Ultimate Delegate Math

by: Chris Bowers

Sat Mar 22, 2008 at 18:30

In the extended entry, I provide a complete breakdown of the delegate situation. It is far more expansive than any breakdown I have completed in the past.
Democratic Nomination Campaign Delegate Projection #1
Delegate Type Obama Clinton Other Remaining Total 50%+1
Total 1 1,415.5 1,253.5 18 566 3,253 1,627
Super 209 246 0 263 718 --
Projected Add-ons 40 24 0 12 76 --
Total 2 1,664.5 1,523.5 18 841 4,047.0 2,024.0

In this table, "Total 1" includes pledged delegates outside of Florida and Michigan, while "Total 2" includes pledged, super and projected add-on delegates outside of Florida and Michigan. Detailed pledged delegate results can be found at the bottom of this post. Superdelegate totals can be found at Democratic Convention Watch. Add-on delegates are projected, winner-take-all, from the states each candidate has won. Obama is projected to win the add-on delegates from Nevada and Texas, Clinton is projected to win the add-on delegate from New Hampshire, and the two add-on delegates from Missouri are projected as split.

Based on current polling or, when no polling is available, analogous contests, here are the projected delegate totals for the remaining states and territories:

Democratic Nomination Primary Schedule
State Date O % C % P. Del Obama Del Clinton Del
Pennsylvania Apr 22 36.4% 52.6% 158 66 92
Guam May 03 -- -- 4 2 2
Indiana May 06 40.0% 25.0% 72 41 31
North Carolina May 06 46.7% 41.3% 115 60 55
West Virginia May 13 24.5% 49.0% 28 9 19
Kentucky May 20 -- -- 51 21 30
Oregon May 20 -- -- 52 27 25
Puerto Rico Jun 01 -- -- 55 23 32
Montana Jun 03 -- -- 16 8 8
South Dakota Jun 03 -- -- 15 8 7
Total June 10 46.0% 45.5% 566 265 301

American Samoa is the analogous contest for Guam, Tennessee is the analogous contest for Kentucky, Arizona is the analogous contest for Puerto Rico, and the Washington primary is the analogous contest for Montana, Oregon and South Dakota. These numbers lead to a third total:

Democratic Nomination Campaign Delegate Projection #2
Delegate Type Obama Clinton Other Remaining Total 50%+1
Total 2 1,664.5 1,523.5 18 841 4,047.0 2,024.0
Projected Pledged 265 301 0 0 566 --
Projected Super 0 0 0 263 718 --
Projected Add-ons 6 6 0 0 76 --
Total 3 1,935.5 1,830.5 18 263 4,047.0 2,024.0

The entire remainder in the above projection comes from superdelegates.

If a deal is struck to seat Florida as is (notes on the projected Florida and Michigan delegations can be found at the bottom of this post), but no deal is struck to seat Michigan, a fourth total emerges:

Democratic Nomination Campaign Delegate Projection #3
Delegate Type Obama Clinton Other Remaining Total 50%+1
Total 3 1,935.5 1,830.5 18 263 4,047.0 2,024.0
Pledged 67 105 13 128 -- --
Super 4 8 0 301 -- --
Add-ons 0 3 0 2 -- --
Total 4 2,006.5 1,946.5 31 431 4,415.0 2,208.0

The remainder in the above projection is a combination of superdelegates and the entire Michigan delegation.

If a deal is struck to seat both Florida and Michigan as is, a fifth total emerges:

Democratic Nomination Campaign Delegate Projection #4
Delegate Type Obama Clinton Other Remaining Total 50%+1
Total 4 2,006.5 1,946.5 31 431 4,415.0 2,208.0
Pledged 0 73 55 0 -- --
Super 1 7 0 293 -- --
Add-ons 0 2 0 0 -- --
Total 5 2,007.5 2,028.5 86 293 4,415.0 2,208.0

The entire remainder in the above projection comes from superdelegates.

These five totals result in the following magic number projections:

Magic Numbers and Percentage of Remaining Delegates Needed
Total Clinton Del Obama Del Remaining Clinton % Obama %
Total 1 373.5 211.5 566 66.0% 37.4%
Total 2 500.5 359.5 841 59.5% 42.7%
Total 3 193.5 88.5 263 73.6% 33.7%
Total 4 261.5 200.5 431 60.7% 46.8%
Total 5 179.5 199.5 293 61.3% 68.1%

According to totals #1 and #3, the campaign is over as, short of the most destructive political scandal against Obama ever, there is simply no conceivable way that Clinton can acquire either 66.0% or 73.6% of the remaining delegates. According to totals #2 and #4, the campaign is virtually over, since Clinton needs to string together significantly and repeatedly outperform current polling in order to achieve the requisite number of delegates. According to total #5, we are inexorably headed toward a floor fight over at least the Michigan delegation, since there is virtually no conceivable way that either candidate can acquire the delegates necessary to win.

Obama will reach 2,024 delegates outside of Florida and Michigan sometime between May 20th and June 21st. From that point, the length of the nomination campaign depends on whether or not deals are struck to seat the Florida and Michigan delegations, and what sort of deals those will be. As such, there are only two contingencies that would result in the nomination campaign continuing into July. First, there is an extreme outside chance that Clinton could go on a remarkable run in the remaining states and territories which pushes the delegate count so close that even if Obama was given all 55 uncommitted delegates in Michigan, there is simply no way to know who is ahead without a roll call at the convention. Second, no deals are struck on Florida and Michigan, and even though Obama has reached 2,024 outside of Florida and Michigan, the Clinton campaign argues it still has a chance if Obama is given no pledged delegates in Michigan.

So, basically we are waiting to see if Clinton can pull off a string of landslides, force a favorable deal in Florida and Michigan, or prevent any deal thus resulting in a floor fight over Florida and / or Michigan at the convention. That is the ultimate delegate math, and that is what this campaign has come down to.

Detailed Pledged Delegate Count
State Reporting C % O % Delegates Clinton Obama
P. Delegates 82.6% 46.7% 52.7% 2,687 1,253.5 1,415.5
Alabama 100% 42% 56% 52 25 27
Alaska 100% 25% 74% 13 4 9
Am. Samoa 100% 57% 42% 3 2 1
Arizona 100% 50% 42% 56 31 25
Arkansas 100% 70% 27% 35 27 8
California 100% 52% 43% 370 204 166
Colorado 99% 32% 67% 55 20 35
Connecticut 100% 47% 51% 48 22 26
Delaware 100% 42% 53% 15 6 9
Dems Abroad 100% 33% 66% 7 2.5 4.5
D.C. 100% 24% 75% 15 3 12
Georgia 100% 31% 67% 87 27 60
Hawaii 100% 24% 76% 20 6 14
Idaho 100% 17% 79% 18 3 15
Iowa 100% 29% 38% 45 14 25
Illinois 99% 33% 65% 153 49 104
Kansas 100% 26% 74% 32 9 23
Louisiana 100% 36% 57% 56 22 34
Maine 99% 40% 59% 24 9 15
Maryland 99% 36% 61% 70 28 42
Massachusetts 100% 56% 41% 93 55 38
Minnesota 99% 32% 66% 72 24 48
Mississippi 100% 37% 61% 33 14 19
Missouri 100% 48% 49% 72 36 36
Nebraska 100% 32% 68% 24 8 16
Nevada 100% 51% 45% 25 12 13
New Hampshire 100% 39% 36% 22 9 9
New Jersey 100% 54% 44% 107 59 48
New Mexico 100% 49% 48% 26 14 12
New York 100% 57% 40% 232 139 93
North Dakota 100%. 37% 61% 13 5 8
Ohio 100% 55% 44% 141 75 66
Oklahoma 100% 55% 31% 38 24 14
Rhode Island 100% 58% 40% 21 13 8
South Carolina 100% 27% 55% 45 12 25
Tennessee 100% 54% 41% 68 40 28
Texas Caucus 40% 44% 56% 67 29 38
Texas Primary 100% 51% 47% 126 65 61
Utah 100% 39% 57% 23 9 14
Vermont 100% 39% 59% 15 6 9
Virginia 99% 35% 64% 83 29 54
Virgin Islands 100% 8% 92% 3 0 3
Washington 96% 31% 68% 78 26 52
Wisconsin 100% 41% 58% 74 32 42
Wyoming 100% 38% 61% 12 5 7

Notes

  • The remaining 18 delegates from states with completed results are for John Edwards.
  • Delegate counts for caucus states might alter following county, district and state party conventions, which take place variously from March through June. Click here for a schedule of state conventions.
  • The Michigan Democratic Party has claimed it will send a pledged delegate count of 73 Clinton, 55 uncommitted to the national convention. The DNC has ruled that Michigan has no pledged delegates. This conflict will be worked out by the DNC credentials committee, sometime in June or July. For more on the DNC credentials committee, click here.
  • The Florida Democratic Party has claimed that it will send a pledged delegate count of 105 Clinton, 67 Obama, and 13 Edwards to the national convention. The DNC has ruled that Florida has no pledged delegates. This conflict will be worked out by the DNC credentials committee, sometime in June or July.
  • There are 794 unlpledged, or "super" delegates, to the DNC convention, plus another 54 from Michigan and Florida, and minus 81 add-on delegates (including 5 from Michigan and Florida). Historically, they have lined up behind the pledged delegate leader. In the event that there is no clear pledged delegate leader in June, they will come into play. In that "tiebreaker" event, Clinton currently holds a large, but declining, advantage.
  • For more on a possible brokered convention, click here.
Close Window