Senate Forecast, 8/13: Where Has All The Competition Gone?

by: Chris Bowers

Wed Aug 13, 2008 at 14:51


Current Projection: Democratic Pickup of 5 seats

Republican Held: Democratic Pickups 5-6
State Type Democratic Republican Dem Cash Margin Polls
Lock D Pickups: 2
New Mexico Open T. Udall Pearce 542% D +26.3 3
Virginia Open Warner Gilmore 4370% D +24.0 3
Likely D Pickups: 2
Alaska Incumbent Begich Stevens* 48% D +10.4 5
New Hampshire Freshman Shaheen Sununu 42% D +10.7 3
Lean D Pickups: 2
Colorado Open M. Udall Schaffer 140% D +4.5 4
Lean R Pickups: 0-1
Minnesota Freshman Franken Coleman 58% R +8.3 3
Mississippi-B Special Musgrove Wicker 24% R +5.0 2
North Carolina Freshman Hagen Dole 45% R +8.4 5
Oregon Incumbent Merkley Smith 13% R +9.0 4
Texas Freshman Noriega Cornyn 10% R +9.0 3
Likely R Pickups: 0
Georgia Open Martin Chambliss 1% R +15.3 3
Idaho Open LaRocco Risch 27% R +12.5 2
Kentucky Incumbent Lunsford McConnell 15% R +11.0 3
Maine Incumbent Allen Collins 61% R +14.0 3

Republican Held, Uncompetitive Republican Locks (9): Alabama (Sessions), Kansas (Roberts), Mississippi-A (Cochran), Nebraska (Open, Johanns), Oklahoma (Inhofe), South Carolina (Graham), Tennessee (Alexander), Wyoming-1 (Barrasso), Wyoming-2 (Enzi)

Democratic Held: Democratic Losses, 0-1
State Type Democrat Republican Dem Cash Margin Polls
Toss-up Losses: 0-1
Louisiana Incumbent Landrieu Kennedy 204% D +1.3 3
Likely D Losses: 0
New Jersey Incumbent Lautenberg Zimmer 315% D +11.0 4

Democratic Held, Uncompetitive Democratic Locks (10): Arkansas (Pryor), Delaware (Biden), Illinois (Durbin), Iowa (Harkin), Massachusetts (Kerry), Michigan (Levin), Montana (Baucus), Rhode Island (Reed), South Dakota (Johnson), West Virginia (Rockerfeller)

Analysis in the extended entry.

Chris Bowers :: Senate Forecast, 8/13: Where Has All The Competition Gone?
In the last two weeks, there have been new polls from virtually every single state in this update. Here are the category changes:

  • Alaska upgrades from “Lean Democrat” to “Likely Democrat”
  • Georgia upgrades from “Lock Republican” to “Likely Republican”
  • Kentucky downgrades from “Lean Republican” to “Likely Republican”
  • Louisiana downgrades from “Lean Democrat” to “Toss-up”
  • North Carolina upgrades from “Likely Republican” to “Lean Republican”
  • Texas upgrades from “Likely Republican” to “Lean Republican”

Two things strike me about this forecast. First, the almost total lack of competitive Senate campaigns is interesting, even if it makes for a boring forecast. Only two campaigns, Louisiana and Mississippi-B, are currently within the margin of error, according to Pollster.com. Further, only two other campaigns, Oregon and Colorado, and within twice the margin of error according to Pollster.com. Virtually every Senate race, including four Democratic pickups, are virtual locks right now.

Second, it is almost impossible to see a Democratic path to 60 right now. Even if no Democratic incumbents lose, reaching 60 even with Lieberman requires winning four of the “Lean” or “Likely” Republican seats. If you can see four victories in there, you are a much more optimistic person than I am. Now, with 60 votes probably unreachable, we should instead be focusing on picking up as many good Democrats as possible, rather than as many Democrats as possible. In other words, if we can squeeze out a win in one of Minnesota, Maine, or Oregon, right now that it probably our best play.

* = Stevens is virtually guaranteed to lose, pending the outcome of his primary. While he now has a self-financing primary challenger, he also leads his primary by about 40 points. If Stevens were to not be on the ballot, the complexion of this campaign would change dramatically.  


Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Synergy–Or Lack Thereof (4.00 / 2)
Although the primary onus is clearly on the candidate themselves, I think that the three progressive Dem chances you point to–OR, MN and ME–would all be a lot closer if Obama were running a clearly progressive campaign, articulating a sharply different vision, with solid substantive positions that GOP senators would find difficult to embrace as blurring strategies, and which the Dems could enthusiastically run with.

Shorter version: I, too, would like a pony.

“You know what they say — those of us who fail history… doomed to repeat it in summer school.” — Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3


 
I'd rather have a kitten (0.00 / 0)
Ponies are high maintenance.

[ Parent ]  
It's A MAGIC Pony (4.00 / 1)
No maintenance involved.

“You know what they say — those of us who fail history… doomed to repeat it in summer school.” — Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 6, Episode 3

[ Parent ]  
I think looking at this purely at the state level (0.00 / 0)
misses part of the picture. I think it’s possible to pick up rather more than the current projection, and probably also less, if the national mood swings — and the national mood is a fickle thing, reacting more the external events than anything we can directly influence. True, many of these races are slipping, but this seems to be concurrent with slippage nationally: Rasmussen (and others?) found the party ID gap narrowing, and Obama has also slipped somewhat — where Obama went from a significant lead to a narrow one, many of these Democratic Senate challengers went from somewhat behind to way behind. If the national mood goes back in the other direction, though, a rising tide lifts all boats, and we could get right back to where we were. (Nothing you can count on, of course, but it’s definitely there as a possibility.)

 
A very minor mistype in the "Lean D" collumn (0.00 / 0)
You give an estimate of 2 pick-up’s instead of 1.

Not trying to be critical or so as I’m addicted to these projections of yours. Just thought you’d like to know.

Keep up the good work!


 
I really want to win MN (0.00 / 0)
Coleman is a particularly bad Senator – much worse than Graham or Collins.     If we are to expand beyond the 5 pickups we seem to have (AK, VA, NH, NM & CO) I want it to be MN.  

Al Franken needs to be seen as the serious candidate he is.   I think we really missed an opportunity by not naming Franken as the keynote speaker.   That would have raised his national stature and enhanced is image greatly.    

I also remain optimistic that Hagan will run a good race against Dole in NC.    Dole is also a particularly bad Senator.    Unfortunately, NC seems to like bad Senators.    


 
Alright, well "almost impossible to see 60"? Hmmm, perhaps not: (0.00 / 0)
In many many of these states, there exists a large African-American population.  In the last election (2004) in NC there was a 26% of the vote as AA.  In the latest Hagen-Dole poll, the pollster included on 19% AA in the sample.  So that whittles the race down to within under five points right there.

The truth is, we don’t know.  What’s making folks like Dole and Wicker worried – and, thus, missing the RNC convention to continue campaigning back home – is the fear of a (in my opinion) likely DELUGE of black voters in this general election…..for obvious reasons.

FWIW, in my opinion, those incumbent Republicans in red states with large AA populations, like Liddy Dole in NC, they better have at least a poll lead of EIGHT percentage points prior to November 4th, becasue if they don’t, they will be washed away in the tsunami of AA voters on election day.  And they fucking know this, that’s why they are panicking and the GOP is more worried about a 60 vote senate than we are in anticipating one.

It may happen.  Does anyone here honestly believe that North Carolina’s black vote will stay static with 2004’s 26%?  HA!  I think it’ll be about 33% of NC’s vote this time.  I think Dole is gonzo.

For some reason, it seems that Obama has some pathological and deep-seated psychological need for Republicans to like him.  Seriously.  It’s weird.


 
Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.

As an anti-spam measure, there is a 24-hour waiting period after registering before new users can comment.
blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search