Presidential Forecast, August 6th: Is This The Best McCain Can Do?

by: Chris Bowers

Wed Aug 06, 2008 at 14:15



Electoral College: Obama 264, McCain 172, Toss-up 102 (270 to win)
National popular vote: Obama 46.1%-43.8% McCain


(Dark Blue (236): Obama +8.0% or more
Lean Blue (28): Obama +3.0%-+7.9%
White / Toss-up (102): Obama +2.9% to McCain +2.9%
Lean Red (76): McCain +3.0%-+7.9%
Dark Red (96): McCain +8.0% or more
)

New polls from Alabama, Arizona, Connecticut, Florida (2), Massachusetts and Washington show little change. Even though the map doesn’t show it, Arizona moves from “lean McCain” to solid McCain.” (I’ll fix the map later–not in a position to do so right now.) Also, even though the state is still technically a statistical toss-up, McCain has regained a narrow lead in Florida. Over the past week, Obama had a narrow, statistically insignificant lead in the state. In national polling, the campaign continues to hover between a statistical toss-up and a statistically significant lead for Obama.

Swing State Overview (270 to win, 269 to tie)
State EV’s Obama % McCain % Margin Obama Total
Obama Base 243 243
Michigan 17 45.5% 41.3% +4.2% 260
New Hampshire 4 45.5% 42.5% +3.0% 264
Virginia 13 46.8% 44.8% +2.0% 277
Colorado 9 45.3% 43.5% +1.8% 286
Ohio 20 45.4% 44.0% +1.4% 306
Nevada 5 42.3% 43.0% -0.7% 311
North Dakota 3 42.3% 43.5% -1.2% 314
Florida 27 46.8% 46.3% -2.0% 341
Indiana 11 43.3% 45.3% -2.0% 352
Missouri 11 43.8% 45.4% -2.0% 363
Montana 3 43.3% 46.0% -2.2% 366
North Carolina 15 43.5% 47.0% -3.6% 381

If this is as bad as the McCain barrage can get, then Obama should be in a strong position. McCain’s best shot still has yet to put him in a statistically insignificant lead nationally, or at a statistically significant lead in states worth 200 electoral votes. I except Obama to gain in polls over the next week, relative to the current standings. From that point, we will have VP picks and the conventions to change and / or define the campaign. This barrage by McCain appears to simply have not been enough.

State by state details in the extended entry.  

Chris Bowers :: Presidential Forecast, August 6th: Is This The Best McCain Can Do?
Solid Obama: 236 Electoral Votes
State EV’s Obama % McCain % Margin # Polls
California 55 52.8% 36.3% +15.5% 4
Connecticut 7 54.5% 36.3% +18.2% 4
Delaware 3 50.0% 41.0% +9.0% 1
D.C. 3 — — +80.0% 0
Hawaii 4 61.0% 31.0% +30.0% 1
Illinois 21 55.5% 35.3% +20.2% 4
Maine-AL* 2 50.3% 36.0% +14.3% 4
Maine-01* 1 — — +17.5% 0
Maine-02* 1 — — +11.1% 0
Maryland 10 51.5% 37.3% +14.2% 4
Massachusetts 12 51.8% 35.0% +16.8% 4
Minnesota 10 48.3% 40.3% +8.8% 4
New Mexico 5 48.5% 40.3% +8.2% 4
New Jersey 15 47.8% 36.4% +11.4% 5
New York 31 52.4% 31.8% +20.6% 5
Oregon 7 48.0% 39.0% +9.0% 4
Pennsylvania 21 48.8% 40.8% +8.0% 4
Rhode Island 4 50.8% 31.0% +19.8% 4
Vermont 3 60.0% 32.5% +27.5% 2
Washington 11 50.3% 39.0% +11.3% 4
Wisconsin 10 50.0% 39.8% +10.3% 4

Lean Obama: 28 Electoral Votes
State EV’s Obama % McCain % Margin # Polls
Iowa 7 46.0% 39.8% +6.2% 4
Michigan 17 45.5% 41.3% +4.2% 4
New Hampshire 4 45.5% 42.5% +3.0% 4

Toss-up: 102 Electoral Votes
State EV’s Obama % McCain % Margin # Polls
Colorado 9 45.3% 43.5% +1.8% 4
Florida 27 44.7% 46.7% -2.0% 6
Indiana 11 43.3% 45.3% -2.0% 4
Missouri 11 44.5% 46.5% -2.0% 4
Montana 3 44.3% 46.5% -2.2% 4
Nevada 5 42.3% 43.0% -0.7% 4
North Dakota 3 42.3% 43.5% -1.2% 4
Ohio 20 45.4% 44.0% +1.4% 5
Virginia 13 46.8% 44.8% +2.0% 4

Lean McCain: 86 Electoral Votes
State EV’s Obama % McCain % Margin # Polls
Alaska 3 42.3% 48.8% -6.5% 4
Georgia 15 41.8% 48.5% -6.7% 4
Nebraska-02** 1 — — -7.0% 0
North Carolina 15 43.4% 47.0% -3.6% 5
South Carolina 8 40.0% 46.8% -6.8% 4
Texas 34 39.3% 45.8% -6.5% 4

Solid McCain: 86 Electoral Votes
State EV’s Obama % McCain % Margin # Polls
Alabama 9 35.5% 51.3% -15.8% 4
Arizona 10 37.0% 46.5% -9.5% 4
Arkansas 6 38.0% 49.0% -11.0% 4
Idaho 4 38.0% 52.5% -14.5% 2
Kansas 6 36.8% 51.0% -14.2% 4
Kentucky 8 38.0% 50.8% -12.8% 4
Louisiana 9 38.5% 51.3% -12.8% 4
Mississippi 6 43.0% 51.3% -8.3% 4
Nebraska-AL** 2 35.3% 53.3% -18.0% 4
Nebraska-01** 1 — — -12.0% 0
Nebraska-03** 1 — — -36.0% 0
Oklahoma 7 30.0% 53.0% -23.0% 4
South Dakota 3 38.8% 47.5% -8.7% 3
Tennessee 11 34.8% 50.8% -16.0% 4
Utah 5 32.0% 55.3% -23.3% 4
West Virginia 5 36.0% 49.0% -13.0% 2
Wyoming 3 37.5% 53.5% -16.0% 2

* Maine four electoral votes are awarded as follows: two for the statewide winner, and one for the winner of each congressional district. ME-01 is about 3.5% more Democratic than the state as a whole, while ME-02 is about 3.5% less Democratic than the state as a whole.

** Nebraska’s five electoral votes are awarded as follows: two for the statewide winner, and one for the winner of each congressional district. NE-01 is about 6.0% more Democratic than the state as a whole, NE-02 is about 11.0% more Democratic than the state as a whole, and NE-03 is about 18.0% less Democratic than the state as a whole.

Methodology
I will update at least once every day between now and November 4th. The methodology is simple and straightforward.

  1. For each state, take the last four polls conducted for the state, and average them.
  2. If more than four polls were conducted in the state over the previous thirty days, all polls conducted during that time period are included in the averages.
  3. If polling dates overlap, and make it difficult to determine which polls were the four most recent, include all of the overlapping polls.
  4. No polling firm discrimination whatsoever. Polls are never excluded because the organization has a bad or partisan reputation. Also, if a polling firm has conducted more than one of the most recent four polls, all of the polls from that organization are included.

As we move closer to the election and more data becomes available, both the time frames for polls included in the averages will decrease and the definition of a “solid” lead will eventually drop to 7.0%.  

');
Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
I also wonder if McCain is short of cash (0.00 / 0)
As per the Hotline referenced Quick Hit.

 
Obama will go down in polls first… (0.00 / 0)
At least, I think he will.. before he starts to track upwards again.

 
Yeah generally I think the state polls won't start to show… (0.00 / 0)
…a true picture until both conventions are done and dusted.

[ Parent ]  
I don't think Florida and Missouri (4.00 / 1)
are tossups – I would rate both as leaning McCain.  That gets McCain to 210.  

I agree with pretty much everything else.  Obama’s strength in Pennsylvania and in the Dukakis states makes this map fundementally different from the map Kerry or even Gore had.  Obama has multiple ways of winning (win either Ohio, Va, Indiana, Colorado, or NV and Montana, or Montana and North Dakota).  

A couple of weeks ago I posted a prediction of the electoral college, which was 284 – 254.  I am going to wait for some August data, but the model using Jyly numbers has it Obama 280, McCain 254 (New Hampshire is the reason for the chance).  Obama wins everything Kerry but New Hampshire and wins Iowa, New Mexico, and Ohio.  He loses New Hampshire by .2%, Nevada by .9%, Colorado by 1.5% and Florida by 4%.  He loses VA and Missouri by 5.

He wins Ohio 50.6 to 49.4.  


 
just out of curiosity… (0.00 / 0)
Do people really think that Obama is going to end up winning PA by anywhere close to 8%?  

 
it's possible (0.00 / 0)
Rendell won by 20%.  McCain’s numbers are the same as Swann’s were in August. The Democratic voter registration advantage is 7%.  I’ll bet McCain will write off the state by October, since he can win without it.  No, I’m not predicting a 20 point win, but I think 8 points is possible.



New Jersey politics at Blue Jersey.


[ Parent ]  
So do I (0.00 / 0)
Gore won it by 5 with a virtual tie in the popular vote.

[ Parent ]  
swing state overview is fantastic – thanks (0.00 / 0)
Polls may show it as close but VA will go blue. Polls have trouble predicting black turnout which I expect to be substantial. Voter registration is underway as well as phone banking from MD and DC. Remember the support he saw in the Chesapeake primary?

I guarantee dem turn out for this region will surpass expectations. Plus there is almost no blue collar controversy in VA like in Ohio and Indiana. Its going to be a party line election and we will have more voters at the polls.


 
Obama will win Colorado (0.00 / 0)
The Democratic Convention will be the biggest thing in this state since the Rockies playoff run last year — absent a game changing gaffe, the halo effect of all that free publicity will win Colorado for Obama.

 
Obama will win Colorado … Maybe (0.00 / 0)
I’m not feeling the love in Colorado for Big O unless he gets the energy issue stabilized. Not saying he needs to go exploring for shale, but I sense the energy issue is taking a toll out here.

Also, Peter Boyles is kicking the crap out of the dems on his morning radio show for how the funding and labor at The Can has been less than clean/clear.

Factor in the near panic the Denver Police have of a Seattle WTO type demonstration, things aren’t all peaches ‘n cream.

BUT!!!!

I live in Highlands Ranch and 4 years ago just about EVERY CAR had an oval W sticker. So far I have not seen a single McNumnuts sticker and I’ve seen quite a number of Obama stickers.

Whatever that’s worth…


Maverick – An unbranded range animal, especially a calf that has become separated from its mother, traditionally considered the property of the first person who brands it.


[ Parent ]  
most important states (0.00 / 0)
According to election-projection.net, the most important state for both candidates is Ohio.

If Obama loses:      Next most important state for Obama
—————      ———————————–
Ohio                 Virginia
Virginia + above     Florida
Florida + above      Michigan
Michigan + above     Indiana
Indiana + above      Missouri
Missouri + above     N. Carolina
N. Carolina + above  Georgia
Georgia + above      Nevada
Nevada + above       he’s out (prob win < 3%)

If McCain loses:     Next most important state for McCain
—————-     ————————————
Ohio                 he’s out (prob win < 3%)

Source: interactive simulations at
http://election-projection.net…


 
Obama has several different ways to win (0.00 / 0)
Plan A is Kerry + Ohio.

Plan B is Kerry + Iowa, Colorado, and either New Mexico or Nevada.

Plan C is Kerry + Iowa and Virginia.

Etc.


[ Parent ]  
McCain's Strategy Is To Drive The Media Narrative (4.00 / 2)
And then to have the media narrative drive the polls, and ultimately, the voters.  He is counting on Versailles to win it for him, and that’s why he was particularly freaked out as it began to dawn on him that Versailles was getting pretty darn comfortable with the new kid in town.  So he struck, and struck hard, and Obama really was not prepared.

But 3 things:

(1) Media narratives just aren’t that effective with 75-80%+ “wrong track” numbers.

(2) Obama has, belatedly begun to strike back.

(3) Paris Hilton made John McCain a laughingstock.

So, this is likely to be as far as this McCain offensive gets.  But another offensive could do more (particularly since the pundits are totally clueless about the state of the race, and will never accurately characterize McCain’s desperate flailing) if Obama doesn’t work hard to innoculate himself–and not with more moves to the right, but with some powerful narrative ads that (a) destroy McCain’s mythology and (b) define his own candidacy in compelling and crystal-clear terms.

“Senate passes expanded GI bill despite Bush, McCain opposition”


 
Donate to Open Left
ELECTION 2008 Presidential Forecast
Senate Forecast
House Forecast
PREMIUM AD

ADVERTISEMENTS

');

MENU

OpenLeft in your inbox!

 

Or, subscribe to each author individually.

OPTIMIZE MCCAIN About
Tips
McCain
John McCain
QUICK HITS
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search

OPENLEFT VIDEO WALL
Donna Edwards Thanks OpenLeft


Russ Feingold on the New FISA Legislation


Jon Conyers on Impeachment


Al Franken Thanks Blue Majority


FCC Commissioner Michael Copps on Pearl Jam, Net Neutrality


Darcy Burner on the FISA Legislation

More OpenLeft video…