack on a left-wing blog.

Best to leave the mind-reading for social gatherings instead of trying to decipher the motivations of blog commenters from a few sentences.


[ Parent ]
You really have no idea what the logical fallacy means (0.00 / 1)
Repeating back to me what I say does not convince me that you do understand it, especially where you seemingly are unable to understand analogies either now. Look, I get it, you have to justify your behavior in some way other thann the fact that you don't like dissent. But that all this really is.

[ Parent ]
I see Daily Kos has infected this site as well. (0.00 / 0)
First JDS with the 0 ratings for dissent. And then the endless circle jerks about misused terms out of reasoning. Apparently, we can not even question your use of definitions now without being zero rated for it. As I said, and JDS confirms, this is about dissent. Good luck with working with JDS CUrt, If Daily Kos is any judge, youa re going to need it.

[ Parent ]
maybe you (0.00 / 1)
should move to Europe after all.  

Extraordinary progressive star in the making

[ Parent ]
I agree (0.00 / 1)
rabbithole just likes to spend his time here all day harassing people he thinks aren't as smart as him.

Extraordinary progressive star in the making

[ Parent ]
I cannot imagine anything else passing in the short term. (4.00 / 2)
The only way to get to Medicare for all is to wait for costs to soar even further.  Massachusetts, which passed a bill similar to this in 2006, is just beginning to grapple with the fact that, surprise, costs are still rising quickly.
Since the bulk of this plan does not even kick in until 2014, it will be at least 2016-18 before I can see any real movement.

I like Alan Grayson's Medicare buy-in bill, but I predict it will top out at 100 cosponsors or so and go nowhere the way Medicare for All did for years.  Conyers used to introduce Medicare for all every Congress, 60-80 would sign up as cosponsors, and then nothing, not even a hearing would happen.  Medicare for All never did get more than the merest of mentions in Congress and nearly all of the corporate press.


you can't imagine the same bill + lowering the medicare eligibility age 10 years? (0.00 / 0)
it's one thing to acknowledge limitations.  It's another thing not to probe whether those limitations are as binding as we think they are.  

Personally, I think more could have been one - starting by having 'medicare for all' as the beginning point which could have been arrived at through a discussion among progressives to PRESENT to the congressional progressive caucus and ending with the use of progressive power at every step of the way, both inside and outside congress, rather than waiting on the president to step in and save everything.

a bit more real journalism would have helped too - i would have liked to know about the backroom deals that were cut with the pharma and health care and wahtever other industries a little earlier ;)

even now the debate and discussion on this website is of much higher quality (if contentious at times :) than the New York Times articles, for instance.


[ Parent ]
Well the NYT did give us (0.00 / 0)
this gem, so I wouldn't say they're all bad.

[ Parent ]
Does a partial success (4.00 / 3)
give momentum to forces seeking change, or does it cause them to be satisfied and go away?

In the short run, the answer depends on the elections in 2010.  Politicians, like everyone else in this world, are very much aware of their own self interest.  If the 2010 elections are a bloodbath the conclusion will be that seeking big change is not in their self interest, and further HCR changes will be difficult.

If the elections in 2010 are about normal for off year losses by incumbent parties, and Obama wins re-election the conclusion will be the big change is a political winner, and future changes will be regarded as a political opportunity.

Anyone who thinks they know the answer to the question above is smarter than I am.  I will say this: cost pressure in the system is going to continue to rise, and that means the problems not addressed by this Bill aren't going away either.  Given that fact, I find it difficult to believe that change is now lost for a generation.


Almost like you read my mind (4.00 / 1)
The same argument could have been made about Bush/Cheney with regard to the invasion of Iraq. The overt practice of pre-emptive war by the US was something of a "big change" and the GOPpers apparently paid for that change by losing their majority and the WH. (note the word "overt", please)

Now, the GOPpers are screaming about "repealing" the bill after the next election, but I remember Dems screaming about "ending" the concept of pre-emptive war, too.  

For all the screaming and complaining - both "big changes" are likely to outlive the political factions that instigated them.


"It sounds wrong...
     ...but its right."


[ Parent ]
Yes, I suppose the only answer is that they must be smarter (0.00 / 0)
Either that or not relying on belief, but instead using known behavior as evidence to define what we think politicians, who all will mostly still be there in the next decade, will do.

Relying on disaster to suggest reform will happen means that we should be expecting big chances with finance considering the near collapse of 2008. And yet, we are facing the same out come with finance reform that we just experienced with health care. Those are the two variables available to us. Yours is mostly hope.


[ Parent ]
I'm glad to see you bring this up (0.00 / 0)
because so few do.

That said, I'm not completely with you on the implications of victory and defeat.  If Democrats are successful in future elections, that may read as a validation of their approach rather than an encouragement to go further.  They may become content to rest on their laurels, with few minor changes, rather than continue pushing the way towards something better like Medicare for All.

I'm skeptical about "fix it later", because besides the oft-used examples of Medicare and Social Security I don't see much of it happening.  Case in point: Medicare Part D.  I'm not just talking about filling in the donut hole or allowing for government negotiations of drug prices (though that got killed off thanks to Obama), I mean actual overhauling Part D so it delivers the drug benefit directly through Medicare instead of through private insurance and pharmaceutical companies.  When is that gonna happen?

Also, the problems may not be going away, but if we institutionalize the private, for-profit insurance companies responsible for those problems, both politically and economically, as we have done through this bill, solving those problems may become much harder.


[ Parent ]
Feeling sad (0.00 / 0)
Well, as long as progressives feel sad that my rights were thrown under the bus, I feel better.  Perhaps it might help, though, if instead of feeling sad about the blow to women's rights, progressives actually felt enraged.

In case you're not up on this, here's some history:

Until 1979 most health care plans didn't cover normal pregnancy and childbirth expenses AT ALL.  And of course they didn't cove birth control or therapeutic abortion.  ALL reproductive health care expenses had to be borne by women out of pocket.  ALL of them.

Federal law in 1979 required that pregnancy and childbirth be covered:  Hooray!  A health care advance for women.  No coverage for contraception or abortion, but at least pre-natal care and labor costs were covered.

Not until the 1990s did plans begin to cover birth control and abortion, and that only after protracted agitation and only, in many cases, after Viagra entered the picture and it became too obviously discriminatory to cover Viagra and not birth control.

But yay!  In the 1990s, another health care advance for women.

Now here we are not even 15 years later and that advance is gone.

As one who agitated on this very issue for 30 years, to win small victories over a long period of time, can I say right now:  your sadness makes me want to puke?  

For what other group would you feel "sad" at seeing long-fought-for victories rolled back?    

Geez, maybe if we roll back women's suffrage, we could get universal health care.  






USER MENU


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you

Donate to Open Left

QUICK HITS
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

STATE BLOGS