Over the few days, we have held a fundraiser on Open Left, and right now we stand only $3,000 short of our financial goal. However, for the next week, we are putting that fundraiser on hold, and instead asking you to contribute money to Ed Fallon instead, whose primary against conservative Bush Dog Leonard Boswell is only seven days away.
Matt's post earlier today covers many of the issues where Boswell is a Bush-enabling conservative, and an old post of mine from last August tackles several more. Suffice to say that at Open Left working toward a progressive governing majority is our tagline, and changing Bush Dog behavior was one of our very first campaigns (heck, Matt actually coined the term "Bush Dog.") It is difficult to find a clearer opportunity to take a step toward accomplishing both goals than the IA-03 primary campaign. Defeating Leonard Boswell would send a message to all 39 of the other Bush Dogs: stop supporting Bush policies, and start voting your districts, or you will be held accountable. If you support the founding missions of Open Left, then supporting Ed Fallon is a no-brainer.
Fallon is a serious candidate, and a proven winner in this district. Even before the Des Moines Register endorsement today, Fallon defeated an incumbent Democrat for state assembly in a primary in 1992, and did so by a 2-1 margin. Ten years later, also by 2-1 margins, he fended off party-backed primary challenges for his seat. In 2006, he won this district in the Gubernatorial primary. He is experienced at winning primaries in this district, and surely with the endorsement of the DMR he will be charging hard at the end of this campaign.
In his endorsement interview, Boswell talks about how we liberated Iraq from Saddam Hussein and how the Iraqis have had elections.
Last week, I blogged about Ed Fallon and his race against Bush Dog Democrat Leonard Boswell. Fallon faces a tough race, but got a key boost this weekend. Here's what I noted on Saturday.
The hope for Fallon is that the media continues to report on the race in a substantive manner, and that Boswell's ducking of debates continues to annoy the voting public.
Today, the Des Moines Register endorsed Ed Fallon. Here's what it said about Boswell:
But currently holding the job of congressman doesn't mean a candidate automatically deserves to be re-elected. After interviewing both candidates and reviewing their records, the editorial board can no longer embrace the congressman as the best person to represent Iowa in Congress. Fallon is running under the slogan "new energy for Iowa." On June 3, Democrats in the 3rd District should give Fallon a chance to unleash some of his ideas and energy in Washington.
Why Boswell falls short
Boswell's own record of accomplishment in a dozen years in Congress is relatively light, and, in a recent meeting with the editorial board, he seemed out of touch about some serious issues facing the country.
One example: Boswell expressed skepticism about the financial problems facing Medicare, asking what economists the Register had consulted to conclude the health-care program was in fiscal trouble. It's hardly an issue for debate. The Medicare Board of Trustees has issued numerous reports outlining the trust fund's looming deficits. David Walker, former comptroller general, has expressed concerns about projected Medicare spending. Yet Boswell talked about further studying the issue rather than proposing how to address it.
On immigration, he suggested that undocumented immigrants should go back to their home countries and "get in line" for a chance to come here. That's hardly realistic considering there are an estimated 12 million undocumented immigrants in the United States.
When asked about Republican presidential candidate John McCain's prediction the previous day that most American troops could be home from Iraq by 2013, Boswell seemed unaware of McCain's statement. When asked about education in Iowa, Boswell said the state does "pretty good." And when asked what he based that on, he said Iowa's history and his own experience. But Iowa's educational system - not to mention the world economy - looks nothing like it did in Boswell's childhood.
Fallon has endorsed Obama, whereas Boswell is a Clinton superdelegate. There couldn't be a more stark difference. Here's Fallon's letter on May 10th to Boswell on his vote in the Intelligence Committee offering retroactive immunity to telecom companies.
May 10, 2008
The Hon. Leonard Boswell
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, D.C.
Dear Congressman Boswell:
I am writing today to ask you to disclose to the people of our district how you voted last week in the House Intelligence Committee on Rep. Heather Wilson's measure to add the Senate-approved FISA bill to the fiscal year 2009 intelligence authorization bill.
Published reports indicate that one of the Democratic members of the committee voted in support of Rep. Wilson's measure, thus supporting the Bush Administration's agenda of giving retroactive immunity to the telecom companies for assisting in the Administration's program of eavesdropping on Americans. You were also one of the 21 Democrats who signed a letter to Speaker Nancy Pelosi on January 28, 2008, asking the House to grant such retroactive immunity to the telecom companies.
Your original and continued support of the so-called "Protect America Act" and of the PATRIOT Act is an issue to be addressed in public debates. As one of your constituents, I want to know why you supported these bills, and whether you continue to support them. In particular, I want to know whether you continue to support granting retroactive immunity to telecom companies.
On a related matter, I am disappointed that you have refused to debate me, and I encourage you to reconsider. You and I both know that, as candidates for public office, we have a responsibility to voters to let them see us, face-to-face, discussing the key issues facing our district, state, and nation. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Ed Fallon
Candidate for Congress
We are thinking of doing a special OpenLeft fundraiser for Fallon.
What is progressive if not a willingness to push back? There is much to be gained by pushing back against right winged conservatives and even Blue Dog Democrats and, I would maintain, there is also much to be gained by pushing back against ourselves. The blogosphere, including the Open Left, not unlike other collections of people, is such a diverse assortment of homogenous pod. Safe though it may be, the chrysalis has little impact on the world beyond its shell.
I am not a wonk. I am an activist on a very local level, which, I suspect, puts me in a different universe than those focused more nationally and globally. One of the few sources I read for analysis of the world beyond my own little pod is Openleft.com. It is practically the only blog that I read and I read it only sporadically. I find depth and insight here that broadens my understanding from a perspective that I share. I have never found a lot of connection between most of the posts that I read here and the Bush Dog strategy. But here lately I keep stumbling against this approach that seems somewhat ancillary to the value I find in Openleft. I am increasingly irritated and baffled by this Bush Dog approach.
I suspect that part of this difference may be a reflection of perspectives from different scales. As a local activist, I am very much of the "all politics is local" perspective. The authors of Openleft come more from a "politics of the possible," big institutions perspective. As someone who works on very localized and often nonpartisan issues that allow me to join hands with Republicans and others I might not agree with on issues other than those at hand, I want to consider context and extenuating circumstances. National politics serves to average context across great distance.
Two years ago while I sat on the leadership council of our local Planned Parenthood facility, I worked to help elect a City Council woman who is rather avidly anti-choice. It just so happens that this woman also believes in quality of life for our community and opposes sprawl development. The clinic is in a neighboring town so she could do no damage there. Many in our progressive community could not bring themselves to support this candidate. While I can appreciate this principled stance, I feel that in supporting her I gained a lot for my community, and for a progressive agenda. While my support is not going to change her stance on choice, this woman now sees progressives as her ally on at least some issues. No longer will she be able to marginalize and demonize all progressives - nor I all conservatives.
As a southerner, I know the power of welcoming hospitality. While many southerners are anything but progressive, they often do hold this uniquely southern and distinctly progressive value of hospitality. I know some who are eloquent in their defense of civil rights, yet treat the individuals around them with little dignity. I know others who hold racist thoughts, yet manage to treat all with dignity. Neither is justifiable, yet both hold the elements of redemption that we seek.
Painting all Bush Dogs with the same brush is counterproductive and maybe even ill-progressive. Where there is a chance to replace a conservative Democrat with a more liberal one we should make the effort, but attacking Democrats who represent Republican, or swing districts for making some less than progressive votes is cutting off our nose to spite our face. So often what we get from Openleft is detailed and nuanced analysis, yet this approach lacks any of that. As a progressive I am thrilled to be represented by a Bush Dog. My congressman, Chet Edwards, has received a few letters from me lamenting his votes against such things as gay marriage. He has also received donations from me for his consistent votes for choice and even his only occasional vote against the war because I know that if he were not in office we would probably have a big-business, anything but compassionate, mean spirited Republican in his place.
It is annoying to see Edwards listed as a Bush Dog by people outside of my district who have failed to consider the extenuating circumstance that he operates in. Even if you are unwilling to compromise idealistically, consider that maybe that is what he is doing. Democrats in Republican districts do not have the luxury of voting on principle with each and every vote. They must measure each vote against its likely impact and its proximity to election time. Look, for example, how these Democrats votes have changed since there has been a Democratic congress. Consider how critical their "wrong" votes are. Are they voting "wrong" when their vote has no chance to make a difference but coming through when they need to?
One cannot help but chuckle when Open Left points out the homogeneity of the Bush Dogs. I'm sure that the irony is lost on no one, least of all these perceptive writers. I am no more threatened by the maleness or whiteness of Bush Dogs than I am of that of Chris, Mike and Matt. And I can assure you that there is nothing in the warm water of the south that makes people conservative. These are correlations that cause some to make sweeping generalizations that malign what it is to be progressive.
I am just as willing to be tolerant of the few differences that I have with Openleft and this Bush Dog approach as I am willing to be of my Bush Dog representative. I can only hope for reciprocation
We're headed for a realigning period in American politics, but whether we get there with a group of conservative Democrats or progressive Democrats is an open question. In fact, in many ways, it's the political question.
Who will Obama be as President? If he is confronted with 60 Blue Dogs in the House that feel no pressure, he will be a moderate President, necessarily. If he has progressive allies advocating from the left pressing for a low carbon economy, a sustainable food system, and a return to a civil society that respects the rule of law and criminalizes torture, he will be progressive. The place to make this change is in primaries, but there is a reason most DC groups won't go there. It is because when you try to go after someone within the party, party establishment figures go after you. It's a compendium of little things, from denying credentials to conventions to being unable to find consultants and pollsters and media buyers to work a race.
The political market is divided into Democrats and Republicans, and if you don't play by the standard partisan rules, you get pushed out. And so it's not a surprise that after Donna Edwards in Maryland's fourth district, there is only one other significant primary going on, in Iowa's third: incumbent Bush Dog Leonard Boswell versus progressive activists Ed Fallon.
Fallon is hated by the establishment, much more so than Donna. He has raised a much smaller amount of money, around $200,000 versus $900,000 for Donna. The Iowa legislature actually passed a law during this campaign making it harder for Fallon to take a salary from an organization he runs, just to be punitive. Fallon is a pure anti-establishment guy; he beat an incumbent to get into the state legislature, and then came in third in the gubernatorial primary against the current Governor of the state (though winning the third district). He backed Edwards first, and now he backed Obama, though in 2000, he supported Nader. He refuses PAC money of all kinds, and has taken the Change Congress pledge put forward by Larry Lessig. There is literally no one less likely to piss off the establishment than Ed Fallon.
On the other side is Leonard Boswell, a 74 year old conservative Democrat representing a liberal district. Boswell is a Vietnam vet, and has been in Congress for twelve years, though redestricting changed the contours of who he represented; local politicos tell me that he has 'yet to jell with the district'. In other words, he's a jerk. A mean, curmodgeonly, sonuvabitch. About two thirds of his money comes from corporate and labor PACs.
If you can name it, Boswell's bad on it. Free trade, net neutrality, torture in the Military Commissions Act, subsidies for oil and gas companies, CAFE standards, the estate tax, increasing the use of coal, immigration, the Bankruptcy Bill, factory hog confinements, etc. My favorite is factory hog confinements, which are industrial size pig farms that create football field size pools of shit in rural areas. Boswell is for them. He's a mean-spirited, degraded, evil man who wants to jail immigrants, torture people, burn more coal, hurt the middle class while paying off the wealthy, and help AT&T; spy on all of us to boot.
Boswell is also corrupt, sending out taxpayer funded mailers promoting himself and using $1.1M in PAC and wealthy interests to blanket the district. The abuse of franking privileges is a fairly common problem in Congress, but it's still the use of taxpayer money to run a political campaign. Nevertheless, the establishment closed ranks around him instantly, with major endorsements from labor, public officials and even liberal Senator Tom Harkin. This has resulted in a twenty four point lead in the only poll taken in the race for Boswell, back in April.
Boswell is a Blue Dog, and as part of that group, has pushed aggressively for retroactive immunity for telecom companies. While he has backed off his strident pro-war record since the primary began, in a recent intelligence committee vote, he was in all likelihood the vote that flipped the committee from 12-9 to 11-10 on immunity provisions. We don't know for sure, because he's ducking debates with Fallon, ten at this point, which means it is difficult to get him on the record.
The primary is on June 3, and Fallon has several advantages to offset Boswell's massive warchest and establishment help. He's the candidate of change, having endorsed Obama while Boswell (who is also a superdelegate) hews to Clinton. Yard signs in the district that have Obama signs tend to also have Fallon signs, and vice versa with Clinton. Obama took the district. It's also a low turnout primary. The Iowa caucuses have already happened, so people who vote again in a lower ticket race are going to vote for either Fallon or Boswell, so Fallon has a stronger activist core likely to vote in June. Finally, the media narrative is changing. Throughout most of the race, the media has been attacking Flalon for petty meaningless campaign problems, going along with Boswell's critique that Fallon is small-time and refusing to cover issus. Recently, that shifted, and Fallon's position on hog confinements is getting wide press
The hope for Fallon is that the media continues to report on the race in a substantive manner, and that Boswell's ducking of debates continues to annoy the voting public. He won't have the money to spend against Boswell, and he won't have the party establshment, so we'll see what his activists can do.
How do the Bush Dogs stack up on reproductive rights issues? Mostly bad, especially compared to the rest of the Democratic caucus. Not as bad as they could be, especially compared to the Republican caucus.
I used two voter scorecards to evaluate them on, the most recent available from NARAL Pro-Choice America (2007) and the Planned Parenthood Action Fund (2006). The NARAL 2007 House scores were based on two 2007 votes, one partially repealing the global gag rule and the other and one preserving federal funding to support Planned Parenthood in providing family planning services to low income families, with possible voting scores of 0, 50 and 100%. The PPAF 2006 House scores are based on a composite of 11 votes and/or issue positions, which you can look at by clicking on any representative's name at the link, and giving a more nuanced view of a member's stance on reproductive justice.
I'm including here only the scores of the Bush Dogs. Scores of other House members were tabulated separately but from the same references, means were calculated without the inclusion of those marked NA, or otherwise indicated below.
There is one significant pieces of news hitting today about FISA and immunity for telecom companies. The fight is being taken directly to the voters through two complementary strategies. In the House, Steny Hoyer has been relentlessly focused on pulling a deal together, one that would probably grant some sort of de facto immunity to lawbreakers in the Bush administration and in the telecommunications industry (though it's often hard to tell the two apart). He has so far been unable to negotiate between the White House, Jay Rockefeller, Jon Kyl, and liberals in the House, but every time I make inquiries I hear that there is 'encouraging' news that a deal is possible. By the same token, the ACLU is quite aware of what is going on, and has been lobbying aggressively.
As Glenn Greenwald notes, even Speaker Pelosi is pushing for a deal. The significant news is that this issue is being taken to the voters. There are two strategies being employed to make this happen. One, the Blue America PAC has raised $75k and is blanketing freshman Blue Dog Democrat Chris Carney's district with radio, billboard, print, and cable ads criticizing him for caving to Bush on immunity for telecom companies. The extraordinary television ad they put together is here, and the theme is betrayal.
Two, the following radio ad, and one similar to it, are running in the district of Blue Dogs John Tanner in Tennessee and Bud Cramer in Alabama.
You can hear the radio ad in Cramer's district here.
These ads are put together by They Work for Us, an organization sponsored by Moveon and SEIU designed to hold representatives accountable to their constituents. I consult for this organization, and we are experimenting with some issue-based advocacy around core progressive values. This strategy is designed to be a positive encouragement to Congressional representatives to refuse to give immunity to the phone companies. The script is at the bottom of this post.
By moving FISA and civil liberties out of the activist space and educating voters through broadcast media, They Work for Us hopes to demonstrate to Congressional representatives that when Democrats stand up to the lawless Bush administration, voters will be supportive. At the same time, the Blue America action is designed to show that betraying progressives carries substantial costs. Glenn puts it well:
That is true particularly if there continues to be no incentive for Congressional Democrats to pay attention to their base and do anything other than support the right-wing agenda, because they perceive that they only pay a price when they oppose the Right. That is the incentive scheme that has to change.
I first noticed this problem in August, 2007, in a piece about the Working Conservative Majority, in which I traced both how the Democratic caucus has become substantially more progressive in the last six years and that it is still controlled by a swing group of conservative Democrats that mostly reside in the Blue Dog caucus (we call the worst ones part of the 'Bush Dog' caucus). Electing more Democrats - exceptional ones like Darcy Burner, Eric Massa, Leslie Byrne, and Martin Heinrich (who spoke out eloquently on FISA here), is part of the solution. Subsequent to August, progressives have defeated a reactionary Democrat - Al Wynn - in a primary and seated a progressive, Donna Edwards, in his place, but at the same time, added three new Blue Dogs to Congress: Bill Foster, Don Cazayoux, and Travis Childers. It's clear that an incentive system designed around rewarding Democrats, Blue Dog or otherwise, when they oppose radical right-wing policies, and criticizing them when they cave, is necessary. And that's what is happening, with Blue America and They Work for Us.
Less than a month before the Democratic primary to represent Iowa's third district, Ed Fallon is trying to make Congressman Leonard Boswell either debate him or pay a political price for refusing to debate.
Join me after the jump for more on that and other recent developments in the race.
Former Vice President Al Gore has sent out an e-mail to Democrats asking for financial donations and support for Boswell's campaign. Boswell is being challenged in the 3rd District Democratic primary by Ed Fallon, a former state legislator from Des Moines.
"The congressman is honored that Vice President Gore has endorsed his candidacy for re-election and is actively participating in this campaign," said Boswell campaign manager Scott Ourth in a telephone interview with Iowa Independent.
The fundraising e-mail notes Boswell's support for Gore during the presidential campaign of 2000. "I will never forget traveling across Iowa back in 1999 and 2000 during my presidential campaign with Leonard and his wife, Dody, joining Tipper and me. Few people fought as hard for me as Leonard did," stated Gore. "From our very first bus trip until election night -- every step of the way, he was right there beside me, standing up to pharmaceutical companies, fighting to make Iowa a leader in alternative energy. As you remember, we won the caucus."
Fallon did not support Gore during the 2000 presidential campaign, opting instead to endorse and work on behalf of Green Party candidate Ralph Nader. Many Democrats still blame Nader for playing a part in Gore's 2000 loss to George Bush.
It's basic political loyalty, and I don't begrudge Al Gore his right to engage in some payback against someone that hurt him in 2000. Still, Leonard Boswell has a bad showing on subsidies for oil companies, the war in Iraq, and constitutional rights in Guantanamo.
Gore is not above politics, and despite his post-2000 persona, his political instincts remain constant. He praises John McCain and supports Boswell, much as he pushed for Free Trade in the 1990s and failed to fight for the Presidency in 2000. In other words, Gore is like a lot of antipartisan Democrats who emerged in the 1970s, speaking in media circles as a liberal while operationally supporting the status quo.
UPDATE: I suppose it's possible Gore did not know that Boswell is in a primary with a progressive primary opponent, so I sent a request for information to Al Gore's spokesperson, Kalee Kreider.
Before sending an email solicitation for Leonard Boswell's reelection campaign, did Al Gore know that there's a primary, and that Ed Fallon (Boswell's opponent) supports a moratorium on coal fired power plants? If so, why did he choose to endorse a candidate who prefers a less optimal solution on climate change than his opponent?
If you want to know why Democrats don't stand up to do the right thing, look no further than the difficulty of running in a primary. There are very few credible candidates, and one of them, Ed Fallon, is getting attacked by the Iowa state Senate itself because he dared challenge a sitting Congressman, Leonard Boswell. Boswell has run a nasty and dishonest campaign focused on extremely petty characteristics of Fallon's campaign operation. Now the Iowa Senate is getting into the action.
The Iowa Senate has passed a bill that would forbid candidates involved in state-level races from using campaign funds to pay themselves a salary. The issue has flared during a Democratic primary that pits Congressman Leonard Boswell against former State Representative Ed Fallon who paid himself a salary from his campaign funds when he ran for governor in 2006.
This is just a crazy slap in the face to progressives and to those who are not wealthy. There are huge hurdles to running for office already, so adding another one - you have to go without salary for six months - simply privileges the wealthy and entitled incumbents like Boswell. Does Boswell have to give up his Congressional salary? No. But Boswell is sending out extremely pricey mailers from his House office on his accomplishments in office.
Moreover, passing this so close to a primary election is entirely political. People in the Iowa establishment just do not like Ed Fallon, and they are making it known by abusing their power.
I'm going to guess that Boswell will vote against supplemental funding for the Iraq war, and then, if he wins reelection, immediately flip to be as hawkish as the person he endorsed in the primary, Hillary Clinton.
Last week we launched Change-Congress.org. After that event, I made my first call on a Member of Congress, to ask him to join. I knew he was a supporter of at least some of our ideas. I had come to many of my own ideas about how Congress needs to change after long conversations with him.
I am very proud to announce today that Congressman Jim Cooper (TN-5) (Dem) has become the first Member to join the Change Congress movement. (He supports planks 2, 3, and 4). Congressman Cooper is a "blue dog" Democrat.
http://campaign-archive.com/ar...
I am not sure how I feel about this. More below the jump.
McJoan has the news on the FISA victory today. It's a bit hard to describe just how much work this took and how significant a change this represents. I never believed we had a chance to stop immunity for telecom companies, I thought it was a fight worth having anyway. But something has shifted in the last few weeks that suggest this Congress is willing to stand up to Bush.
There were always two leverage points for the right on this one. First of all, the fake deadline that would leave our country vulnerable was trotted out as an excuse for expanding wiretapping authority and immunizing telecoms. I had private assurances from senior Democrats that they would make sure that the country fixed this vulnerability before the temporary FISA fix expired in August. Amazingly, the House was willing to let the bill lapse and go back to the 1978 FISA law, and called out the dishonest characterization instead of knuckling under to Bush. Second of all, 21 Bush Dogs wrote a letter asking to pass immunity for telecom companies. Those Bush Dogs create a pro-immunity majority, which gave pro-immunity Rockefeller all the leverage in House-Senate negotiations.
The Republican House secret session nonsense, combined with the amazing organizing by the ACLU and Glenn Greenwald, Jane Hamsher, Marcy Wheeler and Christie Hardin Smith and good leadership by Pelosi, Conyers, and Hoyer, and some bravery by House freshman Nancy Boyda, brought the Bush Dogs away from their position. An intelligent compromise - that phone companies would be allowed to submit evidence in court despite state secret arguments from the President rather than getting blanket immunity - allowed the Bush Dogs to vote for national security instead of the telecoms.
Here are the Bush Dogs that voted correctly on the FISA bill today (h/t Marcy Wheeler).
Congressman Joe Baca (D-California) http://www.house.gov/baca/
Congressman John Barrow (D-Georgia) http://barrow.house.gov/ Congresswoman Melissa Bean (D-Illinois) http://www.house.gov/bean/
Congressman Marion Berry (D-Arkansas) http://www.house.gov/berry/
Congressman Leonard L. Boswell (D-Iowa) http://boswell.house.gov/ Congressman Allen Boyd (D-Florida) http://www.house.gov/boyd/
Congressman Brad Ellsworth (D-Indiana) http://www.ellsworth.house.gov/ Congressman Jim Matheson, (D-Utah) http://www.house.gov/matheson/
Congressman Charlie Melancon (D-Louisiana) http://www.melancon.house.gov/ Congressman Dennis Moore (D-Kansas) http://www.moore.house.gov/ Congressman Earl Pomeroy (D-North Dakota) http://www.pomeroy.house.gov/ Congressman Mike Ross (D-Arkansas) http://ross.house.gov/ Congressman Zack Space (D-Ohio) http://space.house.gov/ Congressman John Tanner (D-Tennessee) http://www.house.gov/tanner/
Heath Shuler and Chris Carney did their usual Bush enabling. I will have more soon on the amazing victory this vote represents. Democrats do not and have not stood up to Bush and the right-wing on national security, ever. Only this time, they did. And it looks like it might just become a habit. Immediately after the vote, a slew of Democrats running for office issued statements on the vote and at least one referenced Bill Foster's victory. There's nothing stronger in politics than running on an issue, and that's what is happening right now.
Congratulations to all involved. And to the 400 people who gave some cash to Bill Foster, and to the many others who volunteered to get him elected, kudos to you. Elections have consequences.
A thistle to U.S. Rep. Leonard Boswell for sending a campaign brochure to residents of the 3rd District and billing taxpayers for the expense. The slick mailer complete with full-color pictures crows about Boswell's accomplishments in big type, but you have to read the fine print to learn that the mailing "was prepared, published, and mailed at taxpayer expense." There is a fine line between using the congressional franking privilege for legitimate constituent communication and overt political campaigning. This one crashes across that line, coming as it does as Boswell faces a serious opponent in the Democratic primary this year.
Apparently that's what Boswell uses taxpayer dollars for. He certainly doesn't use his position to pass legislation. I just received this Democracy for America press release over email.
Since first being elected to Congress in 1996, Boswell has only managed to get 2 bills out of committee and enacted into law. 2 bills in 12 years; the change Iowa need in Washington is not going to happen with Leonard Boswell...
While Rep. Boswell has not been introducing legislation, he has been voting for a host of unsound and unpopular Bush policies. He voted for the War in Iraq and has voted for each and every one of the President's bills to fund it. He voted for the Patriot Act and has been a champion of retroactive immunity for the telecommunications companies that participated in the President's program of warrantless wiretapping.
And, he has done this while collecting boatloads of cash from Washington PACs and lobbyists. In fact, 74% of his campaign contributions have come from the political action committees of companies like AT&T; and Wal-Mart.
Bowell is one of 21 Bush Dog Democrats to sign the letter pushing for retroactive immunity to the telecoms after accepting money from telecom PACs, though he apparently believes that his can be obviated by his cosponsorship of a resolution to impeach Dick Cheney (it didn't work for Al Wynn). Boswell is a recipient of money from the American Bankers Association, the group spearheading the fight against mortgage relief. And he is defending his vote for the Bankruptcy Bill in 2005.
I've spent some time watching Boswell on TV and reading through his site, and he reminds me of most reactionary incumbents I've seen: mean and entitled.
The plan of the House leadership is to pass this specific bill in the House, send it to the Senate (where telecom immunity will be added in by the same bipartisan Senate faction that already voted for immunity), have it go back to the House for an up-or-down-vote on the House-bill-plus-telecom-immunity (which will pass with the support of the Blue Dogs), and then compliantly sent on to a happy and satisfied President, who will sign the bill that he demanded.
So that's the plan for now. I'm pleased that both Obama and Clinton have chosen to make their case for President based on stupid identity politics instead of fighting on core Constitutional issues like this.
A major mortgage relief measure before Congress just went down to defeat in the Senate.
The banking industry and President Bush opposed the bill, which would have allowed bankruptcy judges to reduce a filer's mortgage debt to the home's current market value.
At least a dozen industry associations have banded together to fight the proposed legislation. They include the American Bankers Association, the Financial Services Roundtable, the Consumer Bankers Association and the Mortgage Bankers Association. These groups and others have signed joint letters to lawmakers on the issue.
Let's just take the American Bankers Association and their contributions this year, and you'll see a pretty even split in terms of parties. Sure, lots of Republicans are on there, and yes, it's Republicans in the Senate who are killing the measure. But legislation is chess, and there are lots of ways to make changes that aren't in the public eye. The ABA also gives to lots of Democrats, but mostly it's leadership and, of course, Bush Dogs, including Melissa Bean, Leonard Boswell, Alan Boyd, Heath Shuler, the Indiana boys, etc. You'll also see Nancy Pelosi, Steny Hoyer, Rahm Emanuel, Debbie Wasserman-Schultz, and James Clyburn on there.
It's fascinating how there are so few progressive members on the list of ABA cash recipients. Weird. The House is likely to make noises about fighting for mortgage relief, but it's not clear that it will be anything more than a half-hearted attempt.
Let's note this going forward. And yes, Ed Fallon should start making noise about the $10K Boswell has already received from these very bad people.
Here's Leonard Boswell, conservative Democrat in Iowa, criticizing his liberal primary challenger, Ed Fallon.
Fallon has said that while Boswell has performed admirably at times, he has sided too much with Bush, a Republican, and has no absolute right to his seat. Asked about this, Boswell said Fallon was unpopular among state lawmakers and at times a lone "no" vote among Democrats on issues. Boswell aides said the congressman has sided with the Democratic Party line 90 percent of the time, often opposing Bush.
You periodically get hints of what is really motivating our political leadership. A lot of people think it's just money or greed, and there's some truth in that, as money and greed influence everyone (not just politicians). But we shouldn't ignore the culture of politics, the fact that politicians go to an office every day, have cliques, and like and dislike each other. None of this really matters to voters, but politicians who are out of touch think that it does.
And so Boswell is saying that Fallon wasn't well-liked and often was a lonely 'no' vote. That could be criticism or praise, depending on whether voters like the political system at the moment. But to Boswell, this is damning. Fallon is willing to rock the boat and annoy lots of other political figures, and that's apparently quite damning.