Hayden & Goss bluntly defend torture, indefinite detention

by: Daniel De Groot

Sat Nov 20, 2010 at 13:37


The Toronto Star sent a reporter to a "Spy Cruise" gathering of intelligence community types, which included former CIA Director Porter Goss and former NSA Director Michael Hayden, and landed some revealing quotes:


About 30 minutes into an interview on an outdoor deck aboard the "spy cruise," the issue of Osama bin Laden arises.

"What can you do with him?" asks Porter Goss, the former head of the CIA, as he settles back in a padded lounge chair.

"Are we going to sit him on a deckchair and ask him to cooperate? Or are we going to put him in a place where he can't leave?"

Goss's point is this: Now that the Obama administration has outlawed harsh interrogation techniques such as waterboarding, shut the CIA covert "black sites" around the world and frowned upon renditions, what are the options open to America's intelligence service?

He insists the CIA "enhanced" methods worked.

"There are undeniable, provable, extraordinary successes," Goss said when asked about waterboarding - an interrogation technique that U.S. President Barack Obama denounced as torture.

The whole article is worth reading (it's not lengthy) as a revealing look at the incredible obstinancy of the anything-for-national-defence crowd as represented by the two keynote speakers to this floating conference.  As much as I agree with the main thrust of Glenn Greenwald's criticism of the Obama administration on these issues, it might amaze anyone who hasn't watched the way the right operates to see how completely unmoved they are toward the many ways in which Obama has compromised core civil liberties and US treaty obligations.  If Obama listened to the left, Goss and Hayden would likely be in jail, rather than carping about him from the deck of a luxury cruise ship.

On a political tactical level, this highlights the futility of trying to placate these extremists since they can't be assauged by anything short of utter capitulation and meanwhile it just puts off Obama's own natural allies and base.  That said, obviously these decisions shouldn't be made on the basis of political tactics, but it's worth noting that if that was the real rationale (since the Obama admin's given rationale on so many of their compromises on this front don't make much sense in policy terms), it's not working.

It also bolsters the need for stronger political oversight of these organizations as Hayden hides behind an astonishingly narrow technocratic view of his role, acting as he or other intelligence officials who participated in the widescale violation of US and international law bear no responsibility for the harm to the US from those actions.  But then this is Hayden's perspective:


Hayden said he is tired of the criticism and doesn't believe the CIA's use of waterboarding or covert interrogation sites affected the U.S.'s reputation or fuelled Al Qaeda's propaganda.

Yeah, a real hard nosed "realist" there.

Daniel De Groot :: Hayden & Goss bluntly defend torture, indefinite detention

Tags: , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
If Nothing Else (4.00 / 4)
A trial would have meant that all their lies would have been officially refuted.

And that alone would have been a remarkably freeing achievement.

"You know what they say -- those of us who fail history... doomed to repeat it in summer school." -- Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


Efficacy does not equal legality (4.00 / 2)
Torture does not work. Torture does not work. Torture does not work. Goss and the others are just flat wrong.

But even if it did work torture is illegal under international law, domestic law, and the UCMJ.

Neither the belief torture works nor the possibility of torture actually working to produce information (again, it doesn't) is germane to the question of legality.

If Goss and others think torturing does work and works well enough to save us from grave danger, then begin the process of withdrawal from international treaties and changing domestic law.

Even then it would remain illegal because the view torture is wrong and should be illegal has become customary international law (no treaties or domestic law needed) but that is another issue.

Did they get you to trade your heroes for ghosts? Hot ashes for trees? Hot air for a cool breeze? And cold comfort for change?


Torture does work, but not in the way that's purported. (4.00 / 4)
You're right in terms of using a method of extracting actionable intel. It doesn't work and human beings have collectively known this for literally at least a couple centuries. George Washington knew that, in fact.

So why do certain elements still insist on it? Why are there states in existence we actually refer as "torture states"? Because it does work, but not as advertised to the public.

Augusto Pinochet didn't torture people his secret police knew to be innocent because "it works" in the manner that's described by fascists like Hayden. They tortured people as a means of terrorizing the populace. They extracted phony confessions for propaganda purposes. They extracted denouncements of perfectly innocent people for propaganda purposes.

In this sense, torture works extremely well.... for a time.

When DOD decided to "Salvadorize" Iraq, that was their intent, not gaining intel. That was obviously simply because they bothered to use that term. The torture state in El Salvador gained no intel and their American advisors had, even at that time, literally decades of knowledge to support the assumption that it was no good for anything other than terrorizing civilians. The US military has been teaching torture at the school formerly known as "School of Americas," not because it has use as an intelligence method. They teach state terror at that school.

In 1985 I wrote a paper in which I asked the question, "When will these practices come home to us?"

It would seem there are some in official circles who seem intent on doing just that, as has been apparent since 2000. Nothing has changed in this regard since then. Nothing.

You see, torture does work. Just not in the way it's being sold to the public. But it does work and that's what this argument is really about. It's about State Terror, not intel. It's always been about that.


"Find out just what people will submit to, and you have found out the exact amount of injustice and wrong which will be imposed upon them; .... The limits of tyrants are prescribed by the endurance of those whom they oppress. " -- Frederick Douglass


[ Parent ]
Absolutely (4.00 / 2)
Torture works for some purposes but not for the purpose of extracting useful information to protect Americans and others against threats. Which is the claim made by those cited in the diary.

Whether it works or not for any particular purpose it is illegal (and obviously immoral). Not that legality or morality will stop anyone prepared to actually consider torturing another human being. The people who do it and even more the people who develop the overarching policies to promote it are clinical sociopaths, no two ways about it. Dick Cheney is Ted Bundy controlling the world's largest military.

It is important I think despite the truth of what you say to dispute the intel angle because that is the myth that is being used to slowly mainstream the acceptance of torture. I absolutely agree with you that those who carry out torture or at least order it know that it is ineffective for they invoke and that some of the unstated purposes relate to the types of things you highlight.

Did they get you to trade your heroes for ghosts? Hot ashes for trees? Hot air for a cool breeze? And cold comfort for change?


[ Parent ]
Agreed. All the more reason to destroy that meme and tell the truth about torture. (4.00 / 1)
Recent experience shows quite well that people can argue about "whether it works or not." That discussion can go on ad infinitum.

It's time to pivot and talk about what it's really for.

"Find out just what people will submit to, and you have found out the exact amount of injustice and wrong which will be imposed upon them; .... The limits of tyrants are prescribed by the endurance of those whom they oppress. " -- Frederick Douglass


[ Parent ]
Sick SOBs, aren't they. (n/t) (4.00 / 1)


You just don't understand (0.00 / 0)
But, but
he's tired of the criticism
.  

Idiots rationalize America violating the Geneva Convention (4.00 / 1)
Hang your head lady liberty. Every crime ever committed has been rationalized in the mind of the perpetrator. Torture is a moral violation of human rights. Torture their prisoners and you doom your military who are captured to torture. It's pretty easy nowadays to use fear to corral folks into agreeing with your point of view. I wonder how pro-torture advocates would explain their point of view to military personnell who are captured or to their families. These are not proud americans. They have become what our forefounders despised - advocates of running rough shod over the rights of our brothers and sisters. Hang your head America.





USER MENU


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you

Donate to Open Left

QUICK HITS
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

STATE BLOGS