If the fundamental problem is the legislation itself, there is a dire secondary problem in the lack of public information about legislation as it gets processed by the Congress.
And HHS has been signing loadsa waivers from annual limit restrictions in the health care act.
Next, waivers from the miminum medical loss ratio provision, once the regulations have been put in place.
Currently, we rely on the chance interest of journos or bloggers to unearth nasty stuff in bills. Mostly, even when they are unearthed, they get enacted in one form or another.
And this stuff is technical off the chart - though not too technical for AHIP and the other lobbies, natch.
And, of course, the lobbies and the pols rely on the technicalities and complications to get the nasties through without a public fuss.
A proper intelligence system for the Congressional legislative process would be expensive - a fair number of core staff tapping into a range of experts - and would not be a ratings winner.
But, relative to the dough spent on the election? Chickenfeed.
Harry held pro forma sessions to stop Bush using recess apppointments; he and Mitch have agreed to do the same for Obama and his huge backlog.
Otherwise, the backlog of pending noms would have to start over in the 112th; noms can be carried over from one Congress to the next with unanimous consent, apparently, and the pro forma sessions are Mitch's price for GOP support for the UCA.
What's the record for time served on Nomination Row, I wonder?
But Obama can unilaterally - without the intervention of the Party of No! - suspend the operation of this provision under 10 USC 12305 - the stop loss provision. (See this PDF.)
So the opposition of the Party of No is clearly not what is holding him back.
Same for JFK and what eventually became his EO 11063, desegregating new Federally funded housing. He could have issued the EO on Day 1, but wanted to stroke the Southern gatekeepers of the Congress. (Not that that did him much good, of course.)
In the event, it came on November 20 1962.
Back to Obama: shows how useful the Congress is to him - another thing he and his (and their) corporate sponsors have in common.
However, the funding includes $2bn taken from SNAP (food stamps to you).
Which, given the recent stats on the hike in the poverty rate doesn't seem quite right.
Worse
This follows an even larger reduction in SNAP funding -- over $10 billion -- imposed to help cover other, unrelated expenses in the federal budget.
The old Reverse Robin Hood still in full working order! (What did that $10bn go on, I wonder?)
There is a House Bill (HR 5504) which contains S 3307 without the SNAP cuts - but that's gone nowhere so far, and it looks as if the House will pass S 3307 by the end of the month.
There's no doubting that, when they feel like it, the current Administration have a certain way with words when characterizing its supporters; like Robert Gibbs' professional left.
Or Rahmbo's choice fucking stupid.
Both of those petites phrases provoked a furious reaction from the lefty sphere.
Blessed is he who expects nothing; for he is seldom disappointed.
That's my favorite Beatitude - for being so widely applicable. Never more so than as observer of the Obama first (and only?) term.
We have come to know (as if we doubted it going in) that Washington Dems are corporate to their fingertips - and not because they're dumb or cowardly, but because they figure that's how it suits them best.
The idea that a Howard Beale moment is a-bubbling does, to put it mildly, lack supporting evidence. Chances have come and gone (cutting off folks' unemployment?).
Since the amendment is already in the bill, it will take only a simple majority to defeat any amendments (via a motion to table). Apparently, McCain is threatening a filibuster if such amendments fail.
The bill is, of course, full of goodies for the MIC - CRS report and the pressure to pass the bill therefore considerable.
(Defense is the only main area of spending which gets an annual authorization bill - I'm not clear whether passing the bill in the 111th is essential, but I can't see the proposition as attractive to Dem mods; and, if it were postponed, in the 112th, with a much closer Dem-GOP situation, Burris would stand no chance.)
The inter-house dynamics are interesting, too: apparently, antiabortionist HASC chairman Skelton was a leading opponent the last time a Burris amendment came up in 2006.
Not holding my breath, but - who knows? Fairy tales can come true, it can happen to you...
An industry like mining knows that it's going to get regulated. Politically impossible not to (even in West Virginia!).
So it needs an MO: embrace the regulators warmly in a bear hug that ensures they can't do a hand's turn against it.
That way, regulation is actually a plus for the industry: voters think the situation is under control, pols don't come under pressure to act - and, when a bad story breaks (as with Upper Big Branch accident), there is a weakened investigatory organization in place to which pols will gladly hand over responsibility.
According to The Hill,
Massey Energy, the company that operates Upper Big Branch, was able to keep the Mine Safety and Health Administration at bay by regularly appealing safety violations.
Since 2005, Massey has gone to the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission 89 times to dispute safety violations that federal inspectors found at Upper Big Branch, according to an official at the commission.
The litigation stalled many of the findings of safety violations and prevented the Mine Safety and Health Commission from finding a "pattern of violation" that would have enabled them to exercise more oversight.
The WH has is at least been on the case, with funding in place to increase the number of administrative judges from 10 to 14 and in the 2011 WH budget for another four.
However,
The backlog of cases has soared from 2,100 in 2006 to 16,600 today, delaying the implementation of penalties for any safety violations mining companies choose to dispute.
So Massey clearly hasn't been the only one!
Why the spurt since 2006? Perhaps it was just a preemptive strike, to show that they could turn the spigot on enough to stymie any administrative action.
I'm not clear whether amendments to the regulatory regime could deal with the problem - though I doubt whether the current law takes it to the wire, constitutionally speaking.
But there's clearly no chance of meaningful amendments any decade soon.
Blog sources
Coal Tattoo covers the WV coal industry; more from WV Blue.
An industry like mining knows that it's going to get regulated. Politically impossible not to (even in West Virginia!).
So it needs an MO: embrace the regulators warmly in a bear hug that ensures they can't do a hand's turn against it.
That way, regulation is actually a plus for the industry: voters think the situation is under control, pols don't come under pressure to act - and, when a bad story breaks (as with Upper Big Branch accident), there is a weakened investigatory organization in place to which pols will gladly hand over responsibility.
According to The Hill,
Massey Energy, the company that operates Upper Big Branch, was able to keep the Mine Safety and Health Administration at bay by regularly appealing safety violations.
Since 2005, Massey has gone to the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission 89 times to dispute safety violations that federal inspectors found at Upper Big Branch, according to an official at the commission.
The litigation stalled many of the findings of safety violations and prevented the Mine Safety and Health Commission from finding a "pattern of violation" that would have enabled them to exercise more oversight.
The WH has is at least been on the case, with funding in place to increase the number of administrative judges from 10 to 14 and in the 2011 WH budget for another four.
However,
The backlog of cases has soared from 2,100 in 2006 to 16,600 today, delaying the implementation of penalties for any safety violations mining companies choose to dispute.
So Massey clearly hasn't been the only one!
Why the spurt since 2006? Perhaps it was just a preemptive strike, to show that they could turn the spigot on enough to stymie any administrative action.
I'm not clear whether amendments to the regulatory regime could deal with the problem - though I doubt whether the current law takes it to the wire, constitutionally speaking.
But there's clearly no chance of meaningful amendments any decade soon.
One thing I've been struck by in the whole health care thing has been the fog in which the Masters of the Universe succeded in shrouding whatever version of the legislation was under consideration at the time.
Everyone was a 'low info voter' with health care - however hard the interested layman tried, he was defeated by the technical complexity and the lack of a walk-through by a knowledgeable soul willing to share his knowledge - and I mean every section, and explaining how those awkward tricksy Interests-goosing provisions work. (As if that was ever likely to happen...)
So we're left with the political win for Obama and the suggestions (commands?) from leading lefty spheroids that we should rejoice thereat, and generally take a Panglossian view of the whole thing. (Certainly, I've not seen any lefty cheerleaders actually take us through the detail of the reforms as enacted - which may be because they don't understand said detail, or because it doesn't bear too great a scrutiny from anyone seeking to keep the faith with the prez.)
But the facts always count. And - usually - you've got them wrong. Not through any fault, or malicious intent. You're just underinformed. And you get a jolt when you find you are.
As witness: the famous number Strange Fruit, popularized by Billy Holliday, was, I'm told by Wikipedia, inspired by a photo of the 1930 lynching of Thomas Schipp and Abram Smith.
The first line of the lyrics is Southern trees bear strange fruit - yet Schipp and Smith were lynched in Marion IN! Which is in the middle of Indiana which itself is separated from the Deep South by a full two states (KY and TN).
Now, by 1930, the classic church picnic-style lynching was going out of style, even in the deep South. So perhaps Schipp/Smith was the last such lynching in the North. (Yay, North!)
Yet I'd never heard of it before - let alone in connection with the iconic song it inspired.
(Ironically, later in the 30s, IN's Senator Van Nuys was one of the prime movers of antilynching legislation - FDR took a strictly Tammany view of such Proggery!)
In a letter sent to Speaker Pelosi, Representatives Woolsey and Grijalva stated that most of the 77-member progressive caucus will not support a health care plan that lacks a public option with a level playing field.
Gets the lefty juices flowing, don't it?
We have polled CPC Members and a strong majority will not support legislation that does not include a public plan option that is supported on a level playing field with private health insurance plans.
And you can take that to the bank!
Naturally, we're talking prehistory: April 2 2009, in fact. (Just a day late, you might say.)
Since then, a lot of Prog hands have got numb from being sat on for months at time.
And (as I recall) there's been a series of letters from Progs - a variety of numbers, a variety of formulations that make one think of poor old Joe McCarthy and the State Department. Credibility is somewhat below ground level.
Of course, there is still time for enough below-ground worms to turn to fulfill the Prog's promise of last April (with a little help from some Stupak's, it's possible).
But I doubt whether there'll be much inclination to celebrate.
Plausible (let alone, accurate) information about the mechanics of the Big Push to pass health care has been thin on the ground.
One plausible shenanigan is that there will be no direct House vote on the Senate Bill HR 3962 at all.
How? The rule governing the sidecar will include a provision that, if the sidecar passes, HR 3962 will be deemed to have passed.
I'm not sure what the precise wording would be; but that sort of 'self-executing' rule is quite usual (though it usually applies to elements of the bill to which the rule relates, not some other bill entirely.
Perhaps this is the wave of the future: you take a shell bill, Rules reports out a rule deeming all sorts of embarrassing legislation to have passed on passage of the shell bill - and there are no nasty roll call fingerprints to identify the guilty parties.
Beyond the sheerly political mush of Health Care 09/10, there's the mush on the Congressional rules which govern the legislation. And, natch, both mushes get mushed together.
You can understand that our friends on the Hill may simply view this as a necessary condition of warfare: drawing bright lines can only help the Enemy, etc.
They might, in turn, understand (but probably don't give a damn) that outsiders doubt (based, in my case, on 5+ years of observation) that the insiders (on our side, at least) have a proper grasp of the rules.
This is of particular concern on health care, where we have a perfect storm brewing: a vital bill for the Dems, intertia in Congress, a tricky (not to say, tricksy) weapon to be wielded to unblock the bill's passage, dire consequences of failure.
This is a situation which the current leadership have sedulously avoided in those 5+ years; they have taken the view (with great justice!) that their troops aren't up to pulling off that kind of coordinated series of precision shenanigans.
Now, they're committed.
Let's take a couple of points on the rules governing reconciliation:
First, is the motion to proceed to the motion to appoint conferees debatable (and hence subject to filibuster)?
The Congressional Budget Act doesn't deal with the point, that I can see; The Hill says
The parliamentarian has ruled that the limit on debate does not allow senators to filibuster the motion to proceed to a reconciliation bill.
I haven't nailed it down; but Riddick's says that it's a general rule that the motion to proceed conference reports is nondebatable, and passes on a simple majority (p472)!
Second: during Senate floor proceedings on a reconciliation bill, can amendments be ruled out of order as being dilatory?
Apparently, the GOP Alamo is to mass-produce amendments to prolong the vote-a-rama till the Last Trump. There is provision in the rules to rule non-germane amendments out of order, but no similar provision for dilatory amendments.
Of course, the cloture rule covers dilatory amendments - but (for reasons that escape me) not the rules relating to reconciliation.
Now, as we know, Generalissimo Joe can rule which ever way he chooses on points of order, and, if, on appeal, a simple majority of the Senate backs him up, that settles the issue. If Biden pulls a dilatory amendment rule from his ass, that's fine.
The appeal is (so far as I can see) debatable; but the time taken comes out of the 20 hours. However, given the volume of GOP amendments to be expected, what happens when the 20 hours has run out? Can Biden just rule all the remaining GOP amendments out of order as dilatory (or non-germane), with no possibility of appeal, because the 20 hours has expired? Or is he even allowed to rule on amendments - again, because time has run out?
Great to see Senate Dems raising the flag for good, old-fashioned political values.
All too often, lefty blogs would give you the impression that Dem senators are a pretty wishy-washy lot, afraid to wipe their own noses for fear of offending some interest group or other.
Not the Carbon Eight, though:
Eight Senate Democrats jointly said Friday that they fear the economic effects of planned EPA global warming rules...
The Democrats, who hail mostly from coal-producing and coal-reliant states, said in a letter to the EPA that they have "serious economic and energy security concerns" about rules to limit greenhouse gases from power plants and other stationary sources.
And the identity of these fine representatives of 19th century values:
Sen. Jay Rockefeller (W.Va.) spearheaded the letter, which was also signed by Sens. Max Baucus (Mont.), Sherrod Brown (Ohio), Mark Begich (Alaska), Robert Byrd (W.Va.), Robert Casey (Penn.), Claire McCaskill (Mo.) and Carl Levin (Mich.).
Just a note to self that Bush's greatest domestic legacy is currently intact.
The legatees of a billionaire (or anyone else) who dies right now collect their dough entirely free of estate tax.
Thought was, there'd be a fix - but no dice.
But - wild pitch - the downside is that the stepup in basis that applied to legacy back in the estate tax era no longer applies. Which can be a nightmare for estates well shy of the billionaire category. (Because, when they sell the assets they receive, the legatees will pay income tax on the gain based on its cost to the deceased, not (as before) the value of the asset at the time of his death.)
Would a retrospective fix (the tax expired on 31 December) be constitutional? Can any sort of fix pass the Senate? (The House passed a fix last year.)
Plus - how many more of these festering sores are there that the Dems (Congressional and WH) have failed to deal with?
There's a definite head of steam (no small thanks to Chris) behind passing the healthcare sidecar bill via reconciliation.
And the political will to do the thing is, naturally, a sine qua non to it happening.
However, in tandem with the lobbying process, it's as well to consider the difficulties - an interreacting mix of the procedural and the political - in getting it done.
For starters, it's the sort of complex series of shenanigans which we've never seen Harry attempt, never mind see through to success. It requires not only will on behalf of both party and leadership, but coordinated technical expertise wielded skillfully on the floor and off.
I can't remember the last time anything so complicated was brought off: I'd say it would every bit as complex as Johnson passing the 1957 Civil Rights Bill.
On the other side - the GOP are bound to look on the very use of reconciliation as legitimising massive resistance (to coin a phrase).
I'm pretty sure that the Interests would be happy to see the Senate bill enacted; and the GOP took care (by going along with unanimous consent agreements) not to get in the way of it passing the Senate.
But the Interests would recognize that the Dems going for reconciliation would be a partisan challenge that the GOP could not pass up: it fits to a T their metanarrative of holding the Alamo against the Washington Establishment (to mix a metaphor or two).
Whatever opportunities to cause mischief will be taken; pressure on must-pass and marquee legislation (reduced floor time this pre-election session) will be maximized; the Dem leadership's will and expertise will be tested at every turn.
Fox and friends will be crying coup d'état - or some English equivalent. The flabbiest WH spokesmen will be invited on cable to defend the process, with a view to driving wedges within the WH and between the WH and the Senate. (Sebelius, for instance - pretty flabby on Maddow, for instance.) The vacillation of the WH on health care in general and the public option in particular suggests it could get ugly pretty soon.
Then, there are the rules. I'd be fairly certain that getting the sidecar within the boundaries of the Byrd Rule is going to be tricky - certainly, every element in the sidecar needs the most careful consideration from the Byrd viewpoint.
The Parliamentarian will be helpful in giving Harry and Co help in threading the needle - but the chance that he will balk at some key provision must be significant. And that provision is probably the quo for some quid elsewhere in the bill.
Practice is that the chair, whose responsibility it is to rule on compliance with the Byrd Rule, abides by the Parliamentarian's decision in every case. But the law (§904(d) of the Congressional Budget Act) says that it's the chair's decision.
Are the Dems prepared to have the chair go against the Parliamentarian if necessary? If not, best not start the whole thing.
(It takes 60 votes to overturn the chair's ruling, by the way.)
How likely is that Dem senators will get cold feet in the face of such an exercise of raw power?
Meanwhile, the GOP will be looking for every opportunity to filibuster - every motion to proceed, for instance.
And, if the bill escapes the Byrd Rule trap, there'll be dozens (hundreds?) of amendments in the vote-a-rama.
(Unlike cloture, every unvoted amendment gets its vote, thus potentially extending the floor debate indefinitely.)
All during this process, GOP morale will be sky-high. And, natch, they'll be getting the teabaggers doing their thing at maximum decibels.
In common with the massed ranks of the lefty sphere, I'd love to see the Senate Dems finally throw down, after years of whining and cringing. But they'd better make sure they're in shape for the long battle ahead.
JTA...
What's with the pre-summit WH bill? Supposedly, Congressional Dems haven't seen it - doesn't mean they don't know what's in it, of course - or agreed it.
Is it a sidecar bill, or does it start from scratch (the GOP proposal, of course!)? Looks like the latter, from the piece, quoting Sebelius. Talking points for the summit? (Easy to get the discussion bogged down in drafting - perhaps that's the purpose.)
Why the WH should roll out a bill at this stage (presumably WH staff have been working on a text for ages), I'm not sure.
Plus - I'm not sure how they set up the bill as a reconciliation measure (this question applies to the sidecar as well).