China's latest powerplays - more unfair trade, now grave threats to our security

by: Leo Hindery

Tue Oct 12, 2010 at 15:00


The guest piece below from my friend Leo Hindery shows why he would be a great chair for the National Economic Council. He has been a consistently strong advocate for a trade and manufacturing policy that puts the interests of American workers ahead of those companies getting rich by outsourcing their factories to China. -Mike

After three decades of double-digit growth, China has just passed Japan to become the world's second-largest economy behind only the United States - and it should surpass us as early as 2030.  And when China wins in trade, as it now does every day, it's really only the U.S. which loses.  In fact, for the last several years the correlation has been almost dollar for dollar, with America's trade deficit with China in goods and services virtually mirroring China's overall trade surplus.

This should be enough of a clarion call to the administration to demand the integrated all-of-government approach to our trade relations with China that is the only one which is going to address the economic nightmare we find ourselves in with that country.  Yet the realities around our trade with China trade continue to worsen - and become a whole lot more foreboding.

Back in May 2009, in a speech I gave in Qatar, I predicted that as an extension of its ever-growing trading and geopolitical status, China would soon accelerate (and relatively soon complete) its deployment of a full-scale "blue water navy."  I felt that once China has this force in place and is able to readily project power throughout the Pacific and as far as the Indian Ocean, there will be, into the long term, regional and global tensions of a magnitude not seen since the Cold War.  I also felt there would soon be great pressure on Japan to re-militarize, given that a massive 86% of its oil & gas needs are met by Middle East suppliers by way of the Indian Ocean.

This past April 2010,  the New York Times also began to write about China's military's initiative that is now called "far sea defense", which China has publicly confirmed is fully intended to project naval power well beyond the Chinese coast.  China has been testing long-range ballistic missiles that could be used against our aircraft carriers, it intends to deploy their own aircraft carrier group 'within a few years', and its naval forces already stand at 275 "principal combatants" - i.e., major warships - and more than 60 submarines, including at least two Jin-class submarines with ballistic missile capabilities, with two more under construction, and two Shang-class nuclear-powered attack submarines.

So, what do you do if you suddenly have a 'blue water navy'?  Well, you use the bloody thing, which is exactly what China is already doing in the South China Sea, where it's just said it will tolerate no interference in what it now believes to be a "core interest" of its sovereignty, on par with Taiwan and Tibet.  And by making the South China Sea sovereignty issue 'non-negotiable', imminent problems now exist between China and each of Vietnam, the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Brunei.  

Leo Hindery :: China's latest powerplays - more unfair trade, now grave threats to our security


The most recent example of China's aggression - and of it linking its trade practices with its growing military might - is its blockage of exports of "rare earth" minerals to Japan in retaliation for Japan's detention of a Chinese fishing trawler captain operating in disputed waters of the South China Sea.  At the same time, to show it really means business, it even cancelled the China tour of SMAP, the Japanese boy-band.

You might ask what could possibly have more value than a touring Japanese boy-band, well it's those "rare earths", which are not only "rare" but vital to almost everything worldwide that is on the cutting edge of technology, from hybrid cars to wind turbines to Boeing's helicopter blades to the tiny magnets that direct the fins of the bombs being dropped every day in Afghanistan to Raytheon's missile targeting systems to General Dynamics' tank guns.

These 17 elements in the periodic table - these "rare earths" - are now among the most sought-after materials in modern manufacturing, and China currently supplies a staggering 97% of the world's demand for them.  This is because in 1986 Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping made 'mastering' them a priority.  And just six years later, Deng was able to say that, "The Middle East has oil, but China [now] has rare earths."  With this domination has come global trade friction, massive U.S. job losses and, now, threats to the national and economic security of America, Japan and any other nation which is dependent, as we each are, on access to rare earths for high-end manufacturing.

Every day, China uses a combination of export taxes and controls, which clearly violate WTO rules, and mid-'70s OPEC-like practices to price gouge rare earths in the extreme, to destroy all possible foreign competition in rare earths, and, most insidious, to 'persuade' foreign firms to move their related manufacturing to China before non-Chinese rare earth mines are on stream and its market domination diminishes.  Even though China actually holds in-country only 36% of global rare earth reserves, this highly manipulated 'triple play' gives China global supply domination approaching 100%.

When China imposed a ban on exports of rare earth metals to Japan, the world saw firsthand the complete failure of diplomacy-only strategies with China that don't include the threat of retaliation.  

We know that U.S. trade officials have been considering for months whether to challenge China's quotas on rare earth exports, just as they have been considering whether to meaningfully challenge China's myriad other trade abuses.  And all the while they have been considering - some might call it 'dithering' - China has continued to steal even more American manufacturing jobs, launch even more capital ships, and, lately, threaten one of our staunchest allies, Japan, and in the process our own national security.  As Paul Krugman recently inferred, the hype about the adverse consequences of a possible trade war with China in response is so unjustified as to be laughable, for as Krugman actually wrote, "there are worse things than trade conflict" - things like our ongoing jobless recovery and real U.S. unemployment rate of 20%!

**********

With China's trade and real guns pointed at our heads - and at the heads of a lot of other citizens of the world - what should the U.S. government do in response?

To start, we need a much fuller picture of China's commercial policies, business practices and rule of law, and their relationship to China's military aspirations.  We need to 'update' this picture on a real-time basis, with a lot better analysis than attaches to infrequent Congressional hearings held usually on only one issue.  To achieve this, the White House should establish, as a complement to the National Security Council's "China Directorate", an Office dedicated to understanding China's commercial activities at all levels.  This Office would specifically not make U.S.-China policy of any sort, rather it should be structured to fully understand China's manufacturing and industrial strategies and policies and then communicate its findings and analysis to the NSC's Directorate, State and Defense, and the relevant Committees of Congress.

At the same time, while the USG shouldn't discard single-issue WTO cases, it must better appreciate their often too-narrowly-tailored limitations and too-protracted timeframes.  (The only recent exception to this generalization is the brilliantly crafted pending 'clean energy' subsidies case brought by the United Steelworkers.)  Instead, the USG should mostly concentrate on the six broad issues that if aggressively pursued would bring great value back to the American-side of U.S.-China trade relations:

1. Mitigate the role of China's centralized approval authority which forces foreign companies to go to the authority for just about anything they do in China, including notably foreign imports into China.  In the process, mitigate China's deplorable record on transparency and its dramatic overuse of vague and draconian "State Secret" laws to restrict foreign competition.

2. Seek to balance the de minimus labor and environmental requirements that China places on "State Owned Enterprises", or SOEs, with the responsible ones placed on non-state owned enterprises operating outside China.

3. Go after all of China's illegal subsidies, not just its currency manipulation, while also putting a quick halt to China's persistent theft of America's hard-gained, valuable intellectual property or IP.  Many of China's practices provide its companies with obvious "counteravailable subsidies" and they need to be treated as such.

4. Bring what's called a Section 301 case at USTR against China's "Indigenous Innovation Production Accreditation Program.".  This Program limits all Chinese central and provincial government procurement to companies that have "indigenous" - or Chinese - "innovation", and embedded in it are China's two so-called 'trade advantages', namely, (i) regulations to block non-Chinese firms from selling their products to Chinese government agencies and (ii) rules that force Western companies to give up technological secrets in exchange for access to China's markets.  

5. Establish strong "Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States" (or CFIUS) type reviews of any planned investments by China in our nation's ports and transportation industry, natural resources, financial markets, "Advanced Technical Products" manufacturing, and items deemed by Defense to be "militarily critical".  In these instances, however, before a controlling or influencing investment is made, there should be a "national security impact statement" prepared jointly by Commerce and Defense for the Congress and the administration which considers the investment's defense, security and infrastructure implications.

The House just sent an unusually strong signal to China's leaders when it voted overwhelmingly, on September 29, to give the Obama administration expanded authority to impose tariffs on virtually all Chinese imports to the U.S. - more than $300 billion in goods this year alone - in retaliation for the country's refusal to revalue its currency.  The bill, H.R. 2378, passed 348 to 79 and included the support of 99 Republicans.  Treasury Secretary Geithner (finally!) added his own tough rhetoric in a speech last week at the Brookings Institute.  Now, it's time for the Senate to follow through when it returns in November and pass its own version (S. 3134).

Finally, as the rare earths contretemps has made abundantly clear, we must acknowledge with great urgency that China is growing more confident in leveraging its economic power through its growing military might, in order to advance its broad strategic interests and regional expansion objectives.  We must conclude that if we don't manage this situation aggressively, this shift will soon begin to seriously adversely impact our allies in the South China Sea region and of course our relationship with China itself.  We need to commit to our allies that with their asking, they will have the support of the U.S. to protect their national and economic security.  

It's past time for China to see, firsthand, that the U.S. is committed to permanently linking our trade policies with our nation's security interests, global defense responsibilities and foreign relations.  


Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
YEEEEEEEECCCCCCCCCCHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!! (2.40 / 5)
I had not realized before how dangerous and corrupt Hindery was. I guess we know now. And Lux promotes him? Is this really the sort of policies that Open Left promotes. My God. The danger isn't the Republicans. It is a lot closer than that.

You're fucking kidding right? (2.40 / 5)
You disagree with this analysis? You think the US should essentially unilaterally disarm against China? Why so greedy American capitalists can continue to have unfettered access to Chinese markets?

[ Parent ]
I am not kidding at all. (4.00 / 3)
Here is what I wrote yesterday on a quick hit "Why Democrats Should Not Join In Economic Scapegoating  (David Kaib)" when Reich reported the China-bashing and economic scapegoating and now the saber-rattling. I certainly think this is an attempt to divert attention from America's policies and problems. At my last count America was involved in about three or four good size wars right now with many screaming for war with Iran, I didn't realize that the Democrats and their insiders (Mike Lux) wanted another, now with China. Sure. Who's next? Is anybody left?

Of course, the China-bashing
is both morally and historically wrong. The low-to-no tariff trade relationship with China and India and elsewhere in
Asia and Latin America had in my mind two places of origin. The first and most important was the desire on the part of large corporations to try to exploit the low cost of labor in these countries and as Dameocrat also says the lack of costly environmental and safety regulations that are an essential concomitant of rapid economic development in underdeveloped and undeveloped countries undergoing massive industrialization. In a sense this development was going to occur whether or not American corporations joined in and benefitted or not, but obviously this development woulkd have been much much slower without the infusion of advanced capital and without the low-to-no tariff ability to sell goods and of course to accumulate the vast dollar reserves that China for example has. It is morally unjustifiable to bash the Chinese for a policy adopted deliberately by the American business/government elite. The idea was to benefit these corporations while exporting jobs and keep the population from becoming restive by importing cheaper affordable Chinese products. Of course the policy was shortsighted then and corrections can be made, but those who scapegoat our problems by pointing the finger at foreign powers should be pointing the finger at our domestic
rulers who benefited themselves with a very short sighted policy. Of course, the rulers gained support by promoting and institutionalizing (in media and elsewhere) the dime store philosophical arguments on market place efficiencies and free-market ideology...all convenient when it benefits their pockets.
by: VLaszlo @ Mon Oct 11, 2010 at 07:28
[ Reply ]  


[ Parent ]
Why not target the greedy capitalist instead of the chinese (4.00 / 3)
the greedy capitalist can still emply labor arbitrage in other emerging states like India, Mexico and Malaysia etc...!

[ Parent ]
Well it is an unholy alliance between greedy capitalists... (0.00 / 0)
...and totalitarian communists, you have to target both of them.

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR

[ Parent ]
Why not just apply principles of fair trade with all (0.00 / 0)
countries we trade with, so the corporatist can't  use labor arbitrage to game environmental and labor laws.  No need to start a new cold war.  Even if you do that it is silly to focus on just China.  Computer geeks like me are losing jobs to India.

[ Parent ]
I agree with your fair trade proposal... (0.00 / 0)
...but we definitely have to focus on Communist China.  The history of powerful violent totalitarian regimes is not a pretty history.

Regards,

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR


[ Parent ]
all workers would be empowered by fair trade. (0.00 / 0)
since under a fair trade policy china couldn't use slave labor and would have to pay workers better.  Ditto for India.

[ Parent ]
Who in the world said that we should "unilaterally disarm against China"? (4.00 / 2)
We have a right to control imports. It is our right, and it is not an act of war, just as the monetary policies of other countries are not acts of war. Our lack of will should not be turned into some kind of jingoistic alarmism. BTW, I troll-rated you because you abused the rating first.  

[ Parent ]
I absolutely agree with you (2.67 / 3)
The Chinese government is no more innocent or saintly than our own corporatists and flat earthers; and of course, they have their own agenda and ambitions.   China will emerge as a new economic and military power house, and we will have paid for every damned dime of it.  

Do I blame our government and the "corporatists"?  You bet.  But I am not stupid or naive enough to ignore the fact that the Chinese government is manipulative, power hungry, and quite capable of horrific human rights abuses.  

Don't blame the Chinese my foot.  US autos and other companies have been complaining for years about China imposing tariffs, banning some imports, and manipulating their currency.  

I think this analysis is right on.  If we can't feed, clothe,  or arm ourselves, we have no national security. Being dependent on China is as stupid as being dependent on the middle east.  



[ Parent ]
Each one of your points... (0.00 / 0)
...is exactly right.  There are two parties here that we have to be fearful of, and that is the multi-national corporations and a violent totalitarian Chinese regime.

Excellent post!!

Regards,

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR


[ Parent ]
Wow. This is pretty crazy. (4.00 / 2)
Totally out of place on these pages. A few things: China's ability to project sea power is nowhere near ours, not even close. The idea that the world's most populous nation would have one carrier group (most of the major European countries have them) is called a "grave threat"? Projecting power in the South China Sea is in no way comparable to projecting power all around the globe, as we do.

What is most alarming about this post is the idea that withholding exports is somehow an aggressive move. The idea that powers have a right to resources is what led to the two world wars. The right to unfettered access is at the heart of imperialist ideology.

What are the editors doing by posting the POS?


The US military power is way over blown (4.00 / 1)
We are struggling in wars in Iraq and Afghanistan - not to mention, Pakistan, Sudan and Somalia - facing enemies that don't even have 1 naval vessel, let alone an airforce, or any heavy amour.

I sincerely doubt the US is ready to take on China. Why would they lend us money to attack them?

"It sounds wrong...
     ...but its right."


[ Parent ]
Limits of military power (4.00 / 1)
You are confusing the strength of military power with the limits of military power.

We have absolutely no problem going in and destroying some country.  We can blow things up without reservations against basically anyone, including China and all our allies.

What we cannot do is go into a country and occupy it in a way that transforms the country as we like.  But that is a completely different situation than saying our military power is over blown.


[ Parent ]
To bad the world doesn't pertain to rhetoric (0.00 / 0)
No matter what words you use to describe it, the US military is a program that has shown little to no return on the investment.

How many trillions of dollars have we sunk into that organization since the end of WW2? What do we have to show for it? A fragile giant that never quite seems to have been designed for the mission in which it finds itself.

Like a wealthy uncle that's always hitting you up for cash.


"It sounds wrong...
     ...but its right."


[ Parent ]
now this is true china bashin! (4.00 / 3)
yee gods!  Our trade deficit with China is happening because of American labor arbitrage, on the part of the corporate America, not because the Chinese are evil!  The corporatists aren't just doing labor arbitrage with China.  They are also using labor arbitrage, with India, Mexico and Viet Nam.

Is Mike trying the play the militarist against the corporatists in a backdoor way?

What gives?


Wow. This is some seriously alarmist hyperbole. (3.43 / 7)
China is stealing American jobs?! Wha?

I guess American corporations and the American Ruling Elites have nothing to do with this? (getting dizzy just thinking about this bit of nonsense)

As for their military, yes, they are making a lot of progress in their desire to transform their military to a more modern and competent state, but Leo's alarmist tone on this point is way overplayed. For instance, China's published defense budget for 2010 is a whopping $78 Billion. Right? That's a mere 10% of our outlays, if we're reasonably conservative with the supplementals. They might have two carrier groups by 2020. As for subs, they have a few now, but it's estimated they would need upwards of 60 to present a genuine threat to navies in that region--including ours.

As for missiles, I'd just like to point out we still possess enough ICBMs to incinerate the northern hemisphere several times over. I think we possess more than adequate deterrent capability in that regard, yes?

Bottom line is China only currently represents a genuine threat if we invade them. A decade or more from now, they'll be able to assert themselves within their own sphere of influence much more broadly. So enough of this Neo-Liberal fear mongering on this point, okay?

Lastly, I just love this notion that somehow, the very same USA that cannibalized it's own economy to suit the needs of its corporations that are now the PLA's BFFs is now in some kind of a position to demand radical changes in China's domestic policy realms. But yes, I suppose a can person can dream.....

One needn't point out, or shouldn't have to, that the US acts in servile devotion to those very same corporations that just loves them some Chinese authoritarianism.

If the US hadn't become such a corrupt corporatist state in the first place, we might stand a chance here. Instead, our Ruling "Elites" sold the horses and torched the barn... for their own enrichment. Now we've nothing left except 15 million unemployed and millions more having their homes stolen from them by corrupt banks the Obama Administration doesn't want to deal with, lest they lose all that lovely cash from them.

So we're stuck in a bad situation vis a vis China. I don't think it's hopeless,  since they're also invested in the US market and "own" a lot of our debt that would cripple them if it somehow became worthless. So there is potential for diplomacy here. Not that the US is any good at it anymore....

Lastly, while it's still possible we might see a trade war (which would prove costly to China, to say the least), the biggest losers will be the multinationals that own the White House lock, stock and barrel.

Guess who's going to win that argument? Because I seriously doubt our vaunted leaders want to see their investment portfolios take that kind of hit.

Bottom line: We can't deal with China effectively until we get our own house in order. No amount of alarmist, pseudo-populist fear mongering is going to change that.


There are two types of people in the world: Those who say there are two types of people and those who don't.


This is Mike's description: (4.00 / 2)
[Hindery] has been a consistently strong advocate for a trade and manufacturing policy that puts the interests of American workers ahead of those companies getting rich by outsourcing their factories to China.

I'm sure that most here would agree with these goals. But the column we get is something that argues for increased militarism, as if the US DOESN'T ALREADY combine its global military and economic policies. Absolutely crazy.  


I don't think Hindery is arguing for more militarism, actually. (4.00 / 1)
All of his policy prescriptions, some of which seem quite reasonable, are all about trade, investment and economics. I'm not seeing any desire for even more defense spending, much less arguing for military confrontation. That's the Neo-Con's job, it seems.

But all the military hyperbole is just that and it only seems to be in the post to push people's buttons. As such, it's just propaganda. If he had left that stuff out, the post would have gotten a better reaction, methinks.

Oh, and leave out the part about China stealing American jobs too. That's just pathetic.

But this is what bothers me: If Hindery has to resort to these kinds of rhetorical tactics and ignore how the US has--all of it's own accord-- throttled it's own economy and thus security just to suit corporate interests that run counter to the US National Interest, then ignoring that makes any so-called "analysis" of this situation inherently worthless.

Carping about China is braying after the horse has left the barn.

There are two types of people in the world: Those who say there are two types of people and those who don't.


[ Parent ]
i do fear hindery is enabling the militarists (4.00 / 3)
because of progressive weakness.  We kind of did this during the iraq war, when many of us supported the rothbard/von misis libertarians as a way of fighting the neocon. Remember antiwar.com.  It was run by a right wing libertarian. We ended up empowering Ron and Rand Paul and the libertarian wing of the tea party.  Progressives need to stop looking for quick and dirty shortcuts.  The third way was probably a quick and dirty short cut too.  Many of us are just too short term in our thinking to build progressive power bases.

[ Parent ]
It's very hard for me to disagree with you. (4.00 / 1)
I personally don't see this as "enabling the militarists," though I can understand why you would say that. But it's only a degree or two away from my own point about fear mongering. If this post were directed at the militarists, that would be one thing. But in this case it's directed at Progressives, which in a way bothers me even more.

I don't actually see anything Progressive about Hindery's post. I see Great Power politics, stated in a way that neglects the failures of our state to take care of it's own interests until it's really quite late. I also hear Schumer in this... which leads me to believe Hindery's post is nothing more than Economic Nationalism.

Good points about short cuts.

There are two types of people in the world: Those who say there are two types of people and those who don't.


[ Parent ]
Oh come on. The language pervading this post is all too familiar, and the post (4.00 / 3)
ends with " We need to commit to our allies that with their asking, they will have the support of the U.S. to protect their national and economic security.  

It's past time for China to see, firsthand, that the U.S. is committed to permanently linking our trade policies with our nation's security interests, global defense responsibilities and foreign relations," after arguing for "managing the situation more aggressively."

I agree with your points, however. The post is really an insult, as if we can't see our conundrum without externalizing all its causes in the form of an aggressive enemy. Weimar Germany had legitimate economic gripes, too.  


[ Parent ]
Okay, we surely agree on the Insult. (4.00 / 2)
In the distinction I was trying to make, I simply noted that his prescriptions were all in the realm of trade/econ policy. If he had stated military prescriptions as well, I would be in complete agreement with you. That said, it's a small knigget.

Yeah, it is insulting to our intelligence to read these kind of scare tactics used in a forum like this. His appraisal of China's military capabilities is wildly out of line with the facts.

He sounds like a Neo-Liberal trying to sound like an Economic Nationalist, which is distinctly Pseudo-Populist. But that's enough labeling for one comment.

There are two types of people in the world: Those who say there are two types of people and those who don't.


[ Parent ]
Just a few points for people here who find the Chinese the enemy. (4.00 / 2)
dkmich says: "China will emerge as a new economic and military power house, and we will have paid for every damned dime of it."
In my opinion, it already has. That horse has left the barn a long time ago. China has real economic power both in terms of its control over huge amounts of Western currency, its buying spree in the west and in underdeveloped nations, and in its own burgeoning and growing industrial power. In military power, China is second to none. That is none as in the rest of the world. Its military is technologically extremely advanced it has a huge pool of educated, technologically capable manpower to draw and fill its military machine which numerically far outweighs say our own. I have visited China several times in the last decade...most recently for 3 weeks this summer. It no longer has the feel of a third world country; I was in Western China and it had the feel and look of a modern country.

dkmich further says:  "US autos and other companies have been complaining for years about China imposing tariffs, banning some imports, and manipulating their currency.   "
US and other companies want it both ways. Most of GM and Ford profits now are deriving from their sales to the Chinese public which is starved for cars. The cars they sell are very often built in China with cheaper labor than here and the auto companies are enjoying an admittedly short term bonanza. That is exactly whose fault? The Chinese fix their currency and peg it to the dollar. In fat times for American economy this was fine with corporations exporting our jobs, manufacturing with cheap labor and keeping social peace at home with cheap imports. Who benefitted? The Chinese industrialized, Chinese labor made some advances, and American corporations and finance were raking in big bucks. Now times are lean and fingers are pointing at the Chinese low rate of the renmini. With their vast dollar holdings, strengthening the dollar significantly at the expense of the dollar will weaken a lot of our financial industry. The problems that were transmuted by exporting jobs will return in a different form for this country.

dkmich, BobbyK, Leo Hindery and the war faction of the Democratic Party are seeking a National Socialist (sorry I know the reference. You are not Nazis. I categorically state I am not accusing you of being Nazis or Nazi sympathizers. i know how odious any comparison is. But this IS the National Socialist solution). Build up a military machine that is already bankrupting our country even more.

i teach at a big University. For years I have complained about the large number of Chinese, Indian and other students populating our programs, particularly graduate studies. Not because they are bad students. They are great, very serious, very motivated. But because their governments were making a national priority out of building up an advanced group of very educated technologically capable, actually technologically expert students in advanced technical and scientific studies. i complained because the Chinese government was supporting necessary state-of-the-art studies and research. Whose fault? The Chinese of course. Solution? Build up our military. of course.

Finally let me venture out in dangerous waters. Tom Friedman, the moron of the NYTimes, yes billionaire mustache-boy-wonder wrote a column that I had some agreement with in which he described some serious initiatives (infrastructure, electric cars, genomic science) that were being taken by the Chinese.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09...
Very little of the stimulus of our President went to our needed investment in similar projects. The fault? The Chinese, of course. The solution? Build up the Navy. Of course.


Excellent article by Leo Hendry... (0.00 / 0)
...these are exactly the actions that need to be taken.  The future is ominous, the Chinese are becoming the premier economic superpower in the world.  When they combine that with being the premier military superpower in the world, we will be in uncharted territory, there never having been a violent totalitarian superpower with this type of power.  The Soviets had military power, but were relatively weak economically, the Nazi's never had a population base or the modern weapons that we have today to threaten the world in the long run, though their destruction and atrocities were horrific.  Though the Chinese are communist totalitarians, with some exceptions their rise to power reminds me more of the Nazi's than it does the Soviets.  Why we ever allowed our corporations to build up a totalitarian regime like this I will never understand.

Regards,


Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR


Actually to add to that ... (0.00 / 0)
...I misspoke by calling them "our" corporations, they are really multi-national corporations that hold no allegiance to any country, their allegiance is to profit and to the enrichment of their senior management.  Their assistance to a totalitarian regime to enrich themselves should not be any surprise.  Now we are in a situation that really has no easy answers.

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR

[ Parent ]
FLGibsonJr believes: (4.00 / 1)
Fear mongering = "excellent article"

[ Parent ]
I do not think he is fear mongering... (0.00 / 0)
...any powerful violent totalitarian regime should bring concern to those who want long term peace.  Weakness will not necessarily keep the peace, in fact it is often the opposite.

Regards,

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR


[ Parent ]
Were not weak (4.00 / 1)
we just don't think we should have to go to war to stop a labor arbitrage problem with totalitarian capitalist china.

[ Parent ]
. (0.00 / 1)
The best way to argue is to compare what you are arguing against to Nazi's. Thanks to the internet, this revolutionary way of thinking has come to dominate all facets of political discourse.

[ Parent ]
Well the Soviets, the Nazi's and perhaps the Japanese... (0.00 / 0)
...were really the only other powerful and violent totalitarian regimes in the modern era, so it is natural to compare Communist China to other like regimes.

Regards,

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR


[ Parent ]
Mike Lux's friend Leo Hindery (4.00 / 5)
Mike seems blind to this, so I'll spell it out for him. This article is a pitch-perfect example of why and how Walter Lippman-style liberals, whose permanent paranoia over the peril we narrowly escaped in 1939-1945, have threatened us all ever since. Their determination never to be caught napping again has managed to turn them into monstrous would-be masters of Realpolitik, concerned only with the geopolitical games they are playing, and unconcerned about the rest of us, except for our value as pawns.

Leo Hindery isn't a neocon. He's smarter, and far subtler in his seductions, but he's a cold fish nevertheless, and he absolutely, positively doesn't give a rat's ass about peace, democracy, or the fate of our grandchildren. To see his poisonous call for what he's probably pleased to think of as patriotism published here is truly depressing. He may be your friend Mike, but he's no friend of mine, nor of anyone concerned with the welfare of anyone who doesn't share his obsessions.


In Search of Enemies (4.00 / 4)
Great example of how this poison seeps down the power food chain in FLGibson's comment above:

The future is ominous, the Chinese are becoming the premier economic superpower in the world...Though the Chinese are communist totalitarians, with some exceptions their rise to power reminds me more of the Nazi's than it does the Soviets.


[ Parent ]
It is exactly that... as you and William Timberman (4.00 / 4)
say it so well. This is such a seductive and poisonous and dangerous ideology that if it took hold in the higher reaches of the Democratic party I believe I would use the calculus of lesser evil and go over to our American enemies and actively support the other Barbarians.
Hindery says what use is the buildup of the Chinese navy if not to use it? Can you read this sentence and not have the irony knock you to the ground? I guess we should know...we have per capita the greatest spending on military in human history with a great (although by now exhausted) military...and we have used it much more indiscriminately than most in the last 75 years, and certainly by far, by very far, more than anyone in the last 25 years, building the empire and enforcing American hegemony. That is why the neocons called their enterprise Project for a New American Century...the explicit goal spelled out in their documents is the continued hegemonic domination by America. FLGibsonJr may believe we have two equal enemies: corporations and the emerging Chinese power, but anyone with any sense of historic context will know that the military road will not bring the results they want, military conflict with the Chinese will not be confined to Asia, and workers will surely NOT benefit from that road.

[ Parent ]
As Pogo might have said, 1984 falls in 2010 this year. (4.00 / 4)
I was born in 1943, so this is literally where I came in. I've heard Leo's little ditty before:

East Asia is licking its chops. Oceania had better pull up its socks.

There's a long answer to the Leos of our bedraggled imperium, but long answers don't get past the guard at the door -- ask Noam Chomsky. All I still have the energy to say is beware the prophet who counts aircraft carriers.


[ Parent ]
Or, its deja vu all over again (4.00 / 3)
The Democratic party has had for as long as I can remember its quick-to-war faction. Scoop Jackson, LBJ, Hubert Humphrey,Zell Miller, Joe Lieberman. In the past, this was mostly focussed on anti-Communism together with a big dollop of domestic worker benefits and security nets. That was the political base  those guys cobbled together and they gave us Vietnam (with 50,000 Americaqn dead, decisive defeat,  and the end to LBJ's Great Society) and more recently (same people, new enemy) the wars in Iraq and now Afghanistan. If we listen to the arguments above of Hindery and those for whom his message resonates we hear the old arguments without even a fresh coat of paint. You could dust off any of the old cold war speeches or bring out some of Liebeerman's more recent ones and Hindery would hardly need to rewrite the text.

[ Parent ]
Actually historically you could say your reasoning... (0.00 / 0)
...is very similar to those ideas that many people believe led to World War II.  Read Kennedy's Why England Slept, or Churchill's While England Slept.  No one wants war, but being weak against violent totalitarian regimes has not worked out very well in the past.

Regards,

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR


[ Parent ]
iraq war 2 (0.00 / 0)
the world war 2 shit is a cliche, and the solution will never work in a nuclear era.

[ Parent ]
Any powerful violent totalitarian regime... (0.00 / 0)
...should bring concern to those who want long term peace.  Weakness will not necessarily keep the peace, in fact it is often the opposite.

Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me-and I welcome their hatred. - FDR

[ Parent ]
We don't need another war. (0.00 / 0)
period.

[ Parent ]




USER MENU


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you

Donate to Open Left

QUICK HITS
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

STATE BLOGS