After the best Netroots Nation conference yet, my wife and I hit the road out west, going to 4 national parks – Sequoia, King’s Canyon, Yosemite, and the John Muir woods – and ending the trip in San Francisco, my favorite city to visit. Spending time in the majesty of the trees, mountains, canyons, and valleys of Western America fills up your soul with goodness like nothing else I know of. But being with the good folks of Netroots Nation does pretty well at that too.
The progressive netroots is a fascinating movement. Having been around progressive politics for 30 plus years now gives one perspective, and the netroots movement has a lot of the same characteristics as some of the other social movements and constituencies I have seen, but is also very different in some ways. Whether you think of it as starting from MoveOn’s dramatic beginning in 1998, or from the time Jerome Armstrong and Markos began blogging around 2002, the netroots is still a very young movement, and they have a lot of the characteristics of young movements: the excitement of previously ignored people getting a taste of political power for the first time; the passion of people organizing for the first time; the creativity of people not constricted by old ways of thinking about politics; the impatience and anger at how messed up and slow to change things are; the aggressiveness of a movement seeing the potential of power but not yet part of the power structure.
A lot of times what happens in politics is that movements become strong enough to get a seat at the table, but once they have that seat, their leadership becomes satisfied, complacent, and stale. Once you have your seat, you don’t want to lose it by pushing too hard, and you start to accept the conventional wisdom of everyone else already seated there alongside you.
The question for the netroots is what happens now. A seat at the Democratic Party table is a good thing in many ways, and it is within range. This is a movement, though, that will die faster then most if it becomes stale, complacent, or captive to conventional wisdom. What makes this movement a movement is the early-adapter edge, the creativity, the ability to say what is not being said by the establishment. If that is lost, people will get bored and communities build on websites will erode.
On the other hand, without the knowledge of what works on the inside or the capacity to build longer term institutions, without the kinds of relationships with insiders that can turn activism into legislative accomplishments, all the good work being done by this movement will run into a brick wall and people will get frustrated and start drifting away. Striking the balance right is challenging for any young movement, especially one as diverse, bottom-up, and (small d) democratic as the netroots.
These kinds of challenges are inevitable and really healthy. And the signs are good. As a prime example, take the Netroots Nation event itself: in a bad economy, with so many progressives feeling down because of the frustrations of the last year, to have the conference keep growing and get the best attendance yet is pretty remarkable. And the spirits of the people there didn’t feel negative or beaten down to me – it was exciting and energizing to be around so many fired up people.
Right now, there are 3 elements of progressive politics that seem like they are growing and have real potential to change things, the netroots being one, with the other two being the immigration reform movement and the nascent but building anger around corporate domination of our political and economic system. All three of these things have potential but need to be built and nurtured into a long term strategy that can really change things. They also all have clear intersection points, and ways they can reinforce each other. We need to keep exploring ways to mold these elements, along with older parts of the progressive ecosphere, into a unified movement that is bound together rand helps each other fight every day.
On my vacation, I saw canyons and valleys and mountains that had been saved from defilement by the mining companies over a century ago. I saw trees thousands of years old, descended from redwoods that were on the earth 100 million years ago, in old-growth forests that had barely been saved from loggers (unlike thousands of other sequoias and redwoods that had been cut down before Teddy Roosevelt stepped in to save them). I was cursing the loggers and miners who wreaked such destruction, but was thankful every day for the work of people like John Muir and Gifford Pinchot and TR who had given my generation the gift of this beauty. It made me wonder what people a century from now will be saying about our generation. How much will they curse us for the environmental and economic destruction we will have given them? How much will they bless us for preserving some of the best things about our country?
Given the power of the economic forces wreaking the destruction (which are becoming even more powerful then the robber barons of a century ago), it will take a unified and strategic progressive movement to win us more blessings then curses.