Israel, Blogging and Transparency

by: Chris Bowers

Thu Apr 10, 2008 at 00:00


Now that a few of us are in Israel, check out the great coverage the trip is getting on the right-wing blogosphere. Here are some of the comments from Pat Dollard's blog:

IP727
PERHAPS WE CAN FORWARD THE CO-ORDINATES OF THIS
LITTLE GROUP OF RUMP RANGERS TO THE HAMAS TERRS, NOW
THAT THEY WILL BE BUNCHED TOGTHER, LIKE FLIES ON SHIT.
April 8th, 2008 at 11:31 am

steve m
(...)IP727 - right on Bro' Maybe a few of these little maggots will get smoked over there.. but they'll always find a way to spin it "Bush's fault"
April 8th, 2008 at 12:42 pm

Dan (The Infidel)
Wouldn't it be sweet if Hamass or Hizzbullshitta launch a strike against Israel just when the gaybait losers arrive at the border? (...) April 8th, 2008 at 5:22 pm

Jim Jam
(...)For once, i am rooting for ham-ass...bombs away, aim for the roaches!!!
April 9th, 2008 at 7:27 am

Also, for fun, here is the note on Pat Dollard's blog for anyone leaving a comment:

Be respectful of others and their opinions. Inflammatory remarks and inane leftist drivel will be deleted. It ain't about free speech, remember you're in a private domain. My website, my prerogative.

So, not only does Pat Dollard consider comments calling for our deaths to be "respectful of others," but I guess Pat Dollard personally endorses terrorists killing us, given that it is his private website.

More insight on the trip from Gentile Voices:

Whoever cam up with this idea should be hung for treason.

A Hog on Ice comment

It would be intensely ironic if the "Religion of Pieces" were to strike them while they were there. Then the survivors could come back and blog about how it was all Bush's fault (along with the Jews, of course).
km | 04.09.08 - 5:53 pm

****

Conservative desires for the death of the people involved in this trip aside, there are obviously some legitimate questions about accepting a free trip to Israel. For one thing, it presents an image of the trip having a not so hidden agenda, especially when there is actually a media report on the trip that includes the following passages:

The Foreign Affairs Ministry has long since been exerting considerable efforts to bring the prominent writers for an extensive tour of the country, in recognizing the influence many of the writers wield and the fact some of them represent websites that are less-than-friendly towards the Israel.(...)

The group will be taken to view Sderot and Israel's 'narrow waistline' by helicopter in an effort to convey the true meaning of a return to the borders of June 4th 1967.

More in the extended entry.

Chris Bowers :: Israel, Blogging and Transparency
To be honest, when I was first offered the trip about seven weeks ago, two quick worries popped into my mind. First, was it safe to travel to Israel? Second, was there a political agenda behind the trip? After a couple hours, I realized the first concern was a little ridiculous, given that the city and neighborhood where I live, West Philly, actually had a higher rate of violent deaths than Israel did even during the second Intifada (the rate of violent deaths in the West Bank, however, is much higher than that in Philly). The worries over the trip having a possible political agenda, and a right-wing agenda at that, were somewhat allayed by the organizing group being the National Jewish Democratic Council (the organization exists to promote Democrats, not Israel), a little more allayed by talking with Tom McMahon (he and Howard Dean had gone on the trip in a previous year), yet more allayed by seeing an itinerary that included talking to Dr. Naomi Chazan of Meretz and actually visiting Ramallah in the West Bank to talk with Dr. Saeb Erekat, head negotiator for the PLO. It certainly didn't appear to be a trip that was pushing a hard-right view of Israel, and so I agreed to go. A free educational trip to Israel sounded--and so far has been--fantastic. This was especially the case since I hadn't left the country in ten years, had never been to Israel, and don't even really have enough money to take traveling vacation, much less an overseas one to a fascinating part of the world.

One aspect of life as a prominent blogger is that you live much of your life in public, but at the same time readers know very little about you. Often, you are accused of working for a candidate or organization without disclosing it. Also, many people frequently question the advertising that appears on your website, and argue that ads for certain less-than-progressive organizations or candidates should be rejected. The Chevron ad on many blogs was a good example of this. Further, whenever bloggers manage to score high-level meetings, such as with Bill Clinton or Harry Reid, there is always the lingering question of whether those meetings are arranged solely to reduce criticism of the high-ranking officials in question. Will bloggers become tools of the establishment because of these meetings? Further, are there other, less public, back channels where bloggers hob-nob with high ranking insiders?

These questions range from the legitimate and partially accurate to the paranoid and insulting. They are, however, a fact of life in such an impersonal medium, and in a world where transparency is too often a rarity. The key, I have always believed, is simply to be honest and open. When I secure a political consulting gig, I disclose it. When I write a freelance piece, I link to it. When someone pays for me to travel somewhere, I say so. When an ad appears on Open Left, it is because I approve all ads on Open Left. I write under my own name, so that everything I write on the blog is something I would be willing to say in person. I let everyone know that I am both a Democrat and a definite lefty, because I don't pretend to be covering politics from a disinterested, 501c(3) perspective. I want to take partisan, ideological action. In fact, whenever I ask my readers to take an action, I always make sure to take it myself first. Don't ask someone to do something you are not willing to do yourself.

I don't think anyone is ever entirely free of conflicts of interests, but I also don't think that renders all arguments to be of equally subjective merit. The key, I think, is simply to be open and honest, make the strongest arguments you can, cite your sources, and then let everyone decide for him or herself. Actually, I even think that the establishment media focus on "balance" and "objectivity" is misplaced, when the focus should be on honesty and transparency. If you don't think I can be fair and accurate about Israel and Palestine because I took this trip, that is your business. The truth is, it would actually bother me a lot more if you thought, rather than being wrong or inaccurate, that I was being dishonest about Israel and Palestine because I felt some sort of obligation to provide a certain slant after taking this trip. On more of an egocentric level, it would also really bother me if you somehow thought I was so naïve or incapable of thinking for myself that I would return simply repeating everything I saw and heard here. Then again, if you thought that even my exposure to this trip would create a sort of brainwashing effect on me, you probably don't read Open Left to begin with (or, at least you don't read it because you think I have anything of merit to write).

So, there it is. This sort of thing happens every day in the life of a blogger, though certainly not on this scale. A trip to Israel may not make me any money, but it certainly blows away all of the free books I receive but rarely ever review, or free tee-shirts I receive but rarely ever wear. It even beats getting into some conferences for free, or the press credentials I sometimes receive. And, as a blogger, there is certainly nothing unusual about having an organization encouraging you to write about a certain topic, or provide a certain slant on a given issue. While in one way it is par for the course, it is also the best perk I have ever received as a blogger. Draw whatever conclusions you want from it, but please, whatever conclusions you draw, take what I write at face value. I am certainly not hiding anything.  

Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Trips and Meetings (4.00 / 1)
I certainly don't claim to be any real expert on Israel and/or the PLO.  In fact, I remember in my advanced International Studies course in graduate school feeling as though every single person in the room had a better grasp of the history and the politics surrounding both of these states/organizations.

Also, the underlying fear of taking a trip because there might be some underlying political agenda behind doesn't even make taking that trip a bad thing.  I have always thought that the only real way to get know anyplace is to actually visit and experience it, to speak with the people and also of course to read and hopefully at some point understand its history.  I guess what I am trying to say is that meeting with groups only brings both groups closer together...

Now I realize that Obama caught a lot of flack earlier in the year for saying that he would meet with all heads of states in his first year, "rogue" or otherwise.  Many said he was naive, many said worse things.  However, I ask everyone this question, would we be in a better position to bargain, negoitiate, peacekeep, whatever, with Iran, or Chavez, North Korea if we had been there for them in the beginning?  Could fifty years of mismanaged relations and policy with Cuba have been avoided if we had been there to just speak with Castro at the beginning?  Isn't the most influential person not the one screaming at you from across the lake, but the one sitting next to you whispering in your ear?

To paraphrase, perhaps Bart Simpson said it best when he said in response to Lisa Simpson:

Lisa: "We live in America, where we don't judge people we haven't met."
Bart: "Yeah, that's what they do in Russia."

---Come on, of course I am hideously appalled by the comments of others at other blogs and would like to think that those feelings are an enigma among the right wing, left wing or any person in general.  I think this trip is purposeful and none of the participants should think twice about taking it.



Ignore the morally-challenged armchair sociopaths (0.00 / 0)
in the wingnutosphere and just have a good time. Look, meet, listen, talk, experience, discuss, eat, drink, and learn. It's a fascinating country with fascinating people. I'd say stay safe but it's a very safe country where terrorism is simply not a factor in daily life these days. See if you can make it down to Eilat, or at least the Dead Sea. Beautiful places, although the former has gotten very commercial and touristy from what I hear. I'm sure they'll take you to each border, and the Golan Heights. Hopefully you'll see the west bank as well.

Oh, and don't be surprised when the country semi-shuts down on Saturday. Shabbat.


those comments remind me (0.00 / 0)
of a saying that was popular around the right back before 9/11, it went something like "you could take out all of manhattan and not kill a single American"

You could say these people are unbalanced, sick, there are extremists on "both sides," whatever, and they're not representative of mainstream conservatism. But then Bill O'Reilly comes out with his statement about the Coit tower a few years ago and you see that 1) nothing's changed since 9/11, these defenders of freedom don't and never did give a shit about American lives and 2) these kind of attitudes come from the top


Rock on out (0.00 / 0)
I think it's really cool that you've scored a free trip to Israel.

I'm also a bit concerned, because what if your views on the country are opposed to mine?

In any case, good luck, have fun, etc. Don't let the haters get you down.

I blog on InnermostParts.org


I never voted for John McCain


Funny how the Chickenhawks...... (0.00 / 0)
...always try to sound like soldiers in the field.

why bother reading those websites (0.00 / 0)
you'll never have the ear of the audience they attract, and they will always hate anything you do or write. so i'm not sure the point of paying attention to anything they do or say; except in the cases where a meme they might be pushing gets into a mainstream news outlet in which case its probably important to counter. but other than that, why care, and why give them links and attention?

Michael Bloomberg, prince of corporate welfare

good luck, soak in all you can (4.00 / 1)
I firmly believe that so many of America's political divisions are welded to the fact that so few Americans leave even their own state. I've travelled to Germany, Ireland, Italy, France, Switzerland, Austria, Czech Republic, Mexico and Canada.  Knowing how other people in the world live, at the street level goes a long way in understanding the what and why that goes on a half a world away.  So bring back your sense of the effect of the settlements, the palistian day laborers, the other day to day ordinary things that make up the region.  Look forward to reading about your impressions.

crazy wingnuts, thoughtful post. (0.00 / 0)
I had previously assumed that you and Jerome (and anyone else on that trip) were actually Jewish, and were members of the National Jewish Democratic Council. I guess it didn't occur to me that you guys were just offered the trip based on your "famous blogger status."

Great post though I read the entire thing and made me think more about some things. I've also worried that as time went by and blogs became more mainstream that bloggers would themselves become too much apart of the establishment. This post helped ease some of those concerns. It is good to know you guys think about this stuff too. At the end of the day I don't think that so many of us would come to you guys blogs and spend so much time reading long posts if we didn't love your writing and trust you to have better judgement than the rest of the 'mainstream' political punditry.

I would certainly be interested to hear about any "attempts to promote a political agenda" (or lack thereof) that you encountered, though I would encourage you to keep quiet about this until your return. What always angered me most about certain Israel lobby members is their insistence that American politicians tow the Likud party line.

End this war. Stop John McCain. Cindy McCain is filthy rich.


I didn't even realize... (0.00 / 0)
Kos and all of the others were going with you. The only two bloggers I saw mention it were you and Jerome, although I admit I easily could have missed the others saying it.

Seems unusual. Probably why I didn't pick up on it. Even the news story says that

Solomon Project, which was founded in 1996 to "educate the American Jewish community about its rich history of civic involvement."

found it strange they would invite non-Jewish bloggers as well. Nothing wrong with this of course, so long as the plan isn't to "brainwash." My guess is that they would know bloggers would be smart enough to pick up on that.

I wonder if this type of thing is precedented, if they've invited other non-Jewish writers of influence on similar 'excursions' in the past.

End this war. Stop John McCain. Cindy McCain is filthy rich.


[ Parent ]
I'm not in Israel (0.00 / 0)
I didn't go on the trip.

It's kind of hard for me to go anywhere without my wife and two kids hating me for my absence. Short trips are bad enough. Long trips are near impossible.


[ Parent ]
You're going to have an amazing experience (0.00 / 0)
I had the opportunity to visit Israel and Palestine in early 2006 as part of a campus ministry at the University of Wisconsin.  It's an amazing place, perhaps most amazing are the people and how they live out their daily lives in the face of such violence and oppression.  

It's great that you're able to get both perspectives on the conflict.  I was blown away by the ignorance of the 'other' that I witnessed on both sides of the border.  When you are literally physically separated from your neighbors and live in fear of them it's easy for the dehumanization of the 'other' that leads to the violence we see from over here.

I did a diary series on Kos about the trip: http://www.dailykos.com/story/...

Good luck and keep the updates coming!


Donate to Open Left
ELECTION 2008 Presidential Forecast
Senate Forecast
PREMIUM AD

ADVERTISEMENTS



MENU

OpenLeft in your inbox!

 

Or, subscribe to each author individually.

OPTIMIZE MCCAIN About
Tips
McCain
John McCain
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

OPENLEFT VIDEO WALL
Donna Edwards Thanks OpenLeft


Russ Feingold on the New FISA Legislation


Jon Conyers on Impeachment


Al Franken Thanks Blue Majority


FCC Commissioner Michael Copps on Pearl Jam, Net Neutrality


Darcy Burner on the FISA Legislation

More OpenLeft video...