Non-Christians Continue to Increase

by: Chris Bowers

Mon Feb 25, 2008 at 14:32


In a national demographic shift of equal importance to the increasing number of Latinos, Asians and "Others" within race / ethnicity self-identification in America, the number of Americans self-identifying as Christian continues to decline as a precipitous rate:

But the survey, based on interviews with more than 35,000 Americans, offers one of the clearest views yet of that trend, scholars said.(...)

The survey also indicates that the group that had the greatest net gain was the unaffiliated. More than 16 percent of American adults say they are not part of any organized faith, which makes the unaffiliated the country's fourth largest "religious group."(...)

While the unaffiliated have been growing, Protestantism has been declining, the survey found. In the 1970s, Protestants accounted for about two-thirds of the population. The Pew survey found they now make up about 51 percent.(...)

The percentage of Catholics in the American population has held steady for decades at about 25 percent. But that masks a precipitous decline in native-born Catholics. The proportion has been bolstered by the large influx of Catholic immigrants, mostly from Latin America, the survey found.

The complete survey can be found here. Overall, it indicates that 21.4% of the country does not self-identify as Christian, with unaffiliated making up the majority of that diverse group. It is also worth noting that unaffiliated is itself a diverse and largely unknown group:

The rise of the unaffiliated does not mean that Americans are becoming less religious, however. Contrary to assumptions that most of the unaffiliated are atheists or agnostics, most described their religion "as nothing in particular." Pew researchers said that later projects would delve more deeply into the beliefs and practices of the unaffiliated and would try to determine if they remain so as they age.

This is a massive demographic shift that we must understand. Such a large change in a major ideological institution in America, religion, necessarily results in a major shift in American ideology in general. In particular, I have often noted how self-identified whites who do not self-identify as Christian tend to vote for Democrats at almost exactly the same 2-1 or 3-1 ratios as self-identified non-whites. When someone does not self-identify as Christian, it appears to have an equivalent impact on their voting behavior as not self-identifying as white. Given that both non-Christian self-identifiers and non-white self-identifies are growing at rapid rates in America, they appear to be the future of both the Democratic Party in particular and American politics in general. More than 60% of Americans under the age of 43 fall into one or both of these demographic groups. This massive generational demographic shift, combined with the conservative movement's attack on these groups, are the main reasons for why Democrats are no performing exceptionally well with young voters in America.

The diversity within these groups makes continuing to appeal to them at such fantastic rates a difficult task. Latinos, Asians, those with unaffiliated religions, and the religious but non-Christian are all highly diverse groups within themselves, making any monolithic messaging difficult. Faced with such a diverse array of emerging cultural identities within America, the only generalized solution for Democrats and progressives is to make certain that pluralism is a core value in both rhetoric and legislation. The conservative movement has done a good job presenting a cultural supremacist contrast, leaving progressives with a wide open opportunity to continue to score huge margins among the fastest growing demographic groups in America.  

Chris Bowers :: Non-Christians Continue to Increase
Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Interesting. (0.00 / 0)
I think the narratives in the news suggest the opposite. The news seems to always be talking about churches growing, the religious right growing stronger, religious controversies (evolution) growing.

I wonder if there is a reason for that, or if they are just news hungry.  

A party that claims government can't work, can't possibly run a government that does work. --Daily Kos


Backlash against slowly increasing non-religiousness? (4.00 / 1)
That was Matt Yglesias' theory in this post from a couple of months ago:

One hears from a lot of secular people worries that the country is plunging over the edge into theocracy. At the same time, the press often seems to feel that the country is experiencing a massive religious revival that it needs to cover by hiring new "religion" correspondents. The truth, as shown in the above chart based on National Election Survey data, is more like the reverse -- more people than ever say "other" or "none" when asked about their religious beliefs.

It's this, rather than an intensification in fervor, that's made it possible to mobilize conservative Christianity for political purposes. Back in 1960 there were so few avowedly irreligious people out there that trying to rally opposition to the perils of secularism was a non-starter.

 

[ Parent ]
Religious Right is radicalized (0.00 / 0)
It's all happening the same time. The Religious Right has radicalized and politicized religion, but they're still a small minority of the US population. They'll include Catholics and mainline Protestants for statistical purposes when they talk about the US being a Christian nation, but in the next breath they'll denounce Catholics as heretics. It's enough power to swing a Republican primary but still a minority outside the Bible Belt.

[ Parent ]
The US is becoming radicalized (0.00 / 0)
at either end of the spectrum. Religious people are, by and large, becoming more religious, more conservative, and more evangelical, though the rate of change has slowed considerably in recent years. Non-religious people are becoming more progressive, more comfortable with being not much of anything in particular, and there's just plain more of them.

It's folks like me - from the moderate mainline and Catholic churches - that feel the squeeze.

Visit Street Prophets to talk about faith + politics!


[ Parent ]
Almost 80 percent (4.00 / 1)
is still huge. I wish someone could really look into what people mean when they say they're "Christian". Do they follow the political/social values of their religious leaders? Do they think there's something vaguely "good" about Christianity? Do they know anything about what the religion and their sect of it believe and teach?

Surveys say that only about a quarter of Americans go to church regularly. "Self-identify" strikes me as just more meaningless sociobabble. What matters is where people form their opinions on "faith-based" issues, most of which revolve around sex and science.


almost 80% is large (4.00 / 1)
However, that is why this trend is so important when combined with the increasing number of people in America who do not self-identify as white. Overall, the number of white Christians  is now barely a majority in America, and dropping rapidly. The two trends together point to a broad cultural shift in America.  

[ Parent ]
"what people mean" (4.00 / 1)
My guess is that most people who are not fervent church-goers,  yet who self-identify as Christian, are mainly people whose parents were Christians and who don't go to church mainly through apathy rather than any serious questioning of the premises of their parents' religion. They don't bother to go to church, but they also don't bother to do any research into the origins of Christianity that might lead to any kind of informed evaluation of the subject at all. Just a guess.

[ Parent ]
I have to agree (4.00 / 1)
if only because that describes my own experience (though I did eventually bother to self-evaluate and ultimately I went with "None").

[ Parent ]
Correct. (0.00 / 0)
They're "cultural Christians" in the same way Jews sometimes talk about it as an ethnic, not religious, identity.

Visit Street Prophets to talk about faith + politics!

[ Parent ]
pondering... (4.00 / 1)
As a self-identifying white male Christian, demographically I'd be expected to be quite the Republican. Socio-economically, however, the circumstances are different. But class aside, I don't believe religion and politics necessarily should have a hard and fast correlation. I'd be expected to be fervently anti-gay rights, pro-life, etc, based merely upon my religion, but just because I believe in the Church, doesn't mean I have to ascribe to everything the leaders do. Theres a difference between faith in the resurrection of Christ (which one might think is a major part of being Christian) and believing that homosexuality is a sin/inherently evil/etc. I think many people fail to see that.

And not to put words in Chris' or anyone else's mouth, but generally I find on left-leaning blogs, the decline of religion is looked on as a good thing, not necessarily with any explicit words (I don't want to suggest some militant atheist/agnostic agenda -- obviously in cahoots with the Right's other boogeyman, the Gay Agenda), but in a more passive sense.

Yes, I can see how #s of self-identifying Christians would help the left, because the votes tend to vote Republican. But I believe that's just because they're confused, and voting against their class interest. I don't believe Jesus ever said anything nearly as hateful as the garbage that comes out of the collective right.

I also don't believe Chris was suggesting any sort of glee at the decline of self-ID religion/Christianity in America.

[shrug] Apologies for the rant.


[ Parent ]
See where you're coming from (0.00 / 0)
But pretty much nobody on the left hates Jesus' teaching.

It's just that the religious right needs to be knocked back if you want to have a Christianity that adheres to the spirit rather than the letter of its tenets.

Forgotten Countries - a foreign policy-focused blog


[ Parent ]
Explicit words: (0.00 / 0)
I find it comforting that there is a decline in [organized] religion. (a decline in religion itself has not been suggested here).  

[ Parent ]
MENU

OpenLeft in your inbox!

 

Or, subscribe to each author individually.

PREMIUM AD

ADVERTISEMENTS



SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

OPENLEFT VIDEO WALL
Donna Edwards Thanks OpenLeft


Russ Feingold on the New FISA Legislation


Jon Conyers on Impeachment


Al Franken Thanks Blue Majority


FCC Commissioner Michael Copps on Pearl Jam, Net Neutrality


Darcy Burner on the FISA Legislation

More OpenLeft video...

LIBERAL INSTITUTIONS
BUSH DOGS