Health Insurance Mandates

by: Mark Wallace

Tue Feb 19, 2008 at 12:18


Obama's position on health insurance mandates has been a concern of mine ever since the first of the debates where the issue came up. Clinton caught on to this weakness early, and more or less adopted Edward's plan in order to position herself better against Obama. Since then, she has very effectively used the simple argument of "universal coverage" to distinguish her position from Obama's.
Mark Wallace :: Health Insurance Mandates
Obama's argument, while very simple, has been consistent: "Americans aren't covered because they can't afford it..." He glosses over some important policy issues: that affordability may be linked to universality, and so on, but his argument is very catchy. Obama has attacked health insurance mandates in Clinton's plan with ads and unsavory surrogates.

Obama's side of this argument has bothered me a great deal, but, honestly, it bothers me more because of the way he makes the argument than because of the substance. On one point, Obama is undoubtedly correct: most Americans do not want the government to mandate that they purchase health insurance.

On the other hand, most Americans probably would like to have free health insurance. This includes me: I want to have something at least as good as what the Canadians have. I've also heard that many fortune 500 CEO's would also like to see the government provide universal health insurance. This seems reasonable to me, and I like the idea of providing government subsidized health care to make the cost of labor in the US more competitive with our trading partners. A subsidy of this type is accepted as "fair" around the world, and we only hurt our own workforce by not providing it.

So, back to mandates: I am warming up to Obama's point of view (although not necessarily his "Harry and Louise" messages) on mandates. Mandates may be counter-productive, for the following reasons:

My major concern is that a mandate would put in place, long term, what is effectively a regressive tax, similar to social security. If everyone must buy something that costs the same for all people, and only the "poor" get subsidies, then we have effectively mandated a "tax" that is capped at say, a few thousand dollars a year, for everyone. The tax becomes especially bad for heads of household with dependents, since the cost is "per head." It would be a very regressive addition to the current tax code.

Our other example of a regressive tax, social security, has been shown to be especially durable. For low wage workers (which included me for my first few jobs) social security is the major component of withholding. A health care mandate would increase the financial burden on the same set of workers, who often are young people who don't need much medical care. The injustice of the mandate, and the fact that young people and young families are paying to subsidize older people with more disposable income, will not be lost on young wage earners.

Paying income tax never bothered me, but I have always felt screwed by social security withholding. Republicans tap into this: they have used resentment of social security withholding, and have cultivated a fear among younger people that they will not get any benefit in the long term. A health care mandate would give Republicans an even fatter target. Like social security, both parties would ensure that it stays around year after year, but the Republicans would attack it relentlessly. I think their attacks could be successful in converting many, because low wage workers (most young people) hate regressive taxes.

Although I am a pragmatist, and think regulated capitalism is an effective system for optimizing the economy, I also believe in the principle: "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need." We can reconcile this with capitalism by assuming that the majority of consumption in a wealthy society is really for optional, luxury items, that no one really needs. As long as everyone's needs are met for food, health care, housing, education, and so on, we can afford to distribute luxuries like big screen TVs as rewards to the people that play the capitalism game the best. I don't like the game much myself, but I acknowledge its effectiveness.

Social security does not follow the principle of redistributing wealth according to need, so I do not like it as it is. On the other hand, if we  removed the cap on withholding, then it would be more fair. Adding health care mandates, IMO, only compounds the problem of a regressive tax code that redistributes wealth from the young to the old. This is the opposite of what America needs now: we should be redistributing wealth from older high-income earners to young people through things like subsidized college education, Medicare-like coverage for all children, better childhood nutrition, a larger deduction for dependents, and so on. Instead, the post-Reagan era has brought us larger TVs and cars for 40 and 50 somethings, which is, to my mind, both immoral and a poor way to run an economy. The government subsidy of "home ownership" through tax deductions is yet another way that the tax code redistributes wealth from the young to the old, as all renters know. It might not be a very appealing tag line, but a progressive tax code has to be the basis of truly progressive economic policies.

My other major issue is that a health insurance mandate does not do anything to directly reduce health care costs for businesses that already pay for the health care coverage of most Americans. A mandate forces universal coverage, but does not provide a subsidy that would make American labor more competitive with Europe, Canada, etc. This is a long-term disadvantage with respect to trade that we cannot afford. I know that Clinton makes arguments about reducing costs with universal coverage, but from a trade perspective, we need an outright subsidy, just like Europe and Canada, to be competitive. Industries in those countries do not have to include health care in their direct costs -- that's a huge business advantage.

I do not see a practical way to transition from  government mandated private insurance to government subsidized public insurance. The mandate would do a few things that I think are bad:

(a) Expand a trend towards "privatization" of things that are not competitive markets, like private security as opposed to police, private military firms, private standardized testing companies, private power companies, cable TV, etc. "Self-regulated private industry" is a noxious myth that private health insurance mandates play into.

(b) Remove public pressure for subsidized government care. My sense is that the middle class would be put in a very defensive posture trying to pay for mandates that they could not afford, while those "in charge" could tout universal care as a reason not to expand government subsidies of heath care.

(c) Give Republicans a huge opportunity to attack a program that would undoubtedly be very unpopular with the middle class and younger workers, who would know when they are paying for more than they are getting.

The upshot is that I think we must use a progressive tax to pay for subsidized health care. We have to start by making it free for kids and cheaper for young people. Free clinics (for anyone) should be funded at federal, state, and local levels. Trying to do it with mandates may be worse than doing nothing. Just try and chip away at the problem for a little while. Over the next few years, public support for something like single-payer will grow rapidly. Mandates would probably slow down the growth in public support for single-payer health care that our citizen and industry needs so badly. In particular, they might provide a route back to power for the GOP, so they can resume wrecking our economy and civilization.

By the way, this diary is intended to be about the issue of health insurance mandates only. None of this changes the fact that I did not like Obama's book. I do think he's doing a better job of reading public sentiment on this issue. Unfortunately, Obama's plan also seems to have many of the problems I describe above, since it mandates that families buy health insurance for children, rather than just providing it outright. Often, wishful supporters tell me that they think Obama "believes" in single payer, but I've have not heard Obama's words back that up.

If there is one thing that this primary season has taught me, it is that successful political candidates do not lead with ideas. On the contrary, the two remaining candidates are the ones who most successfully harvested ideas from their competitors, and indirectly from "us." So, if we want our candidates to solve a problem, we must have an idea "ourselves" (as the unofficial think-tanks of progressives.) In fact, our idea must be so well thought out that that it seems very simple and obvious to us, and anyone we explain it to. That's hard to accomplish with something as complex as health care, but I think it is possible. If most well-informed Democrats are familiar with issues around insurance mandates, single-payer care, and so on, and think the answers are obvious, then some of our ideas might get picked up by aspiring politicians. We need to talk about and think about this a lot, so when a politician proposes something, we can give instant feedback, as opposed to just being either "convinced" or baffled. Obama and Clinton, during the debates, talked around health care issues very cleverly, both picking up easy points and tag-lines because most voters are not very well informed about these issues. They will only talk with more substance when they think they have to. Clinton deserves credit for being more willing to dive into the subject, even though I disagree with some of her proposals.

On the topic of being well informed: I had to put together most of the conclusions above on my own, and I am no expert on health care. I would have appreciated having a chance to read an analysis like the one above. If any commenter has seen the issue of heath insurance mandates analyzed in a similar way, please provide me with a link.

This is cross-posted at dKos. I wanted to put it over here, too, because dKos has become something of a monoculture lately, and I'd really appreciate comments from a variety of points of view.


Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

USER MENU

Open Left Campaigns

SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

QUICK HITS
STATE BLOGS
Powered by: SoapBlox