The Box McCain is In

by: Mike Lux

Wed Oct 22, 2008 at 15:05



Chris Bowers wrote two posts (here and here) this morning which do a terrific job of analyzing why McCain is targeting Pennsylvania and making other Electoral College decisions. The McCain campaign is truly in a box, and their range of options are narrowing.
Mike Lux :: The Box McCain is In
I would continue targeting PA were I in the McCain campaign as well. In addition to the early voting reason Chris mentioned, I would add the following: it's been a relatively competitive state in big electoral landslides. It's got one of the oldest populations in the country, and one of the most blue-collar, so if there's any kind of last-minute swing back among those swing demographics, McCain will be back in the game. Finally, if they pull out of Pennsylvania after already folding in Michigan, Wisconsin and other swing states, it really allows the Obama campaign huge options in terms of its already big margin regarding targeted-state resource allocation.

The big questions in my mind regarding McCain are what he's planning in terms of Colorado and Virginia. I was stunned to hear that McCain is backing off in any degree in terms of media spending in Colorado- it makes no sense to me given the historic Republican tendencies there, and especially given that Colorado is one of the few states in the country where the Republicans seem to be holding their own in early voting. Furthermore, unless the long-shot bid to come back in Pennsylvania works, he absolutely has to win both Colorado and Virginia.

Speaking of Virginia, the numbers there look remarkably stable, and remarkably good, for Obama. That is really good news, especially given Chris' point regarding early voting starting there so early. I still don't believe it is a lock, because there is plenty of volatility in Virginia, but it sure is moving closer and closer to being done.

Above and beyond the tight box McCain finds himself in regarding the Electoral College myth, there's another big box he finds himself in: he has run out of message options, too. He's in too deep a hole to win this race without taking Obama down a notch or two, but his over-the-top sleazy attacks are so ridiculous that most voters are tuning them out. And his attacks about socialism and spreading the wealth just aren't selling with an American public that has rejected conservative Republican arguments on economics.

Elections are never over until they are over, because any big event can change the dynamics. Voter suppression still a big problem, and so is the threat actual vote-stealing. I will go to the last day of this election (and probably to my grave, in whatever election cycle that may be) saying we should not take victory for granted. But having said my usual piece on all that, this is also clear: John McCain sure is in a world of hurt.

Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
The Box McCain is In | 6 comments
stealing (0.00 / 0)
I'm worried about voter suppression, too, but it's hard to steal a race that isn't close.  And this race isn't.

Yeah, but... (4.00 / 1)
As Obama said a couple of days ago, "Remember New Hampshire" and "don't get too cocky".

[ Parent ]
It's simple, I think (0.00 / 0)
McCain is playing-to-win in Pennsylvania because his campaign cannot afford to demoralize folks further by pulling out or cutting back.  So as long as they're in it, they've got to try to win.  

There are two statewide elections in PA I can remember that swang dramatically late in the game: the 2004 Specter-Toomey primary went from a 15-point Specter lead to a dead-heat Specter win in three weeks -- though that was a closed primary -- and the 1986 gubernatorial race, in which Bob Casey Sr. edged out Bill Scranton on the basis of a last-minute tv ad (not aired in Phila/Pgh, to avoid backlash) tying his Republican opponent to the Maharishi Yogi and TM.


A Bottomless Box (4.00 / 2)
he has run out of message options, too. He's in too deep a hole to win this race without taking Obama down a notch or two, but his over-the-top sleazy attacks are so ridiculous that most voters are tuning them out.

Kos had a very good little roundup this morning of poll comparisons showing how little Obama's favorables have changed since early this year, mostly inching up.

Let's look at those numbers in polls that asked for Obama's Favorable/Unfavorable numbers from the beginning of the year, when this campaign began:

CNN:
1/9-10:   55/28
10/17-19: 62/35

CBS:
2/20-24:  45/23
10/17-19: 53/33

ABC/WaPo:
1/9-12:   63/30
10/8-11:  64/33

Newsweek
3/5-6:    61/28
10/8-9:   60/36

Gallup:
1/10-13:  59/32
10/3-5:   62/34



"Senate passes expanded GI bill despite Bush, McCain opposition"

Geezer think (0.00 / 0)
PA has an interesting stealth component to it, New Jersey.  The ads in the Philly area will spill over into south and parts of central NJ.  The large undecided vote here (10%) can be interpreted many ways.  Is it a huge Bradley effect?  Voters disgusted with both candidates who may stay home or leave the Presidential line blank, or a true undecided.  

If McCain looks at the election from his youth and middle age, both NJ and PA were reliably Republican (from 1948 through 1988).  JFK barely won NJ by less than 1% point and LBJ carried everything.  Throwing out the last 20 years is dangerous but if he wants hope .... All along, I felt McCain's chances hinged on taking two out of three of PA, NJ and MI.  They still do.


my prediction (0.00 / 0)
obama 286, mccain 252
obama 52% mccain 47%
http://the-independent13.blogs...

The Box McCain is In | 6 comments

Donate to Open Left
ELECTION 2008 Presidential Forecast
Senate Forecast
House Forecast
PREMIUM AD

ADVERTISEMENTS



MENU

OpenLeft in your inbox!

 

Or, subscribe to each author individually.

OPTIMIZE MCCAIN About
Tips
McCain
John McCain
QUICK HITS
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

OPENLEFT VIDEO WALL
Donna Edwards Thanks OpenLeft


Russ Feingold on the New FISA Legislation


Jon Conyers on Impeachment


Al Franken Thanks Blue Majority


FCC Commissioner Michael Copps on Pearl Jam, Net Neutrality


Darcy Burner on the FISA Legislation

More OpenLeft video...