'Growing consensus' among House Progressives to dump Geithner (Chris Bowers)
House Progressives have started to make the first rumblings about dumping Tim Geithner. So says Representative DeFazio:

A member of the Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC) said Wednesday that there is a "growing consensus" among the liberal bloc to force Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner to step down.

Unfortunately, they don't seem to have a plan to make it happen:

DeFazio said that lawmakers have not yet drafted a plan to remove Geithner. The lawmaker also took aim at top Obama economic adviser Larry Summers for furthering many of the same policies favored by Geithner.

"We need a new economic team," said DeFazio.

So, a long way to go.  Still, it is nice that someone is making noise about this.

I have a plan
team up with the Ron Paul types.

Oh, wait. That's taboo.


depends on what you mean by "team up"
If you mean, "wholeheartedly embrace them and their quest to return America to the 19th century," then I would have to disagree.

If you mean, "make a temporary alliance with them in order to achieve certain policy goals, such as getting rid of Geithner or opening up the Federal Reserve to congressional audit," that's a more reasonable possiblity.

And can the Ron Paulies even contribute anything organizationally? For all their crowing about their online money bomb, they sure as hell couldn't even swing one primary for their man. Not even close.

Anti-organizational lone wolves who pride themselves on their independence aren't going to be very useful in an enterprise that requires cooperation and organization. But maybe they'll prove me wrong.


[ Parent ]
Given that Ron Paul is
neo-confedarate, I doubt that would be effective.

[ Parent ]
You confuse people being unconvinced with taboo
I haven't seen much evidence that progressives are against issue by issue alliances with Paulites - in fact, what reaction there has been has been positive. I'm all for it - there are a number of issues where that would be great (not just his excellent work on the Fed - also on ending empire and what is misleadingly called the war on terror, for example.)

But I'm unconvinced that a left-right electoral alliance could work, or that there are that many libertarians out there (i.e. enough to matter in terms of elections.)

What's more, what you keep suggesting seems unnecessary because there is extremely broad, cross party support for active government action to produce economic opportunity and security (very un-libertarian).  

Who are the best keepers of the people's liberties? The people themselves. The sacred trust can be no where so safe as in the hands most interested in preserving it.
James Madison


[ Parent ]
And in fact, this happened
when the House rejected the first TARP vote.  That the coalition fell apart when Rahm started making calls doesn't mean that the overall strategy might not work.  

[ Parent ]
Enough already with this libertarian nonsense.
Ron Paul has some good opinions that sound good to liberal ears, but the vast majority of his ideas are horrible and totally removed from reality. Could you pls stop trolling us with Ron Paul every other day?

Let it be said by our children's children that when we were tested, we refused to let this journey end, that we did not turn back, nor did we falter

[ Parent ]
It's not nonsense, just undeveloped as a strategy
See Chris Bowers' front page diary Talk Me Down from Contributing to Rand Paul's Campaign

From that article:

Second, if Rand is anything like his father--and he certainly seems to be--then even if he were to win the general election, he would defect and vote with Democrats more often than any Republican Senator outside the state of Maine.
.
.

Hell, even the Democrats who might win would probably only be reliable on 50-70% of the most important votes, which is only about twice as many as we would get from Rand Paul.

Now, Chris was talking money, while Paul Goodman was (presumably) talking about votes. Both both make a lot of sense, depending on the specifics.

The most salient specific consideration, IMO, which would differentiate a viable progressive/libertarian voting scenario from, say, a very progressive/less progressive voting bloc scenario, is that because the ideological distance between progressives and libertarians is much greater than the distance between a voting bloc coalition such as one between 2 flavors of progressive is expected to be, you probably need cooperations across district or state lines, and not (as will likely be the norm for vote bloc coalitions) within the same district or state.

So, in the case of such an alliance involving Rand Paul, the idea is that progressive voters in Kentucky register as Republicans and help ensure that Rand Paul wins, while libertarian voters in another state reciprocate by helping elect a more progressive Democrat to the Senate.

I think it makes perfect sense, if you just think about it. So, far from trying to dissuade Paul Goodman from even talking about such possibilities, I would instead a) point him towards a post I made in ronpaulforums.com, entitled
Rand Paul for Joe Sestak? Anti-corporatist electoral cooperation, anybody? and b) suggest that, if he has time and inclination, he actually work to make this or a similar situation happen. At it's simplest, there could simply be an online pair of lists of the sort that I suggested - i.e., one list of progressives, one list of libertarians, and the agreed upon process is to match one progressive vote for one libertarian vote.

Even if such an initial effort should fail to get the desired candidates elected, it could help start the ball rolling for future electoral cooperation.

Frankly, I believe that it's precisely because such a strategy has real potential that I think anybody undertaking it should be prepared for pushback from mainstream Democratic and Republican hacks. In John Emerson's fascinating diaries on Democrats and populism (such as this one), he points out that party insiders would rather suffer a lost election than lose power, themselves.

People whose main function in life is to act as gatekeepers (the public, and party rank-and-file be damned) are not going to take a viable strategy to empower voters lightly. In fact, they may be vicious.

DemocracyABC.org
TheRealNews.Com
http://www.pdamerica.org


[ Parent ]
Good!
This plus the news that the "too big to fail" legislation that would allow regulators to break up banks that affect the health of the system is great financial news.  

Getting Obama to agree would go a long way towards getting a plan
Yes, great that someone is at least making noise.

Yup. Geithner's boss never listens to progressives.
So, nice to see some folks are reasonably concerned, but this won't change anything. Geithner has to screw up massively, prompting calls for resignation from the center and right side, to get rid of him.

Let it be said by our children's children that when we were tested, we refused to let this journey end, that we did not turn back, nor did we falter

[ Parent ]
Kaptur (D-OH)
Called for "new Generals" on Moyers' show in early October:


MARCY KAPTUR: When Lincoln ran into trouble, during the Civil War, he got new generals. He brought in Grant. I hope that President Obama will bring in some new generals on the financial front.

BILL MOYERS: Should Geithner be fired? And Summers be fired?

MARCY KAPTUR: I don't think that any individuals who had their hands on creating this mess should be in charge of cleaning it up. I honestly don't think they're capable of it.



The House can't do squat ..
Unfortunately, they don't seem to have a plan to make it happen:

about Geithner .. how would Geithner be impeached?  Is it the same as impeaching a President?  And what would Rahm, and Versailles, say?


Yup, no chance in hell.
The progressive block doesn't have the votes. However, totally ok they make their objections heard. It's just that we shouldn't expect anything to come out of it.

Let it be said by our children's children that when we were tested, we refused to let this journey end, that we did not turn back, nor did we falter

[ Parent ]
Yeah
Unless they can find something that is actually a violation of US statutes, I'm not sure that I necessarily support impeaching him (and as far as I know, that's the only legal means to remove a cabinet member--Jefferson settled this one).  

Unless they just want to ramp up pressure in order to force a resignation or something.  I guess maybe a PR campaign that contrasts Paulson's economic program with Obama's campaign rhetoric might work here, but getting media traction would be very hard.  

They missed this boat during the confirmation hearings, when they just voted everyone in blindly.  


[ Parent ]
It's PR, basically
As you point out, there isn't much Congress can do to get rid of a cabinet appointee. Impeachment isn't going to happen, especially when there's no definable crime involved, just either mindboggling incompetence or total disregard for the interest of the public.

But, it's good for the progressive bloc to disengage from and - in the public's eyes - become hostile to the bailout and the banksters. When the "Wall Street over Main Street" policies start failing the public will develop a white-hot rage at those responsible and it's good that the progressives will be behind and not in front of that mob.


[ Parent ]
Don't confuse formal power with actual power
Someone in the Village loses their job when people in the Village think they should lose their job.  If Geithner became a liability for the White House, they would probably let him go.

But yes, impeaching a cabinet secretary is the same as impeaching the president. It does not require a crime, rather an abuse of power.

Longer term, bringing impeachment back (for its legitimate purposes) is a good thing - John Nichols is right.  

Who are the best keepers of the people's liberties? The people themselves. The sacred trust can be no where so safe as in the hands most interested in preserving it.
James Madison


[ Parent ]
they could use informal mechanisms
holding up legislation, etc.

[ Parent ]
57 CPC members
signed a letter stating that they wouldn't support a healthcare bill with a po as weak as the one in the bill put forward by the D leadership. Only 2 of them kept that pledge -- Kucinich and Massa.

Why should anyone pay any attention at all to statements from the CPC? The House leadership certainly doesn't.


I quit doing two things.
One of them was listening to Democrats.   But if I was going to listen, it would be to Massa and Kucinich.  

They're asking for another four years -- in a just world, they'd get 10 to 20. ~~ Dennis Kucinich  

[ Parent ]
Um, no
They signed a letter saying they wouldn't support a health care bill with no public option at all. That's not the same thing.

[ Parent ]
because more and more of them will more and more keep their pledges
so a smart leader would wait until it got to a critical mass and then start acting progressive.  it's basically a matter of time...

also, they happen to be right about this :)


[ Parent ]
because more and more of them will more and more keep their pledges
so a smart leader would wait until it got to a critical mass and then start acting progressive.  it's basically a matter of time...

also, they happen to be right about this :)


[ Parent ]
Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search