The Exorcism of Voo-Doo Economics

by: Paul Rosenberg

Sun Mar 01, 2009 at 18:55



In the diary, "Credit Where It's Due: Chris Matthews File", Mark Matson commented:

Even those in the White House have admitted the stimulus bill probably isn't enough to do the job.  But this was just a single bill.  More work will be done in most every bill passed by congress this year.

And yes, I really do mean most every bill.  Remember those efficiency numbers everyone posted last month?  Tax cuts for the rich do almost nothing but more money for the poor and middle class do a lot.  Even if you are revenue neutral, every policy choice that directs money away from the richer and towards the poorer people helps the economy.  The health care money put aside in Obama's budget, for instance, will be a big stimulus itself.

Although I'm not quite so sanguine as Mark (state budget cuts are going to be a bitch to offset), this is a very important point.  In rightwing mythos land, every tax cut is always good for the economy--the product of not really thinking through all the effects it will have, including the opportunity costs of not putting that money to potentially much better uses.  But in reality, money that goes to poor people does a helluva lot more good.

That's only the first step, however, as can be seen in this blog post Paul Krugman wrote back in mid-January:

Paul Rosenberg :: The Exorcism of Voo-Doo Economics
Bang for the buck (wonkish)

Mark Thoma says he was thinking about thinking about this; I was actually thinking about it. Anyway, it's true: the cost of an effective fiscal stimulus, in terms of adding to the government's debt, can (and should) be much less than the headline cost.

Okay, I'm cutting out the wonkish heart, and rephrasing it: Textbook economics says--in a simplified model--that stimulus spending has a given multiplier, given certain assumptions.  Say it comes out to 1.5--that is, $100 billion in spnding raises GDP by $150 billion.

Kruigman continues:

But if $100 billion in spending raises GDP by $150 billion, and the marginal tax rate is 1/3, $50 billion of the spending comes back in additional revenue. So bang for the buck - increase in GDP per dollar of added debt - is 3, not 1.5.

That's double the multiplier.  That's huge!.

As Krugman notes:

Since the main concern about stimulus is that it will add to government debt, it's this bang for the buck measure, rather than the multiplier, that's relevant. And 3 sounds a lot better than 1.5.

And yet, that number never got into the public discourse!

Krugman continues:

Take this a bit further: $150 billion is about 1 percent of GDP, which Romer and Bernstein say means a million jobs; so this says $50,000 per job, which is a much better number than the critics have been throwing around (plus many more workers with full-time rather than part-time jobs).

Again, where was this in the public discourse?  MIA.

Finally, Krugman noted, in another wonkified part, that "Bang for the buck also heightens the contrast between effective and ineffective stimulus policies."  A tax cut with a 0.75 multiplier (1/2 the multiplier for spending) only gives a bang-for-the-buck of 1, which 1/3 of the bang-for-the-buck of spending.

Clearly, these two arguments--Mark's above, and Krguman's just now--can be combined:  every shift of government spending that puts more money in poor people's pockets will also bring more money back in as taxes.  It will have a higher multiplier, and in addition a higher bang-for-the buck.

This is the exact opposite of what supply-side/trickle-down/voo-doo economics tells us.  And it will only become more and more important over time for all of us to understand it.

Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
like you said 'that's huge!' (4.00 / 4)
good job to both mark and paul for highlighting this

c and t (4.00 / 2)
The math you skipped in Krugman's article:

hen textbook analysis says that if the stimulus is dG, the increase in GDP is 1/(1 - c(1-t)) where c is the marginal propensity to consume out of income and t is the marginal tax rate. Suppose c is 0.5 and t is 1/3; then the multiplier is 1.5, which is more or less the conventional wisdom right now.

Take this one step further.  The variables t and c are not constants, but functions t(i) and c(i) where i is the income of the individual.  With progressive taxation, high c correlates with low t, because the poorest are both more likely to spend their cash and don't pay income tax.  Unfortunately, we don't actually have particularly progressive taxation once you include payroll taxes, sales tax and so on, but this provides yet another reason why we should.

Do economists know how to solve min/max problems?  If not, someone should teach them calculus.


Precisely (4.00 / 1)
I want to get into this more thoroughly, in a way that gets across to the math phobic.  The deeper you get into it, the clearer it becomes that the progressive position economically is the best from a purely "what's best for the whole economy" perspective.

This should have been obvious to everyone, given how American prosperity went up after the New Deal, as the top 1%'s share of the wealth went down: the more money circulates among the peons, as opposed to sitting in the king's cellar, the better off the country as a whole is.

"Senate passes expanded GI bill despite Bush, McCain opposition"


[ Parent ]
Pharaoh's high priest (0.00 / 0)
I think it was some Pharaoh's high priest who first figured this out and managed to con the Pharaoh to do the right thing in two simple steps.  

Huge public work projects.  (New evidence shows pyramid builders where the middle class of their day.)  

Extremely large death tax.  (Bury large sums of wealth, which quickly gets stolen and redistributed throughout the economy.)

Brilliant!  The result was one of the longest lasting civilizations in history.

(Ok, the topic is only vaguely related -- in a way that really isn't -- to Egypt moving from monotheism to polytheism, but hey, it was an excuse.)


[ Parent ]
good read (0.00 / 0)
really good articles on this site recently related to these subjects.  keep up the good work.  

Also I like the latest analysis on the different types of progressivism.  It was pretty informative.  Glad the back and forth on this has toned down and we are actually debating this in a reasonable way.


pedant on: (4.00 / 1)
tax cuts for the middle class and poor don't really stimulate the economy, beyond putting money in the pockets of corporations and credit providers who have pricing power. don't think they aren't paying attention when tax cuts are passed; prices rise accordingly and that money helps only the already rich and powerful. real stimulus comes in the form of things like health care, UI benefits, and for projects that expand the long term economy.

end pedant

otherwise, yes. it's good to see this discussion finally reaching Village ears.


An Interesting Point (0.00 / 0)
I'm sure there's some truth to this, though it's hard to say how much, given that there's already so much (though still not that well measured) tendency for people to squander their tax cuts on paying off existing debts and other boring stuff.

Do you happen to know about any empirical studies on this?

"Senate passes expanded GI bill despite Bush, McCain opposition"


[ Parent ]
Donate to Open Left
PREMIUM AD

ADVERTISEMENTS


MENU

OpenLeft in your inbox!

 

Or, subscribe to each author individually.

QUICK HITS